Skip to content
×
Try PRO Free Today!
BiggerPockets Pro offers you a comprehensive suite of tools and resources
Market and Deal Finder Tools
Deal Analysis Calculators
Property Management Software
Exclusive discounts to Home Depot, RentRedi, and more
$0
7 days free
$828/yr or $69/mo when billed monthly.
$390/yr or $32.5/mo when billed annually.
7 days free. Cancel anytime.
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Golan Corshidi

Golan Corshidi has started 11 posts and replied 52 times.

Hey Victor, Thanks for the reply. 

That makes sense it seems much less competitive so easier to negotiate. Are there issues that you think you should avoid regardless of potential for discount? 

Hey,

I am curious if any of you have found good deals on the market that were listed on the MLS for a long time (90+ days).

I find that the best deals on the market are usually newly listed (less than a week on the market) and usually the deals that haven't sold have significant issues with them.

What are the reasons that you think homes sit on the market for a long time and how do you navigate the issues to make a deal that works for you? 

Post: Cleveland and/or Columbus area

Golan CorshidiPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Posts 52
  • Votes 38
Quote from @Elisha Johnston:
Quote from @Golan Corshidi:

hey Elisha, I live in San Francisco and just bought a triplex and Cleveland for 140k that's cash flowing well. I think there are some good deals out there. Consider doing section-8 if you end up buying in some of the rougher areas. 

That’s actually very similar to what Im trying to do, I’ve heard a number of good things with section 8. Could I follow up via inbox? Definitely curious about your approach to this 

 Of course! I’ll look out for your message 

Post: Cleveland and/or Columbus area

Golan CorshidiPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Posts 52
  • Votes 38

hey Elisha, I live in San Francisco and just bought a triplex and Cleveland for 140k that's cash flowing well. I think there are some good deals out there. Consider doing section-8 if you end up buying in some of the rougher areas. 

Quote from @Bill B.:

You have a kick butt deal, if you generate ha;f the cash flow you’re planning on you’ll be ok. So it won’t matter if you forgot things like management fees (or the value and costs of your mistakes if you plan to self manage.) Advertising (photos and listings.) turn over costs, snow removal, and those kind of things. The big deals will be vacancy, capex and appliances. (3 water heaters, stoves, fridges, microwaves?, washers? dryers?, dishwashers? ac units, furnaces, etc etc.) best case you only have 15 of those, not 21 or 27. With an average life spans of 6 years you’ve got 2-3 per year. I know, you have “repairs”already. But that’s going to be toilets, faucets, leaks, garage doors, etc etc. 

I’m not saying you have a bad deal, or I wouldn’t buy it if it was located somewhere warmer without income tax. (Ps. Subtract income tax and tax prep from your cash flow. :-)) Run 2025 through quicken and at the end of the year you’ll have real numbers and you can come back to this post and see how close you were. Hopefully you’ve increased rents and your above expectations. 


Thank you Bill. ill add the other expenses and report back in a year! 

Quote from @JD Martin:
Quote from @Golan Corshidi:

Hey all,

I used all the advice and wisdom from these channels and decided to do my first deal out of state. I would love your feedback on how you all think I did. 

I live in San Francisco and bought a triplex in Cleveland, Ohio in a Class C neighborhood. Based on my numbers, it shows a 45% cash-on-cash return. That seems way too high. Am I missing something?  Maybe I need to budget more for tenant default, vacancy, maintenance, or something else. 

Background:

I had never been to Cleveland. I did extensive research on the market and based on purchase prices and rents in the area it seemed like a good investment. I bought an almost rent-ready triplex sight unseen in September and got it fully rented within 60 days of closing. 

Numbers:

Purchase Price: $140,000

Cash Invested: $42,000

Income:

Unit 1: $1075 + utilities. Unit 2: $950 + utilities. Unit 3: $800 + utilities 

Total: $2,825

Expenses:

PITI: $980

General Maintenance: $50/month

Maintenance Reserve: $143/month 

Other Fees (admin stuff like LLC, registration fees, etc): $70/month

Total:  $1,243.

Monthly Cash Flow: $1,582

Cap Rate: 13.5%

Cash on Cash Return: 45%

I appreciate any feedback or advice on this deal as I am just starting. 

Congrats on at least taking action.

You've got nothing budgeted for vacancy that I can see; it depends on how much turnover there is in your market and what your prices are like compared to the rest of the market, but most people would budget 1 month of vacancy/year/unit. In your case that would be $2825/year or about $235/month.

If your place is not fully rehabbed, you have nothing budgeted for capital expenses. Roof, HVAC, water heaters, flooring, etc. You're budgeting less than $2400 for the year for maintenance and repairs for 3 units and that seems unlikely. Who cuts the grass? Where I am, and we have a lot of units under contract for lawn care, we still spend about $1000 per SFH on annual lawn care. There's HVAC servicing once a year on each unit. Assorted things.

Realistically, on a triplex that's not fully rehabbed, without assuming tenant damages I'd be factoring in roof, flooring, HVAC at minimum on nothing more than a 10 year cycle (5 is safer). So let's say $8k for a roof, $10k for new HVAC, $10k on flooring, that's $28k/10 = $2800/yr or about $235/month for just those things.

$235+235 = $470/month, $1582-$470 = $1112 = 33% COC annual.

Either way, you're renting out a place for $2800 that you paid $140k for. That's hitting the 2% "rule", and if you can maintain regular rent on that you've really hit a home run in today's market. Most people are struggling to get 1%. 


 Thank you JD. I appreciate the feedback. For the anticipated cap ex, would you just put that monthly in some reserve fund and wait for that to come up eventually? 

Hey all,

I used all the advice and wisdom from these channels and decided to do my first deal out of state. I would love your feedback on how you all think I did. 

I live in San Francisco and bought a triplex in Cleveland, Ohio in a Class C neighborhood. Based on my numbers, it shows a 45% cash-on-cash return. That seems way too high. Am I missing something?  Maybe I need to budget more for tenant default, vacancy, maintenance, or something else. 

Background:

I had never been to Cleveland. I did extensive research on the market and based on purchase prices and rents in the area it seemed like a good investment. I bought an almost rent-ready triplex sight unseen in September and got it fully rented within 60 days of closing. 

Numbers:

Purchase Price: $140,000

Cash Invested: $42,000

Income:

Unit 1: $1075 + utilities. Unit 2: $950 + utilities. Unit 3: $800 + utilities 

Total: $2,825

Expenses:

PITI: $980

General Maintenance: $50/month

Maintenance Reserve: $143/month 

Other Fees (admin stuff like LLC, registration fees, etc): $70/month

Total:  $1,243.

Monthly Cash Flow: $1,582

Cap Rate: 13.5%

Cash on Cash Return: 45%

I appreciate any feedback or advice on this deal as I am just starting. 

Post: Buying a Property with Dual Agency

Golan CorshidiPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Posts 52
  • Votes 38

Hey all!

I am purchasing a property in Ohio and since I am unrepresented by an agent I am debating having the listing agent represent me as well.

What do you think are the pros and cons of purchasing a property with dual agency? 

Quote from @Bob Stevens:
Quote from @Golan Corshidi:

Hey all!

I am looking at an opportunity to invest in Cleveland, Ohio and I am looking to connect with a local property manager who has experience working with mid-term rentals. 

Looking forward to connecting! 

NOT a good idea, why mid term? Now you need staff to be 100% reliable, not easy there. Also need to furnish. At the end of the day maybe you make 2% more then you would with yearly. Be happy with your 10- 14% net and move on. Oh I assumed you are a cash buyer

Good luck 



Yeah, so far it seems like the juice isn't worth the squeeze with the added work, turnover, etc but that's based on a lot of assumptions Im making from afar. Hoping a local manager can show the returns might be worth it but not convinced yet. You think long term rental is the move?