Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Gary L Wallman

Gary L Wallman has started 3 posts and replied 415 times.

Post: Allow Dutch German shepherd dog in rental property?

Gary L WallmanPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Beavercreek OH
  • Posts 422
  • Votes 972
Quote from @Lara Thatcher:

Hi all, I’m in a bit of a predicament. I have very qualified prospective tenants but they have a Dutch German Shepard dog. Female, 54 lbs, vaccinated, potty trained and “very sweet”. I’ve only ever rented to people with small dogs in the past, so I’m not sure if this is a good idea or not. The prospective tenants themselves are lovely and have no issues qualifying, but I am seeing online that the general consensus is to never rent to people who have a German shepherd, because those dogs are prone to biting and aggression. I was wondering if this is different because it’s not a pure German shepherd, or if it’s all the same. My insurance said they don’t cover German shepherds, but said the tenant can always get renters insurance. BUT, they also said that if the dog were to injure someone, I could be sued too regardless if the tenant has insurance.

I’m not sure what to do. I would hate to lose great, qualified tenants just on the *what if* scenario of their dog injuring someone. They say it’s a sweet dog with no history of bad behavior. What has been your experience renting to people who have a restricted dog breed?


Should I rent to them? Would you? Also, does anyone have experience with mixed shephards? 

Under 20 pounds. Over 20 pounds. Face to face meeting. Huh?
You own the home. You have everything to lose!

 No, No, No. Hard pass.Why risk your home and your assets? An absolute no brainer.

Post: Benefits of Buying New Construction

Gary L WallmanPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Beavercreek OH
  • Posts 422
  • Votes 972
Quote from @Phillip Lebron:

@Gary L Wallman do you think this applies to all markets? My wife and I are moving from Virginia to Palmetto FL which is beginning to develop and the new Construction is cheaper than almost everything else


 Phillip,

In most of coastal Florida, new construction is only cheaper because it is typically farther away from the beach. This is definitely true for Palmetto IMHO.

Best of luck on your move.

Gary 

Quote from @Josh Humbert:

Like the title mentions, I am a chronic over thinker and know that I could spend the next 2 years learning every possible approach to BRRRR, the details, the risks, etc. I am a pretty resourceful thinker but I cannot help that whenever my brain hears "5 things you MUST know before your first BRRRR deal" I can't help but read the content, research each of those topics, etc. Ultimately, I know I just need to get started and over time my goal can become to improve my strategy with every deal.

I don't want to live on the sidelines lol. 

With that being said- Any advice/thoughts on taking a less profitable deal (ie- leaving money in the deal after refinancing to get started)?  If so, how can I use my willingness to be less profitable to my advantage? 


 Josh,

I'm a pretty seasoned investor with over 150 doors. Right now I'm finishing rehab on a couple of homes I was going to rent. They are going on the sales block instead. Why? Simply stated, they have increased in value so much that I can get a better return by simply putting the money in a CD.

I'm also selling all my maintenance intensive properties, primarily for the same reason. Receive top-dollar now and reinvest if and when values drop. Save money on constant service calls in the meantime.

That being said, I just advised my youngest son in his acquisition of his first rental. Return is lower then we'd like, but we view it as free College tuition as a Real Estate major.

Go for it. Don't go crazy and use all your cash, but dive in. The only regret I have in my real estate history are the properties I didn't buy.

Gary

Post: Getting your realtor license is much like getting your insurance license. Yes?

Gary L WallmanPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Beavercreek OH
  • Posts 422
  • Votes 972
Quote from @Joe S.:

 So a number of years ago, I obtained my license to sell health and life insurance. I work for AFLAC for a time and it was a whole lot of door knocking.  basically  prospecting. Later I worked for another company and it was a whole lot of prospecting and trying to chase down potential customers as well. All of which was 100% commission based. ( I no longer sell insurance.)

Being 100% commission is a job in my opinion. being a realtor, for some people could be a good income depending on how hard they work being a insurance sales person can be a good income depending on how hard they work. Neither job equates to owning real estate. Both jobs if you made a lot of money you could invest into real estate.

I had one gentleman tell me four years ago that he was a real estate investor because he just got his realtor license. I didn’t even take the time to correct him .


 Joe,

Both tests are similar in that they'll check your mastery of knowledge you'll never use, so that the State can make money and the existing companies can keep out competition. 

Gary

Post: Trying to figure out which option for electric water heater is best.

Gary L WallmanPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Beavercreek OH
  • Posts 422
  • Votes 972
Quote from @Juan Mora:
Quote from @Gary L Wallman:
Quote from @Juan Mora:

I have experience in residential HVAC/Plumbing installations and the estimate provided is within the ballpark for a legitimate, contractor who operates a profitable business with well trained technicians.  Not your cheap side job guy who will do it for $300 a sixpack of beer.

I am sure you can find a cheap guy who will not give you any warranty for half the price just like you can for flooring, kitchen, hvac, painting and landscape.

The proposal estimate shown above is from a software company called Service Titan.  Only top notch companies use that software, all the cheap companies who don't have real shops or employees just use pen, paper or a free software. I think the lower cost option would be just fine for a basic tank.

AS homeowners or flippers, sometimes we have no idea how much things should cost and have no idea how to run a service/contracting business.  Thats why we automatically say it should only costs XXXX amount. 

I encourage you to get another quote from a reputable company and see whats their ballpark. If you really want the cheap of the cheapest like many flippers; expect to pay cash to a guy who will do it on a saturday but ZERO warranty if something goes wrong. 

est of luck in your repairs



 Juan,

Almost 5k for a water heater replacement? Sorry but your dead wrong. I own 150 plus doors, have replaced  dozens of hot water heaters and haven't spent more than 800 bucks, labor included. The exception being my personal residence which required an 80 gallon tank and that was still half of what this contractor is quoting. Regardless of his fancy software, he still seems like a crook to me. IMHO.

Additionally I would fire the property manager. Likely crook #2, in my opinion.

Further, who replaces a non leaking water heater because "it's at the end of it's useful life"? A prophet of some sort? Give me a break.

Respectfully,

Gary


 Congratulations on the 150 doors, thats a great accomplishment.  I have no idea how to even get to 10 doors yet and that's why I am here learning the biz.  I only have one rental worth over $1mil in sunny Carlsbad CA and a $900k home in Chula Vista. 

I don't know about flipping yet but I do have experience in contracting and know how to operate a multi million dollar business.  There's contractors for all types of customers; we deal with high end customers in La Jolla and Rancho Santa Fe.  It all depends on the level of service one needs or wants. 

Again, theres a cheap contractors for cheap customers.  There is nothing wrong with being cheap, price conscious, budget friendly or the most popular term "reasonable" or  whatever you want to call it.  How much is reasonable?

We see it everyday and theres contractors for every customers.  

That does not make me wrong; just different opinions.  

Again, in my opinion, that's a fair price for a legitimate, licensed and insured company.  Not your weekend side job guy.  

Please don't try to make this between ME and YOU because I have no idea who you are, or what you do for a living.  I am here to learn flipping. 


 Juan,

Of course not, not looking to insult anybody. Just stating my experience. Your world in California is much different than Ohio. What goes as normal for CA prices would never fly here. The prices I quoted are for licensed and insured professionals in my area. Never suggested otherwise.

Good luck in the future with your flipping endeavors. I've done about 20 and they have all been challenging. Never had CA type appreciation to help out. Hope that resumes out there quickly for you guys,

Respectfully, Gary 

Post: Trying to figure out which option for electric water heater is best.

Gary L WallmanPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Beavercreek OH
  • Posts 422
  • Votes 972
Quote from @Juan Mora:

I have experience in residential HVAC/Plumbing installations and the estimate provided is within the ballpark for a legitimate, contractor who operates a profitable business with well trained technicians.  Not your cheap side job guy who will do it for $300 a sixpack of beer.

I am sure you can find a cheap guy who will not give you any warranty for half the price just like you can for flooring, kitchen, hvac, painting and landscape.

The proposal estimate shown above is from a software company called Service Titan.  Only top notch companies use that software, all the cheap companies who don't have real shops or employees just use pen, paper or a free software. I think the lower cost option would be just fine for a basic tank.

AS homeowners or flippers, sometimes we have no idea how much things should cost and have no idea how to run a service/contracting business.  Thats why we automatically say it should only costs XXXX amount. 

I encourage you to get another quote from a reputable company and see whats their ballpark. If you really want the cheap of the cheapest like many flippers; expect to pay cash to a guy who will do it on a saturday but ZERO warranty if something goes wrong. 

est of luck in your repairs



 Juan,

Almost 5k for a water heater replacement? Sorry but your dead wrong. I own 150 plus doors, have replaced  dozens of hot water heaters and haven't spent more than 800 bucks, labor included. The exception being my personal residence which required an 80 gallon tank and that was still half of what this contractor is quoting. Regardless of his fancy software, he still seems like a crook to me. IMHO.

Additionally I would fire the property manager. Likely crook #2, in my opinion.

Further, who replaces a non leaking water heater because "it's at the end of it's useful life"? A prophet of some sort? Give me a break.

Respectfully,

Gary

Post: Tampa and Rising Sea Levels

Gary L WallmanPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Beavercreek OH
  • Posts 422
  • Votes 972
Quote from @Aaron Dixon:

Hey All,

A family friend of mine has instilled the fear of Tampa as a whole being a poor long term investment due to Sea Level Rise (SLR). It seems without a significant investment into preventative measures Tampa and the surrounding area will lose much of its value amongst other things. 

While I bought my first property in Riverview this time last year I’m now hesitant to even continue analyzing properties. Simply looking to get others thoughts on the matter. 

Thanks to all!


 Aaron,

In 1973, when I graduated high school, all the talk was about global cooling and the forthcoming mini ice-age. Time magazine had a cover trying to scare us all to death over our impending doom due to freezing.

50 years later it's global warming err. . . I mean climate change. The fact is, climate is weather and yes it changes. It changes primarily due to solar activity, which man has no control over. It is cyclical in nature.

The idea that man-made warming is the cause has never, and will likely ever, been proved. There is big dollars in the scare, however. Guys like Al Gore have gotten wildly rich while espousing this tripe. Meanwhile his carbon footprint is huge. He flies home to his gigantic energy eating house in his private jet preaching the ice caps were going to disappear many years ago. Why any of these guys are listened to with anything but disdain is beyond my comprehension.

Respectfully,

Gary  

Post: Would love some Floridian Advice!

Gary L WallmanPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Beavercreek OH
  • Posts 422
  • Votes 972
Quote from @Timothy W.:

This is the most accurate statement on investing in Florida I've seen.  I have a son with autism so I live near NASA where autism rates are high and thus services for him are the best in frankly the Eastern half of the US.  I like the particular community I'm in for now for what he needs, but I will probably choose St. Augustine at some point.  I'll take an aged port in a 200-year-old masonry wine grotto over a margarita at a tiki bar.  Prices are high right now but they are stagnating while rents are continuing to rise.  

I saw your comment re the Midwest and I get where your mind is at. One thing about the Midwest that is an advantage over Florida is the weather isn't out to destroy everything you own, generally. Even "good" weather here eats everything. Construction has risen to combat that but it still exists. Frankly if you had a modern Florida built house in the Midwest it'd last forever, through tornadoes and all. You might also want to be wary of HOAs. We don't have local zoning like most states. In fact the most recent update to our building code took away a lot of local code authority. What we do have to make up for that is a robust HOA bylaws.


 Timothy,

Not only the weather but the salt air. I had a personal Gulf front home in PCB. When I got tired of the drive I sold it. I did consider keeping it an an STR, but my experience with the maintenance convinced me otherwise. It's nearly unbelievable.

During 4 years of ownership I went through 8 barbecue grills that rusted out (all stainless steel). Stainless steel deck screws rusting away. HDMI cables corroding IN THE WALLS. Door knobs falling off. Had to replace a two year old heat pump unit. Outdoor furniture lasted one year, even expensive aluminum and rattan. Outdoor speakers and surveillance cameras were impossible to keep working. Had to replace outside electrical panel as well.

Literally had a $30 an hour handyman work nearly full-time at the house just trying to stay ahead of the corrosion and humidity issues. Not to mention 3 hurricanes in 4 years.

Now I own a lake front on fresh water near my home in Ohio. LOL

Gary

Post: flip rehabs/returns - how do i compete?

Gary L WallmanPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Beavercreek OH
  • Posts 422
  • Votes 972
Quote from @Ronald Ty:
Quote from @Gary L Wallman:
Quote from @Ronald Ty:
Quote from @Gary L Wallman:
Quote from @Ronald Ty:
Quote from @Gary L Wallman:
Quote from @Ronald Ty:

i am having trouble competing with other flippers. i try to do things the right way (pull permits) & use contractors/hvac/plumbing/electricians who, i feel, give me the best bang for the buck. and we all know the cost of things, and labor, have risen dramatically lately.

i pay cash for my homes and hit the sales price i anticipated beforehand.  

the problem i am having is getting my rehab numbers in line. i feel other investors are doing rentals or doing some/all the work themselves and/or not pulling permits. 

i should also mention, i do not need to flip. i can live off the returns i get in my bond/stock portfolio (w/ a lot less taxes paid). however, i like to flip 1x/year to keep me from getting bored and get that satisfaction from "working" (i retired 4 years ago). 

and no, i am not interested in doing rentals. :)


 Scott,

These from the ground up flips, particularly with structural changes, are what nightmares are made of. Especially true if your using contractors who likes to charge the way yours do. I have done many higher end finishes in flips and your numbers shock me. Not to say your wrong, inflation in building materials has been crazy.

After doing dozens of flips, I now avoid any of these rebuild from the ground up stuff. If I can't make it appealing by kitchen, bath, paint, flooring and some fancy lighting, I don't do it. Too expensive and way too risky for the dollars expended, to the return.

I've also learned most buyers look at fit and finish more than the houses bones.

Gary

Thanks for the feedback. Agree to disagree. Dont feel I'm being ripped off. And creating value raises the arv. Spend $ to make $. I have done very few cosmetic flips. I haven't really ever gotten crazy returns. It's better just to put it in a stock mutual fund Roth Ira and call it a day.  Everybody thinks it's easy. I'm here to tell the newbs it is not. Again, this is for educational purposes. 

 Not disagreeing with your idea that it takes money to make money. Just disagreeing with your rate of return, which, I believe you were concerned about in your post. I've learned, after being in the flip business and the car business, I can't compete with the car manufacturer or the Real Estate developer. If I have to rebuild a car or a house, it's usually a loser for me. Real money is made by making an ugly house look pretty, not leveling garage floors. IMHO.

Respectfully,

Gary 

Thanks, Gary. Just curious, what kind of return do you get on your flips assuming if you would be paying cash for instance ? 

 Scott,

I never use borrowed money. I'm in the Midwest so returns aren't spectacular. I used to shoot for between 25 and 40 percent cash on cash return in 3 to 4 months. The amount of work it took made me into a buy and hold guy.

Now own 150+ LTR doors.

Gary

I don't get it. How is a 25-40% return not spectacular ? Especially in 4 months? Compounded (if you do 3 a year), that was/is 75-120%! 

 Cheap houses in SW Ohio. Bigger percentage but smaller dollars.

Post: flip rehabs/returns - how do i compete?

Gary L WallmanPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Beavercreek OH
  • Posts 422
  • Votes 972
Quote from @Ronald Ty:
Quote from @Gary L Wallman:
Quote from @Ronald Ty:
Quote from @Gary L Wallman:
Quote from @Ronald Ty:

i am having trouble competing with other flippers. i try to do things the right way (pull permits) & use contractors/hvac/plumbing/electricians who, i feel, give me the best bang for the buck. and we all know the cost of things, and labor, have risen dramatically lately.

i pay cash for my homes and hit the sales price i anticipated beforehand.  

the problem i am having is getting my rehab numbers in line. i feel other investors are doing rentals or doing some/all the work themselves and/or not pulling permits. 

i should also mention, i do not need to flip. i can live off the returns i get in my bond/stock portfolio (w/ a lot less taxes paid). however, i like to flip 1x/year to keep me from getting bored and get that satisfaction from "working" (i retired 4 years ago). 

and no, i am not interested in doing rentals. :)


 Scott,

These from the ground up flips, particularly with structural changes, are what nightmares are made of. Especially true if your using contractors who likes to charge the way yours do. I have done many higher end finishes in flips and your numbers shock me. Not to say your wrong, inflation in building materials has been crazy.

After doing dozens of flips, I now avoid any of these rebuild from the ground up stuff. If I can't make it appealing by kitchen, bath, paint, flooring and some fancy lighting, I don't do it. Too expensive and way too risky for the dollars expended, to the return.

I've also learned most buyers look at fit and finish more than the houses bones.

Gary

Thanks for the feedback. Agree to disagree. Dont feel I'm being ripped off. And creating value raises the arv. Spend $ to make $. I have done very few cosmetic flips. I haven't really ever gotten crazy returns. It's better just to put it in a stock mutual fund Roth Ira and call it a day.  Everybody thinks it's easy. I'm here to tell the newbs it is not. Again, this is for educational purposes. 

 Not disagreeing with your idea that it takes money to make money. Just disagreeing with your rate of return, which, I believe you were concerned about in your post. I've learned, after being in the flip business and the car business, I can't compete with the car manufacturer or the Real Estate developer. If I have to rebuild a car or a house, it's usually a loser for me. Real money is made by making an ugly house look pretty, not leveling garage floors. IMHO.

Respectfully,

Gary 

Thanks, Gary. Just curious, what kind of return do you get on your flips assuming if you would be paying cash for instance ? 

 Scott,

I never use borrowed money. I'm in the Midwest so returns aren't spectacular. I used to shoot for between 25 and 40 percent cash on cash return in 3 to 4 months. The amount of work it took made me into a buy and hold guy.

Now own 150+ LTR doors.

Gary