How did this all turn out?
I'm going through a very similar situation with a very unreasonable and threatening tenant.
i have some challenges you didn't...
The mold test my tenant had professionally done in March showed moderate levels downstairs and high levels upstairs. The chart levels were in reference to someone with CIRS condition. I didn't see any outside test results. March is very wet here.
After a Jan roof leak in the garage he requested a remediation company and a environmental hygienist.
I did not hire a remediation company . I had my contractor fix the leak, pull out the wet and moldy drywall and clean the effected area with moldicide. 2 sqft of moldy area was found and maybe 10 sqft of drywall was removed from each garages in this duplex. Other tenent is happy and healthy.
The March tests had higher mold levels upstairs where the shower is, not downstairs where the leak was.
I've always responded in a timely manner to him. I did not run out and hire three different specialty disciplines when he requested it. He claims the whole house is filled with mold and was before the garage leak.
I had an elderly couple living there for a year before him and they did not experience any symptoms that he is having.
He had covid in November last year.
He thinks the house made him susceptible before we ever had the roof leak.
I asked him if he believes this home is unsafe for him why hasn't he moved? He said it takes time to build a case and takes weeks for to get anybody out here.
He gave me no notice of dissatisfaction after we were there and corrected the problem in Jan.
He gave me no notice of withholding April rent.
He requested that I pay for a hotel, have all of his things tested or replaced, and reimburse him for all his medical tests.
I offered him an alternative home I have available immediately for him. Freshly updated and all clean inside and he refused. He wants me to pay for his hotel instead.
He applied for another apartment. I was contacted by the apartment management company today and they are looking for my landlord reference.
I told him we should have a mutual termination agreement prior to my answering their questions because he's late with April rent and I have started the eviction process. I'm basically offering a clean landlord reference in exchange for taking my offer of keeping April rent towards hotel, returning the full security deposit, and allowing him out of the lease early that has a 2-month cancellation fee.
I contacted my attorney but he retired last year so I have no legal counsel yet.
There's a certified letter waiting for me to pick up at the post office. Yeah me.
The stress is brutal. He screamed at me for 30 minutes, called me a slumlord and told me I should burn my building down.
Your advice?
Gary