Originally posted by @Courtney Radmall:
Hello everyone! WE have purchased our first short term rental that we are using as a vacation rental and are currently living in it while we renovate it and get it ready. We will be renting it out starting this July and I am doing some research on what type of home insurance is the best.
Most of the articles I find come from expensive insurance companies blogs so I don't feel like I am getting an unbiased answer in my research. So I wanted to ask on here and see what you all think.
Thanks in advance!
I’m curious what insurance deductible people here have been getting. My quote from Proper doesn’t have much difference in premium for $10k deductible vs $1k deductible, thus making me inclined to get the $1k deductible for max safety. But then the ultimate question becomes - if you have a $1k deductible - do you find yourself filing claims for small-ish amounts like $1200 frequently? And do your premiums rise if you file too many claims?
Finally, I’d like to add to this discussion by mentioning that insurance is a very important asset and you shouldn’t just jump on a company bc the insurance benefits sound great or the quote sounds great. The most important thing when choosing insurance is the stability of the insurer. After all, a low quote or great benefits are worthless if they can’t afford to pay out when you need it the most!
Good responsible insurers are well diversified with policies written all over the country. Smaller insurers may be over-concentrated in one area. And for example if that area is North Carolina, they may go bankrupt when a hurricane hits NC & does billions of dollars in flooding damage across the state.
That said, I’d recommend everyone go to AMBest.com and check the rating of your insurance company before signing up for insurance. It’s free and takes about 10 seconds on AMBest.com. AM Best has been rating insurance companies since long before your house was even built. Probably. They’ve been around since 1899.
Anyway, Proper is backed by Lloyd’s of London which is highly rated for financial stability by AM Best. All of the big insurers (Geico, Nationwide, USAA, etc) receive AM Best ratings and have for many, many years. Some of the other companies mentioned on this thread are so new that they don’t appear when you search on AMBest.com - I would be wary of using those insurers unless they are backed by a highly-rated underwriter as Proper is. Just my 2 cents. Better to be safe than paying thousands of dollars in premiums to an insurer that later goes bankrupt when you need them the most.