@Scott Price Thanks for creating a great discussion. There is a wealth of knowledge here and experienced investors represented.
Your question was "which is better?" well I have found that it depends on what your GOALS are and how much TIME you have.
My wife and I are currently living in a duplex we purchased and it has been such a fun project for us. We have loved doing the rehab and project over time will be a huge equity builder for our family. BUT we have the time to do this bc we are young and don't have kids yet. We also have time to grow our wealth by holding onto the asset. Our goal is also to build a portfolio of properties in our city to be able to provide housing for folks that we come into contact with through our non-profits.
On the other hand, I also participate in syndication deals with my network of investors bc I find it to be a great strategy for investors looking for solid passive income and a relatively easy way to multiply their money. It's not a jackpot type investment strategy but it does provide avenues to allow you to continue living the type of lifestyle you wish to live.
Feel free to reach out if you want to talk more.
Cheers!
Ellishammond.com