Hey Linden,
The issue you are experiencing is common for most investors in the US right now... We need to see cap rate expansion in most markets that have seen a huge value run-up really since 2014 ish.
I am an acquisitions analyst at a real estate investment advisory firm in Denver called Tangible Wealth Solutions. We specialize in helping clients find cash flow and appreciation out-of-state/ outside of Colorado (no cash flow here).
We are targeting two markets in the midwest and are able to find strong cash flow and great appreciation prospects. The "1% Rule" is a great benchmark to determine if something is likely to cash flow or not - If the monthly rent is 1% or greater of the purchase price, cash flow is more likely than not.
If you would like to schedule a call, I'd be happy to discuss our investment philosophy with you and go over our two markets of focus. We deal with clients from all over the country so you being in Idaho isn't a limiting factor.
Thanks!