The property is in Pottstown... don't really like to give specifics on a forum. :0
Tenant screening is simple, when I'm in town, but I'm not... which means hiring someone in my stead.
Here's what I've discovered so far, of who I've interviewed:
Buxmont- Small, Mom & Pop, but responsive, with the lowest commission (50% of one month's rent) and lowest % (6%/month). One of the first to respond back, both to email/phone. This company doesn't have the doodads (Appfolio/ACH, etc) but they seem to get it done nonetheless.
Local Leasing Company- Bigger company, very professional, used to dealing with A class properties, and offers A class management, with the fees to go with it. $250 initial inspection fee, $125 first year fee, 1 month's commission for 1 year lease, more if it's a longer lease, 10% monthly management fee, $500 eviction fee. I did the math, and in the first year, I'd be paying $1093 more than Buxmont. The problem is, my property is B class, and can't afford A class management... doesn't make much sense. That being said, I do appreciate customer service. They were also quick/responsive, helpful, and have all the doodads.
Del Val- Had trouble answering my questions, didn't email back, weren't very helpful. They actually became quite defensive and started asking ME questions. I requested a PM agreement/fee schedule and never received them. They took themselves quickly out of the running.
Onyx- Answered the questions, polite, but never responded to emails/were similar to Del Val.
Big Realty- this is my current management company, who I inherited, which means I had to re-interview them. I emailed, since they are usually very adept at email, and here's the response I received, verbatim:
"There is no way I am taking an hour to answer all those questions. I have clients with 50+ units who have never asked me for something like that. Thanks." That is what the OWNER said. So, obviously... I had to pass on them. They also have the exorbitant fees-- 10% monthly, 10% of any repairs must be paid to them, 1 month's commission fee, renewal fees, fees fees fees.
I hope this is helpful to people in Pottstown/surrounding areas. These guys operate in the greater Philly area/outskirts.