Chris, good points. Yes, what they really are is a flipper I guess with a RE lic, “wholesaler” has, to me, always meant buying at a very low price and that’s not really what they do. That was my main objection to “wholesaler”. But your right they are really just a very large broker/flipping operation.
That’s my concern with the model, if there is a slowdown I would think their holding costs or purchase price would be an issue. Yes they have control to improve etc. But that’s just putting more $ in the game that has to come back out.
I think it’s really interesting that we have opposite views on what would happen. It’s really the reason why deals can still be found in the market.
The process I experienced 2nd hand at my neighbors house didn’t instill much confidence in their model. Obviously super tiny sample size(one house) but a decent neighborhood in Cary so not an outlier in terms of property type. They paid $283k
New roof
Entirely new plumbing (was polybutylene, but with the copper connections so not bad re: leaking)
Lots of Sheetrock/painting work cause of plumbing.
Replaced kitchen cabinets and appliances (Cabinets are not very current, very odd)
BUT
Then did not update the master bath(1995), nor the 2nd bath.? The eye catching rooms!
Back “yard” was and still is a disaster,
Listed for $315k
I know someone offered full price, then asked for 8k in repair $. They said No, it sat another 5 months and various subs would show up randomly to do stuff, more $ spent, finally sold for $310k.
I’m thinking if rates went up or economy dipped they might’ve had to sell at $290k and I have to think that would have been a significant money loser, especially factoring in holding costs.
I guess the difference in our thinking is that you feel they may have an advantage in a slower longer DOM scenario by being the owner of the property.
I think that would be a problem for them. They can’t decide to just take it off the market and keep it like an actual resident homeowner. From what I saw there were clear signs of inefficiency due to scale. They are competing with residential homeowners but are a huge operation that might have more operational costs/$ leakage than they are seeing in a hot market like this.
Anyway, I am not trying to convince you or prove I’m right. Just clarifying my thinking. I don’t have a direct stake in the game, but they are such a big force now and whatever happens it will have a significant impact on the market. As you said, time will tell!
Cheers!