Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Cliff T.

Cliff T. has started 35 posts and replied 199 times.

Post: Business Line of Credit (Who is best)

Cliff T.Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • San Francisco, CA
  • Posts 215
  • Votes 42
Quote from @Kai Kopsch:

I use American Express business blueprint; they like to work with REI and provide funds ASAP


 What type of rate and terms do you have with Amex business blueprint?

Post: Opinions/experience on M&M Property Pros? (Kansas City PM)

Cliff T.Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • San Francisco, CA
  • Posts 215
  • Votes 42
Quote from @Johanna R.:
Quote from @Gabe Monroy:

I have been using them and so far a great experience! I have about 10 rentals.

Hi Gabe, Im considering them to do some PM'ing for me. Are you still with them? Any pros/cons?
Thank you in advance for any help,
Johanna

Hi Joanna,

I just wanted to chime in. I've been working with M&M Property Pros, specifically Michele and her team, for the past few years. They are excellent at what they do. They manage 3 properties for me - 2 in Raytown, 1 in Independence. Very communicative, hands on, and thorough with their property management.

As some additional context, I own a few rentals in different markets and Michele's team is top notch compared to them. Feel free to message me with any questions.

Best of luck with your search and I hope this helps.

Thanks,

Cliff

Post: How is income from private lending taxed? How does REPS impact this?

Cliff T.Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • San Francisco, CA
  • Posts 215
  • Votes 42

Hi all,

Can anyone provide some guidance on how income from private lending is typically taxed? My understanding is that if I'm NOT considered in the business of loaning money, then the income is considered interest income and taxed at my marginal tax rate for both federal and state. However, if I do more loans and are considered "in the business of loaning money", then the income would be taxed as business income (ie. ordinary income).

Related to the above, if I qualify for REPS, could the income from private lending be theoretically canceled out if I have losses from other RE projects, rental properties, etc?

Post: Using Solo 401k to do hard money / private lending

Cliff T.Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • San Francisco, CA
  • Posts 215
  • Votes 42
Quote from @Ben Stoodley:

@Cliff T. great choice with the lending, and even better with the SDIRA! That is a very common way for our investors to structure their investments as well. I'm sure you are lending to trusted people/friends at the beginning, but make sure you consult an attorney with regards to the loan agreement, trust deed, note and other related docs. Every state requires different disclosures and statements, so it is important that you get those included in your loan doc package. Servicing your loan requires a license in CA, but if you're not licensed, there are many 3rd party servicers that do a great job. Let me know if you have any questions and best of luck on this new venture! 


 Hi Ben, thanks for the advice and great tips. When you say "servicing your loan requires a license in CA" is that only in the case I'm using SDIRA funds? Or even if I'm using personal funds for the private lending?

Also... can you clarify what you mean by servicing? My understanding is most HMLs are calculated based off simple interest, without any interim payments until the project is exited. Seems like very low servicing required (ie. loan is funded, then effectively paid back at the end of the project).

Post: Using Solo 401k to do hard money / private lending

Cliff T.Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • San Francisco, CA
  • Posts 215
  • Votes 42
Quote from @Jeff S.:

Your solo 401k is a separate entity from you, @Cliff T. It is a trust. Just like a corporation or LLC, it can lend money, so your trust's name, not yours, would appear as the lender on your loan documents. This process is super easy after the first few loans, and we've been lending both our after-tax and Solo 401k money, secured by local house flips, for years. You, as the trustee, are allowed to manage the loan, but you cannot take a dime from it until you begin taking disbursements – typically at retirement. Since the money is either tax-free (Roth Solo 401k) or tax-deferred (Traditional), your balance will grow very quickly, especially at hard money rates.

Sorry if I confused you, but I was responding to your question about whether you can personally partner with your solo 401k as co-lenders. In this case, you cannot because you are considered a disqualified person. Disqualified persons include you and your lineal descendants (mother, father, grandparents, sons, daughters, grandkids, etc.). Lateral relatives, such as brothers and sisters, are fine.

The other issue I mentioned is a bit more technical and has nothing to do with who the lender is. If there is more than one lender on a deed of trust, then the loan needs a security exemption. Fortunately, California provides this if a CA-licensed broker is used, who follows the rules for originating fractionalized loans. You will need a broker anyway if your interest rate in CA is greater than 10% APR.

Your solo 401k aside, I strongly recommend that you SEE A LENDING LAWYER before you start lending money. Lending law is complex and varies from state to state, so it is essential to have a lawyer who is familiar with the regulations. You don't know what you don't know, Cliff, and you're not going to get it all here.

Last, do not get your loan documents from a title company. Do not. Title companies are insurance companies. They employ many lawyers who work for them, but these lawyers do not represent you. Instead, hire a lawyer who specializes in lending to draft your loan documents and educate you. As a courtesy, you might get a simple note from a title company and a short-form DOT, but this is not even close to a complete loan package and will not fully protect you or your 401k. With all the automation and competition among lawyers lately, prices have dropped for loan documents. Understand that your borrower will typically pay for these anyway.


 Thanks Jeff! We really appreciate these insights. That all makes sense to me now. Do you have an attorney you recommend?

Post: Using Solo 401k to do hard money / private lending

Cliff T.Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • San Francisco, CA
  • Posts 215
  • Votes 42
Quote from @Dmitriy Fomichenko:

@Cliff T.

Super easy: person A needs a loan secured by the property. Your IRA or 401k would come in as lender and fund this loan. A trust deed would be recorded with the county securing your IRA's interest, all payments belong to the IRA, sheltered from taxes. Yes, you are a "disqualified person", but you personally are not involved in this transaction so no issues there.


Thanks so much Dmitriy. That all makes sense to me now. I didn't realize you were specifically responding to my Question #1. Sounds like I can do private lending from my Solo 401k. The issue is if I'm also personally involved and lending (ie. 2 parties in the transaction).

Post: Using Solo 401k to do hard money / private lending

Cliff T.Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • San Francisco, CA
  • Posts 215
  • Votes 42
Quote from @Jeff S.:

1. The answer is not an easy Yes but a hard No, @Cliff T.  As a disqualified person, you cannot personally profit from any investment made by your Solo 401k. This means you cannot personally co-invest with your retirement plan. (As an aside, if there were two qualified lenders, the loan would have to be fractionalized. This is legal in CA but would require a broker.)

2. Assuming the money resides in a trust account at a bank or equivalent, and that you have checkbook control (i.e. this is not a stock and bond brokerage 401k) then yes, you would wire the money to title after all documents are signed, reviewed by you, and evidence of proper insurance is received.

3. Yes, except it would be the title company. They would wire all funds back into your 401k account. With a few notable exceptions, such as a personal loan, you can’t touch any of this money until you’re 59 ½.

4. This is a completely separate topic. There is a lot more to a loan than a note and DOT. If this loan is in CA, and the interest and points total more than 10% annualized, your plan will need a licensed CA real estate broker to originate the loan. There will be lenders instructions, disclosures, a title prelim review, personal guarantee (if you're wise), 1003, occupancy affidavit, use of funds statement, and lots more. You should really sit with a lending attorney to learn the basics of making a private loan, including licensing ad usury, and an understanding of the required paperwork before you agree to lend like this, Cliff.

In general, the paperwork and process for lending money from a Solo 401k is exactly the same as for any other private loan. The only difference is that you can’t personally touch the money.


 Thanks Jeff! I'm still slightly confused. What's an example of how I could use my Solo 401k to do private lending? 

Post: Using Solo 401k to do hard money / private lending

Cliff T.Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • San Francisco, CA
  • Posts 215
  • Votes 42
Quote from @Dmitriy Fomichenko:

@Cliff T.

Private lending is a great way to deploy your retirement funds, I did several dozen loans and love it. Ended up owning one property as a result of a defaulted note which worked out great. Now to answer your questions:

1. You are considered to be a "disqualified person" to your 401k. Per IRS rules all transactions involving your 401k must be "arms length", so NO, this is not an easy Yes. Since your 401k is unable to do this deal on it's own, by contributing your personal capital to the deal you would be "enabling" your 401k to perform a transaction it can't do otherwise, which can be considered a "prohibited transaction". I recommend you either fund a smaller loan or have your 401k partner with unrelated person. 

2. You need a promissory note and a deed of trust to secure your investment. Local title company can assist with the documents and will ensure loan is structured and recorded correctly. And yes, you can simply wire funds to escrow to fund this loan.

3. Yes, all proceeds (interest payments and loan payoff) must go back to your 401k account. 

4. Read 1 and 2 above again. 


 Thanks for the reply Dmitriy! Super helpful... However, I'm still slightly confused. You mentioned "Private lending is a great way to deploy your retirement funds, I did several dozen loans and love it"

How would I deploy my retirement funds into private lending if I'm considered a disqualified person? Perhaps you can provide an example of when someone could use their Solo 401k for such a loan?

Post: Using Solo 401k to do hard money / private lending

Cliff T.Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • San Francisco, CA
  • Posts 215
  • Votes 42

Hi all,

I am hoping to get into the world of hard money / private lending using my Solo 401k and had a few questions.

1. I have approx. $120k in my Solo 401k but the deal that I am planning to fund needs about $180k. Is it possible for me to do $120k from my Solo 401k and the remaining $60 from another personal account? I'm assuming that is an easy Yes but want to confirm.

2. My Solo 401k is with mysolo401k.net. I went through the process of setting it up a few years ago and have contributed every year since, but haven't learned the ins & outs and don't understand the mechanics of how to fund the deal. Do I simply wire the money out of my Solo 401k account (currently with Schwab)? What type of documentation is needed?

3. Related to #2, when the deal wraps up and I am getting paid back. How does that process work? Escrow would then wire the funds into my Solo 401k account (at Schwab)?

4. Any general tips regarding private lending and protections that I need in place? I will be on the deed with a promissory note recorded, along with being added as mortgagee on insurance.

Many thanks in advance!

Post: Good local credit unions or banks for HELOC?

Cliff T.Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • San Francisco, CA
  • Posts 215
  • Votes 42
Quote from @David Lutz:

also, should mention third fed only doesn't do investment property heloc, sorry. 

 Hey @David Lutz  can you confirm what the underwriting process is like? Do they require tax returns?