I can tell you you are wasting your time with the pre-screening or do not do any pre-screening, or you wouldnt be wasting your time on folks who wouldnt qualify to begin with. I've narrowed down to 3 pre-screening questions I ask all potential applicants: how much do you make? When do you need to move in? are there any smokers or pets? This makes sure they will be a good fit for my property and meet the main criteria that I have. I have tons more, but sometimes you only get a few questions to ask before they might not answer all of them via email, text, FB, etc. If you had asked up front, you could tell them they are welcome to apply, but they wont likely meet the income criteria if they couldnt document or actually make the 3x the rent. This avoids you wasting time on folks who wont qualify. You dont refuse to let them apply, you just tell them up front they won't likely meet your criteria but go ahead:) This applicant is someone who is not going to meet your income criteria, and you were better off finding out much sooner and not having to think about moldy furniture before the much more obvious issue with their being qualified. You're getting distracted by unimportant aspects of the applicant.
Also fun fact: if the applicant does not answer all of the questions on your application like say forget to fill in the income disclosure or provide pay stubs, thats an incomplete application. You can't process an incomplete application nor are you obligated to. So you can just move on from that. I prefer to avoid outright denials.
here is the guide:
https://www.biggerpockets.com/blog/2013/01/27/tena...