Well I never thought I would be the one saying something like this......but I have a recent good news story about a warranty company.
Based on an experience over 30 years ago, I have been on the anti-warranty bandwagon and even run them down on this forum, but:
I bought a house last summer (primary home) and the sellers agent threw in a Home Warranty. I ignored it figuring it was just BS.
#1 - Then the cooktop starting acting up and I figured, hey why not call and give them a chance? Imagine my surprise when a guy showed up promptly, said he couldn't get parts for the Jenn Air model any longer (18 yrs old), and few days later I get an email from the warranty company offering me a replacement cooktop that was far more expensive than an exact replacement! Of course I said yes and the tech returned and installed the new cooktop. I was blown away to be honest, I was expecting a run-around....
#2 - A month later the dishwasher starting leaking. The tech tried replacing the door seal, and it still had a very slight leak, so he recommended a new one to the company. A week later I had a brand new DW. Once again, they did not go cheap...they could have spent $400 ish dollars to buy me a cheap DQ (I still expected as much) but they offered $1500 as a top limit and said go ahead and pick a new one! Once again, a brand new high-end (GE Profile model) DW
#3 - One of the water heaters went out and within a couple days it was fixed (new thermostat)
My co-pay was $85 each for all three of the above.....for about $3000+ worth of product and labor. I'll take that deal all day long. I'm not sure how they make any profit to be honest... :-)
I plan on renewing the plan when it expires in July. One of the smartest financial moves I've every made, Lol.... The AC condensers are both 18 years old so they can be expected to pass on in the next few years.
@Julia Hagen Be aware though that they will not just buy you a new unit. Their first effort (of course) is to attempt a repair. But at least those company will quickly shift their focus to new without hassling you for months.
So my final take is that - IF you get the right company, a warranty plan is actually a smart financial move - and I never thought I'd be the one saying that!
I have not disclosed the name of the company on here to avoid the appearance of impropriety :-)