Originally posted by @Joe Villeneuve:
Originally posted by @Christian Wathne:
Originally posted by @Thomas S.:
It is always less expensive to rent than own, A personal home is a life style choice not a investment.
Determine your priorities in life. Invest or own, your choice. You must choose one to begin. It comes down to what your goals are in life. Is home owner ship or financial security of prime importance.
I would prefer to invest till I reach the point where I have cash to throw away then buy a personal home.
"always less expensive to rent than own"..... thats not true at all. If that were true then by your logic it would mean that nobody on BP has a cash flowing rental because it costs more to own the home than it rents for.
Not the same thing. Buying your own home isn't the same as buying a rental. If you had two identical properties, with identical values, bills, mortgage, DP, repairs. etc... The rental is an investment where the tenant pays for everything, thus the "outgoes" are all "expenses". You pay for everything when you buy your own home, so all the "outgoes" are "costs".
You can't look at an investment property the same way as your own home.
I generally agree with some of your thoughts, but if your one and only property is one that you rent out, you must now go and throw money each month into a home that you yourself are renting and some other landlord is making money off you.
Lets say example A is living in your own primary for $2500/mo that would cost $3k as a rental
Example B, you pay $3k/mo in rent (to get the same type of home), while owning a home that costs $2500/mo that you're renting to a stranger for $3k/mo.
With a portfolio of either zero or one home, I see near zero difference between the A and B example other than the fact that you have to deal with a tenant and landlord in example B. You could say that in example B you get to write off expenses associated with the home, but I would counter that by saying you also add $ to your gross income and are likely paying higher tax overall.
Rental property investing is the way to go, but unless a person strongly values mobility then owning the home you live in makes perfect sense.