So being new and definitly not worth a million dollars this is my take.
From the syndication opportunities I have seen come across my email they are generally 5 years or so in length with CoC average returns of 8%+ per year PLUS and equity multiplier GREATER THAN 1. This to me seems like the best opportunity because effortless income with "appreciation" because of the multiplier payout in the end. Sure, you may not have the depreciation or other tax benefits as a piece of real estate does but you're also not doing much of anything except putting money into a wire transfer and living life.
The SFH option may give you cash flow on a monthly basis and depreciation benefits to shelter some income but if you're in a market that is becoming worse and worse as time goes on, aren't you deteriorating your initial investment base? Doesn't that violate the first rule of investment which is to preserve the initial investment? I mean you could 1031 exchange in perpetuity to keep that base but that is a lot of work and your not really seeing appreciation in the end. You also cant really call your chips back either can you since you would have them tied into 1031 exchanges (without heavy tax implications).
I am def not a finance guy but it seems to me that the capital gains tax you will pay on syndication will likely end with your initial investment principle being multiplied by something greater than 1 plus the cash flow you got from monthly payments. The SFH option will likely end with initial capital being multiplied by something less than one from depreciation recapture and cap gains etc but you have some cash flow...
Again just my thoughts totally new here .