My first deal was a new SFR I purchased to rent to a family member.
Paid 155K, borrowed 124K @ 6% for 30 years.
P&I on loan was $743.44.
I rented it to a family member for $1200 a month.
Using the 50% rule, subtracting $600 for expenses left me in the hole $143.44 each month. Not the best investment huh.
It was a loser for sure, but it was bought for two reasons, one to get me off the sidelines and into the game, and secondly, to help a family member.
Fast forward 5 years, the family member is no longer in that home (but is in another investment property I purchased just over a year ago).
Home is currently rented below market to a fine family that has been there over a year now. Current rent it $1395, but market shows I could get closer to $1600 for it. Current tenant is first rate, pays on the 1st like clockwork and keeps the place immaculate.
I've paid extra on the home and have the principal balance down to $97K. I'm in the process of refinancing this property with a new 30 year fixed rate loan @ 4%. The new payment will be something like $477 (P&I only).
With the new payment of $477, the 50% rule will now look like this:
Current rent @ $1395.
50% for expenses comes to approx $700.
Subtract $477 for the note payment and it leaves me with $233 a month in profit.
I manage the property myself so my expenses will probably be closer to the 40% level, leaving me an additional $139 a month in profit.
I have 3 rental properties today, two are rented to family.
Would I recommend taking this route, probably not, it's full of issues, but I knew it going in and was willing to deal with them.
In the end, it got me in the game and that's what counts.
I had the resources to carry the properties losses and knew it would just be a matter of time before they would become profitable.
All my investment properties are in very desirable areas.
None met the 50% rule when purchased, none even met the 1% rule. I've only purchased properties I would personally live in.
It's been slow going to get to where any of my properties could turn a profit, but they are there now. I know there are quicker ways to profit with RE, but this was the approach I was most comfortable with.