Hello @Baron Wheeler,
It sounds like you have a great foundation to start out with to continue your investment journey! Living for free is essentially the first great achievement to the path of financial independence and you have already done that!! You should be proud of this as most investors (including myself) have not achieved this goal yet!
In my opinion Option 1 could be a bit risky in today's environment as we are not sure if prices have hit the bottom yet, there are positive signs in the CoS market that point to price appreciation in the future, but there is a good chance the interest rates are not coming down for a while, which will have a negative impact on home values. Plus if you do not have a well established team to get your project finished up before the end of the summer selling season, you may not get the return you were expecting as holding costs and declining values are eating profits.
Option 2 sounds like a safer bet, but yes you will have to cover some expenses and may have to carry the property with your own cash until rent prices appreciate enough over the years to cover your mortgage payments. You would still want to be sure to buy a nice home in a good area to ensure that you are not coming out of pocket for years to come, and will attract quality tenants.
Option 3 could work, but I agree that maybe you wouldn't want to give up that prime location and that sweet low interest rate!
My suggestion is that, if you are willing to move around the area then maybe you should consider the strategy that my wife and I are currently implementing. We are buying a new primary residence every year with a low 3.5% - 5% down payment and then keeping the home as a rental when we move on the next year. AND, an even more powerful strategy to implement in today's market is to target homes for sale that have a FHA, VA or USDA loan because these loans are ASSUMABLE!
You can, just as we did last November on our most recent home purchase, buy a home today with a 2%-5% interest rate! We are saving over $1,100 per month on our mortgage payment and banking over $350 in additional monthly debt paydown by taking over a 3% loan originated in 2021 compared to a 7% rate loan if we took out one today!
Depending on the situation of the seller, you may have to come up with a down payment to cover the sellers earned equity, but many homes have dropped in value since mid 2022 and sellers are being left with very minimal equity depending on how much they put down when they purchased. I have a blog post where I talk about the power of buying via an assumable loan and I think this the only way to buy a profitable investment in today's market conditions!
https://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/922/topics/1175338-maxi...
If you need some help finding an assumable loan target in El Paso or Teller County please reach out I would love to share my knowledge with you! I wish you the best on your journey and look forward to hearing about your next steps!
Take Care,
Brian Bohrer - Homesin719.com