@Eric Littlepage all I am saying is be careful. You may not be rejecting them because they are a "protected class" but your criteria could overly affect or limit a protected class.
I will find the details and attach later, but there are HUD groups out west right now that are trying to make it where you can't deny someone based off of their criminal background because it vastly affects a protected class more, same with source of income. These laws are ever changing and landlords and property management companies have to ask themselves, who the policy is affecting and is it going to affect one group more than another.
I believe in mitigating risk for myself as an investor, property manager and that of all my clients.
I would be more than happy to provide an example of rental criteria that I utilize, but as a disclaimer I don't claim it to be full proof and always recommend you have an attorney review these types of things.