Originally posted by Laurel Bowen:
House #1 - 2022 square feet, 4/1, very upscale historic neighborhood in Knoxville, TN - List price was $99,900. I'm buying it for $70,700 and selling it for $80,500 (adding in closing costs, hard money cost to purchase, and $5000 profit for myself). I've also included in the ads that I could assign the contract for less. The ARV is $135,000. Repair costs are estimated at $10,000, so profit would be $44,500. Seems to me that's enough "wiggle room" to make a good profit even if things go wrong, which I know they will. So where am I going wrong?
Here is where I see possible problems with the lack of interest in your this deal. Keep in mind, I am unfamiliar with this market.
1. It is listed in the MLS.
2. It has only 1 bathroom which can be a problem come resale or rental time.
3. Rehabber's usually look for 50 to 60 percent of ARV from wholesaler's which this is not.
4. For buy and hold investors, most will use the current rental rates and unless this neighborhood is getting $1400.00 a month rent, interest will be limited.
Originally posted by Laurel Bowen:
House #2 - 1106 square feet, 3/1 (with room to add a second half bath), quiet street, working class neighborhood - List price was $20,000, HUD owned. I'm buying it for $20,500 and selling it for $32,600 retail or $29,900 wholesale (added in closing costs, hard money cost to purchase, and $5000 profit for myself). The ARV is $75,000. Repair costs are estimated at $28,360, so profit would be $16,740. I've found several retail buyers but am waiting to see which one could get a mortgage. I'm steering them to a local broker who specializes in the FHA Rehab loan. I think I know the problem with this one -- I didn't get it significantly below list price, even though I got it at 78% below ARV (29900+28360)/75000.
This one is much of the same.
1. It is listed in the MLS.
2. It has only 1 bathroom which can be a problem come resale or rental time.
3. Rehabber's usually look for 50 to 60 percent of ARV from wholesaler's which this is, but your asking them to put in a $30K rehab. This might be tying up too much capital for a minimal return.
4. For buy and hold investors, most will use the current rental rates and unless this neighborhood is getting $1000.00 a month rent, interest will be limited.
Here are some potential things you should consider before making an offer.
1. ARV does not equal purchase price + repair costs. ARV is the value of rehabbed comps that have recently sold nearby. It is a term an appraiser would use should a property be brought to current standards. Many investors wrongfully assume ARV means paint and flooring, but it also means brings HVAC/mechanical, plumbing, and electrical up to current standards. If you take a look at property #1, I believe your repair estimate may need an adjustment.
2. Your profit projections need also to take into account closing, carrying, and commission costs. This is generally around 10% or the eventual resale price. In your case, you should adjust your profit projections to include this expense.
3. Wholesale fee - Generally a wholesaler should expect a 0 to 3% fee on the purchase price. These are going to be the average fees especially on listed properties. Once in a while, you may hit one out of the park because you were able to negotiate a very good price. In my opinion, these are not great deals and you probably are expecting too large a fee.