Skip to content
×
Try PRO Free Today!
BiggerPockets Pro offers you a comprehensive suite of tools and resources
Market and Deal Finder Tools
Deal Analysis Calculators
Property Management Software
Exclusive discounts to Home Depot, RentRedi, and more
$0
7 days free
$828/yr or $69/mo when billed monthly.
$390/yr or $32.5/mo when billed annually.
7 days free. Cancel anytime.
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Bian Dahab

Bian Dahab has started 10 posts and replied 24 times.

Post: Problem collecting payment for airbnb reservation

Bian Dahab
Posted
  • Posts 24
  • Votes 16

Hi all, I am curious if this has ever been an issue for short-term rental hosts and how you have mitigated the issue. 

I got an Airbnb guest who reserved 28 nights under a strict cancellation policy. The booking was confirmed in mid-November, she checked in on December 2nd, I received the payout notification on December 4th. 

On December 5th, Airbnb notified me about a problem collecting payment at 4:26pm. At 4:35pm, she asks if she can cancel the reservation. She canceled the reservation at 9:22pm. Airbnb writes that "If your guest doesn't successfully submit payment or if they cancel the reservation before making the payment, Airbnb isn't liable for issuing your host payout." 

This is already the fourth night of the stay, how is this possible? This would have never happened if I had medium-term or long-term tenant where I make sure to collect the rent before letting them in the property, along with security deposit. 

Anyone who can share the experience and ideas to mitigate it?

For avoidance of doubt, I spoke to her and she claimed a technical issue with the payment and she wants to move out early to move closer to another university she was accepted to today in NJ. I am fine with her moving out early. I am just uncomfortable about the fact that there is a possibility that I could have no payout for an Airbnb reservation that has already started. 

Post: Advice Needed for the 2nd House Hack Planning

Bian Dahab
Posted
  • Posts 24
  • Votes 16

Hi all, 

We have completed my first house-hacking in 2023 (Shout out to Craig and the Househacking Bootcamp team!)
I closed in July, got a tenant, and am confident about renting out the rest when I move out.

Now I am looking to get ready for my second house-hack in 2024. With the lower down payment requirement, I want to buy a small multifamily and occupy one unit. 

- Timing: When would be the earliest I can move out and buy the next one? My current mortgage was a 5% down conventional loan. 6M or 1Y or earlier? 

- Loan: What income can I use in DTI to qualify for the loan: our W-2 income, rents from the 1st house hack, potential rents from the 2nd house hack?

- Legal: Do people ever structure their house hack in an LLC? Is it even possible to get an owner-occupant loan in an LLC?

- Tax: I am looking for an investor-friendly tax preparer and planner in NJ who will take a small client like me. Recommendations will be appreciated!

Thank you, 

Bian 

Post: Income verification for travel nurse

Bian Dahab
Posted
  • Posts 24
  • Votes 16
Quote from @Brent Langlinais:

Great points all.  I'm a travel nurse of 9 years and most of my veteran travel nurse friends do not share their income with MTR landlords (same as we don't share with hotels or air b&b hosts) because we are too often taken advantage of. In fact, we have seen a massive increase in our housing costs as our industry has gotten a lot of negative press about how much money we make. I've even heard the sentiment on BP podcasts that travel nurses make a killing, encouraging investors to switch to MTRs to take advantage of our housing stipends.   Indeed, there was a boom during the pandemic with news headlines of nurses making $10,000 a week, not mentioning that we worked 90 hours a week at $90/hr for this income, and paid 40% or more to taxes.  My tattoo artist makes more than $90/hr, so does my electrician, plumber, diesel mechanic, etc. lol 

Part of this $10,000 was a per diem tax free stipend which is based on GSA per diem allowance and varies by zip code and season.  To receive the stipend we are required to duplicate our houses expenses so we are paying rent or mortgage in our home town AND at our duty station. Also, in an attempt to cut costs, some hospital systems cancel our contracts without warning, due to low cense, or hiring new travel nurses who sign contracts paying less than the current traveler is making.  Some predatory travel nurse agencies routinely cut pay as soon as the travel nurse begins their assignment with a take it or leave it approach knowing the nurse waited weeks without work for the contract to start, gave up other opportunities, and accrued thousands in out of pocket expenses for flights, rental car, signed a MTR lease, and maybe even relocated their family.  Many new travel nurses initially fail to realize the "contracts" are not binding in the legal sense, but At-Will job offers.  When the contract is canceled, many real estate investors refuse to let these nurses out of the rental leases and nurses pay for 3 months of MTR rent that they were unable to use while the landlord immediately rents their property to the next travel nurse, and gets double rent for a period.  I could go on and on about how nurses have been burned during the pandemic, sometimes by hospitals, sometimes the staffing agencies, and sometimes their landlords but this is likely why they are hesitant to share their income, i.e. fear of being taken advantage of.   

Quick tip: the travel nurse market has shifted drastically in the last 12 months, falling to pre-pandemic pay levels and often below.  During the pandemic peak, there were as many as 60,000 current listings for travel nurse contracts with pay packages between $4000-$11,000/week ($16K-$44K/month) depending on location, hours worked, specialty, and experience.  We are now down to 6000 current listings with pay between $1500-4000/week ($6K-16K/month).   

I don't think landlords have to worry about our earnings/income.  But I might be concerned with the increasing supply of MTRs and decreasing demand for MTRs with fewer travel nursing contracts, and fewer nurses willing to travel for the reduced pay. 

Thanks for sharing this, Brent! It is very helpful to know the market and the work environment is changing for them quickly. 

I also found the furnished finder’s e-book that explained the concept of Tax Home. That explains why the housing requests I am seeing are far below the GSA guideline. 

Fortunately, I am at a location with a wide range of demand for short-term and medium-term rental, other than travel nurses. I ended up filling the room with someone in another industry who had no issue showing an income verification letter and providing a prior landlord reference. 
 
@Shannon Strickland ‘s comment made me sure about not house-hacking with someone who is uncooperative. Thanks all! 

Post: Income verification for travel nurse

Bian Dahab
Posted
  • Posts 24
  • Votes 16
Quote from @Miguel Del Mazo:
Quote from @Sean Monahan:

Travel nurses are given a specific per diem for their food and shelter.  Also please note that just because this is their stipend that this is what you should charge.  Monitor your area and find a fare value.  

This is an excellent post. Also be aware that the stipend given to travelers is not to just cover the cost of their rental housing, but it also exists to defray some of the cost of the presumed housing they have back home. While many traveling medical professionals fully embrace the nomadic lifestyle and have no such "home base", there is a logical reason why the per diem for housing should be higher than a tenant's rent.
That is a good perspective to have in mind.

My rental pricing is not about maximizing what I can charge based on the tenant’s earning, it is about balancing between 1) the cost base of the house and  2) the price of alternative options to what I offer.

The purpose of income verification is to verify the affordability, rather than establishing information asymmetry. One can make 6x of rent and choose to live way below his/her means, I have no problem with that and rather respect that! 

Post: Income verification for travel nurse

Bian Dahab
Posted
  • Posts 24
  • Votes 16

@Eric Boughner That must be why the applicant was very defensive. 

Given that the applicant has been haggling on everything (the room price, the utilities, the parking space, ...and the application fee...) without providing income verification, I declined the application. Either the applicant must be stretching the budget or have a strong scarcity mindset, neither of which is a good sign. 

Afterward, the applicant followed up with the first page of the full offer letter with hourly rates and also offered to provide a verification from the HR. I declined again as I don't want to work with someone who only responds to an ultimatum. 

Post: Income verification for travel nurse

Bian Dahab
Posted
  • Posts 24
  • Votes 16
Quote from @Shannon Strickland:

We have had our first travel nurse for 6 weeks so far. The way we approached it is, if the background check, credit check and eviction history all came out fine (which says a lot about the person), I asked for the redacted first page of the contract as proof of employment offer. Also, we hired a RE lawyer to draft our mid-term lease because we’re house hacking, and through that, we were persuaded to collect rent on a weekly basis to make eviction quicker if it is ever needed. What was provided by your candidate seems enough, but maybe others here think differently. I hope this is helpful.

Shannon

https://www.plthousing.com/

Thank you for sharing this! Did the first page of the offer letter state the income and the living stipend?

I also asked for a redacted page but did not get the information I needed to feel comfortable and the reply from the candidate makes me more nervous about a potential eviction issue as I am also house-hacking. 

Post: Income verification for travel nurse

Bian Dahab
Posted
  • Posts 24
  • Votes 16

Hi, I have a prospective tenant who is a travel nurse on a 13 week assignment. The background check, credit check and eviction history came out fine.

But the candidate is refusing to provide a verification of income. Only the top half of the assignment letter(that doesn’t show the income and the living stipend), no previous paystubs, no previous tax return, no W2, no 1099. We have been back and forth about this and the rationale has been diverse: 

- Does not feel comfortable providing the info without knowing about us personally 

- Offer letter does not guarantee a future income because travel nurse is an at will employee 

- Tax return does not indicate her affordability 

I Would appreciate any advice for us to push back for the right level of information! 


Post: What’s happening to this floor? Advice needed

Bian Dahab
Posted
  • Posts 24
  • Votes 16

Thanks everyone! 

Yes, the floor has multiple spots that has been caulked and I have seen many spots that showed up over the last 3 months. We are gonna get regular pest control for peace of mind and another termite inspection from a local operator, better to be safe than sorry. 

Post: What’s happening to this floor? Advice needed

Bian Dahab
Posted
  • Posts 24
  • Votes 16

Thanks Ned!

Post: What’s happening to this floor? Advice needed

Bian Dahab
Posted
  • Posts 24
  • Votes 16
Quote from @Richard F.:
Aloha,

Hard to tell from a pic, BUT, the one on the left in particular, when you zoom in, you can clearly see three, maybe 4, holes such as a termite might make. It is entirely possible the flooring ALREADY had termites in it when installed. I have had this happen with cabinets in the past as well.

Big mistake having the Big T out...much better to get a mid-sized local operator. Between all the marketing crap, multiple early "renewal" notices, and generally poor followup service, we stopped using them several years ago.
Thanks so much! Yes he was quite salesy and I did not feel comfortable with his answers. How about Orkin Pest Control? Have you ever heard of them?