Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 54%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$69 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Bart H.

Bart H. has started 11 posts and replied 1129 times.

Post: Tax Sticker shock/ How to value a Duplex

Bart H.Posted
  • Dallas, TX
  • Posts 1,165
  • Votes 744
Originally posted by @Irina Belkofer:

It would be easy in Cleveland - within last 3 years they count as a purchase price.

Anyway, why would it go up that much?

Are there any duplexes sold for $700K?!?

They can't apply other forms of dwellings as comps (SFR, condos etc).

I'd definitely challenge that - at least for 2019 you should be ok with $393K.

Outrageous tax value :(

Hope your rents will jump twice as well 

 Its not impossible to hit $700K, but unless it was a massive multi bedroom student living arrangement, or brand new construction,  it wouldnt come close to $700K, not out by TCU.  Duplexes near Highland park are going for less.

Post: Tax Sticker shock/ How to value a Duplex

Bart H.Posted
  • Dallas, TX
  • Posts 1,165
  • Votes 744
Originally posted by @David Woz:

@Irina Belkofer Yes, purchased in late 2017 for 393,500 with an appraisal for that amount.   The appraised tax was in the 525K range for 2018.. I protested last year by simply sending in the appraisal I had done when I purchased that showed 393K and they lowered it to 393K.

I'm hearing that it should be capped at 10%, putting me at the 433K range.. and I do believe that may be an accurate amount of what it is worth... 

Any Fort Worth/ Tarrant County people out there with knowledge of the caps?   

One would think that if you are capped at 10%, it would be automated and not kick out these crazy numbers.

 No the cap is only on properties that have been homesteaded.

You can go in yourself and contest the appraisal.  If you are unable to go, there are companies that will to the protest for you.

We had our personal house go from $325 to $450 because we missed the timing to put the homestead exemption on the house.

Post: Apartment Investing Events / Seminars ??

Bart H.Posted
  • Dallas, TX
  • Posts 1,165
  • Votes 744
Originally posted by @Kevin Ferguson:

Hello BP Community! I have a few events I was planning on attending soon. A few of them are listed below. 

Are there any other ones that you have marked on your calendar that I should know about? 

Brad Sumrok's- AimNatCon - (Dallas August 10)

Michael Blank's- Deal Maker Live (Dallas July 25-27) 

Tony Robbins- Unleash the Power (Dallas July 11-14)

 ITs fine to go to these thing, imo stay away from the big up sell. I think you will learn a LOT more by taking the several thousand dollars that most of these folks will end up asking to join their super premium elite group, and instead buying your first deal.

I dont believe there is a magic system that will get you a return on spending thousands of dollars on a guru.  Better off reading the materials on this board and asking the folks around here for help.

Post: Dallas real estate meet up!

Bart H.Posted
  • Dallas, TX
  • Posts 1,165
  • Votes 744

Dont think I can make it this time, but will definitely try in the future.

Post: Advice on a horrible situation

Bart H.Posted
  • Dallas, TX
  • Posts 1,165
  • Votes 744
Originally posted by @Larry Spradling:

****UPDATE****

I spoke to the property management company yesterday. It's Fairview Realty Group if anyone knows anything about them. They took over the management last year from Growth Equity Group and he told me that he has several landlords in the same position. He has looked into the situation and confirmed that I was part of a scheme between GEG and Genesis 1, LLC. They sold the property to GEG for $70,000 and he said GEG sold it to me the same day for $100,900, and Genesis 1 became the lender. The whole intent was to sell me an upside down property that did not cashflow inevitably forcing foreclosure so that Genesis 1 would get the property back and then rinse and repeat for the next investor.

He recommended that I stop making mortgage payments and that he would continue to collect rent from the tenant on my behalf. He said that it would take 10-12 months to foreclose, so I could walk away with that much in rent money at the very least. He said that he could not deposit the rent money into my IRA monthly. He would have to keep it and then pay me at the end of the process. I'm not sure why he can't pay me monthly. That sounds fishy to me. I don't know who to trust in this situation, or if I can trust anyone. Can anyone here confirm that I cannot collect rent if I'm not paying the mortgage?

@Clayton Mobley, @Jay Hinrichs, @Andrey Y., I would especially be interested in your thoughts.

 Let me guess, is your house near 71st S and ashland?  or are you a little further south like 90th st?

Post: Advice on a horrible situation

Bart H.Posted
  • Dallas, TX
  • Posts 1,165
  • Votes 744
Originally posted by @Larry Spradling:

****UPDATE****

I spoke to the property management company yesterday. It's Fairview Realty Group if anyone knows anything about them. They took over the management last year from Growth Equity Group and he told me that he has several landlords in the same position. He has looked into the situation and confirmed that I was part of a scheme between GEG and Genesis 1, LLC. They sold the property to GEG for $70,000 and he said GEG sold it to me the same day for $100,900, and Genesis 1 became the lender. The whole intent was to sell me an upside down property that did not cashflow inevitably forcing foreclosure so that Genesis 1 would get the property back and then rinse and repeat for the next investor.

He recommended that I stop making mortgage payments and that he would continue to collect rent from the tenant on my behalf. He said that it would take 10-12 months to foreclose, so I could walk away with that much in rent money at the very least. He said that he could not deposit the rent money into my IRA monthly. He would have to keep it and then pay me at the end of the process. I'm not sure why he can't pay me monthly. That sounds fishy to me. I don't know who to trust in this situation, or if I can trust anyone. Can anyone here confirm that I cannot collect rent if I'm not paying the mortgage?

@Clayton Mobley, @Jay Hinrichs, @Andrey Y., I would especially be interested in your thoughts.

 Dude, you are still getting scammed, dont take this the wrong way, but take control of this thing.

Your seller and lender are running a confidence scam, they ALMOST certainly have worked a deal with a deadbeat tenant to sign a lease in exchange for free rent.  Most likely someone that the lender knows personally.  

The tenant gets free rent. The landlord rules are stupid in Chicago, so low and behold, there is a decent chance they are hoping for cash for keys after living their for free.

Didnt you mention that the turnkey company found the property manager?  There is a huge chance that the property manager is in on it and is either covering for his tenant buddy who isnt paying his rent or is trying to keep some or all of the rent that the tenant may or may not be paying.

Also if the scam is to take the down payment and foreclose, you are playing right into it. Because its an IRA, you cant pay money out of your own pocket to keep the property afloat if the tenant isnt paying. Everyone involved is likely working together hoping that the house will get foreclosed and they can sell it again to another unsuspecting person who comes along.

GET a LAWYER, GET rid of the Property Manager, file for eviction if you dont have the rent.

Post: First house hack!! But is it worth it? Help!

Bart H.Posted
  • Dallas, TX
  • Posts 1,165
  • Votes 744
Originally posted by @Daniel Porter:

Hey BP fam!!

Got a counter offer on a property today and it would be my first deal. Here’s the details.

$120k

$24k down

$5k~ closing costs.

I can rent out the other 4 rooms for about $350-$400 each. So about $1400 in income.

In a C+ neighborhood.

The problem is, i can only qualify for a non-qualified mortgage. So my interest rate on a 30y fixed will be 7.8%, and my monthly PITI will be around $950. $200/mo will be going to taxes (Dallas area).

So as you can see, that only leaves about $400 for CapEx, OpEx and Vacancies.

Right now my rent is about $520/mo with utilities. So my monthly cashflow will still be changing pretty drastically even if I am paying $100-$200 out of pocket per month.

Other things:

I’ll probably put any extra cashflow per month towards the principal, since I can still live off my earnings.

I’ll be refinancing as soon as I can, probably within 24mo, or however long it takes to show border income on your tax return.

Okay, so any thoughts? I’m definitely panicking a bit as I’m about to jump into my first deal head first, but am I missing anything major? Any neighborhood things I should be analyzing? Anything else?

Thanks in advance!! Excited to get this one in the bag!!!

-dan

 Dan, where are you at?  120K sounds like its in a fairly rough neighborhood.  (you can direct message me).

Originally posted by @Scott P.:

I agree with @Theresa Harris and @Albert Hasson and others.  Based on what you're describing I would help her if she would help me.  She keeps the place extra clean and helps show it.  In return you let her break the lease early if/when you find a new tenant.  Any costs you incur would come out of her deposit but keep the prospect of getting some or all of it back in the front of her mind to keep her cooperation.

If a new tenant moved in the day she moved out and I suffered zero extra costs I would either refund the deposit or tell her in writing after she moves that I would refund it after the replacement tenant fulfilled her obligation to the remaining portion of the original 18 month lease. i wouldn't hold her responsible for the new tenants damages but if I let her out of the lease and the new tenant fails to fulfill the remaining months the original tenant was obligated to and I can't recover from the new tenant like I might have been able to recover from her then I'd want her deposit for not fulfilling her 18 months.  

Also, nice idea posting the lease portion. That way, we can see and comment on it if needed.

 I don't think you could do that in Texas, because you have 30 days to  after the tenant has moved out AND provided you with a forwarding address  to return the damage deposit and provide documentation of any money that has been withheld.

Originally posted by @Jim D.:

If I'm reading correctly, she has already paid April rent, would move out at the end of April, and just offered to give you her $2,000 deposit as an early termination fee. You could start looking for a new renter immediately. I usually fill my units in a week or two... worst case scenario 2 months. 

Honestly, compared to how some renters break a lease early (wait until they're behind on rent, move out without cleaning, little notice, etc.) I'd say that's a pretty great situation for you. If it were me I would take her offer, get it listed for rent right away, and move forward.

 Yep, spot on, work with her, tell her she is on the hook for the lease, and the best thing both parties can do is to work to get it released.  Mention she IS required to pay the lease in full, but that you want to work with her as much as possible to find a mutually beneficial solution, so you need to get it listed and shown immediately.  

Originally posted by @Jonathan G.:

@Albert Hasson thank you for that info.  My question wold be, can I keep her holding deposit on top of what you said.  If I find a tenant and she has to pay for rent and utilities until a qualified tenant is in, I believe that my lease states I can still keep her security deposit.  Thoughts?

 If you use a realtor, there is a standard form for breaking the lease and you can include the exact amount of what the charge would be.  DO NOT USE the deposit as the fee for breaking the lease, then they move out and there is 0 reason for the tenant to clean the place or worry about damage.  make it a separate payment.