Quote from @Ryan Normand:
Short answer is you have to do what the contract says. Start by asking them to come back and fix the specific items that were done incorrectly. If they already completed the work according to the contract then you have to pay them, otherwise they can put a mechanic's lien on your property. It's probably not worth the headache for $800.
I'm not here to defend shotty workmanship, but "half*** work" is highly subjective. There are industry standards, codes, and documented best practices for all of the trades. What specifically did he cut corners on? Simply saying it was half*** and you don't like the final product isn't legal grounds for not paying the final draw.
The best way to prevent this kind of stuff in the future is to hire a reputable contractor with good referrals and references. They will probably cost more, but that's the price you gotta pay if you want quality. If you go with the cheapest bidder this is exactly what you will get 100% of the time.
I agree half*** work is highly subjective. But he also threw away my materials/extra paint/paint brushes/etc. All stuff I wanted to reuse because it cost money that I paid for. This is a waste of my money. Also he ruined the floor by spilling paint all over the floor and then they had to repaint the whole floor and they charged me for the paint when this was never in the contract. They were just messy and seemed to be cutting corners. We did not really have a contract. More so just text messages. I learned a huge lesson to have a clear contract. I guess I assumed he would understand my expectations. I thought he would take pride in his work
Mechanic Liens can only be put on your property if the person is licensed correct? This guy is only a handyman so I believe he cannot put one on. Keep in mind I am all for being fair and paying people but I do not want to pay this guy. I do not think it is fair and I understand he can go back and fix some stuff but at this point I am good to cut tides with him.
I included some pictures for reference. Let me know what you think. I want to know if I am overreacting or not lol