STR are successful with proper property management. You'll essentially be building a business. You'd have to really ensure you have boots on the ground to cover any issues that come up. When you start you'll definitely won't be spending 4-6 hours on a STR. It takes time to get your processes and people in place. Also, how often do you plan to travel to the area where the property is? You'd need to ensure you budget for travel expenses as well. LTR are more passive but it's not completely passive. Cleveland is a great market to start because it's a low entry point but with older homes that are priced lower there will be issues and headaches to deal with. A tenant turn or a large capital expense can blow your cashflow for the year. That has happened to me repeatedly with my cheaper homes. No matter what direction you take you need to have a solid team (property manager, realtor, contractor, etc) that you can trust.