Hey @Account Closed,
On a previous post in the house hacking forums I did a numbers breakdown of my house hack. We actually found it on market and we were able to finance with the 5% Fannie Mae conventional loan.
I think it depends on your overall goals and definition of success, but our house hack will absolutely help us on our wealth building/investment journey even without it being a homerun.
It is important to factor in all the benefits of house hacking into your calculations, i.e. amortization, appreciation, income, & potential rent avoidance. All of these factors can lead you well into double digit and even triple digit net-worth returns on investment (NROI).
FHA can be a great option for financing too, because of the low down payment (3.5%) and potentially more favorable interest rate terms. However, you will have PMI for life of loan most likely and there are usually higher premiums to originate FHA loan. I'd recommend speaking to a referred lender to help you understand all of your options.
@Beth Anderson mentions a great point that creative financing can be a great option. It certainly is for the right property and right terms. However, you will need to find a seller that is willing to do this and it wouldn't be a bad idea to have a professional help guide you through this process.
I will play devil's advocate and mention what kind of properties you may get creatively. I can imagine a juicy well taken care of property would not be up for grabs from another landlord. It will most likely need some level of TLC. Not necessarily a bad thing, but something to consider.
Keep at it Beth and James!