We've had rentals now for 3 years, but I didn't think the BRRR strategy was for us until this year. We decided to give it a go, and since the biggest pain in the butt of a refi is all the paperwork, we decided to do 4 houses at once since the paperwork would be the same for 4 as for 1.
1st one. A little 3 bedroom 1 bath, we paid 63k for put 12.6k down, spent about 3k on rehab. Appraised at 86k. Borrowed 64.5k, got 11k back in cash, almost our entire investment.
2nd one. A nice 2 bedroom 1 bath we paid 46k for. Put 9k down, put about 8k into it. Appraised at 85k. Borrowed 63k. put 25k in our pockets. That's all of our investment plus about 18k.
3rd one. A 3 bedroom, 1 bath we paid 70k for and put about 5k into. We put 14k down. Appraised at 130k. borrowed 97k put 40k in our pockets, all of our initial investment plus about 23k.
Last one.. The first 2 homes we bought as rentals, we bought them as a package and only had one mortgage for the 2 of them. We paid 86k for the 2 of them. Did a lot of work to one. We had 13k down and about 10k in rehab. The one we refi'd appraised at 123k. Borrowed 92.5k. Paid off the note, put 26k in our pockets and the second house is now free and clear.
So, we got all of our money back, plus about 44k, and instead of 5 houses mortgaged, we only have 4, and another one we can do some financial maneuvers with in the future.
edit.. Almost forgot to mention, our payments went down by about 60 bucks a month.