Thanks to everybody for the feedback! @Vinay H. you're right! It was a cash deal...I was in for 96k of my own money. With my other projects I have put in closer to 60-80k out of pocket and netted 15-30k, which is why I'm disappointed with this spread. That said, I didn't do any of the work myself. I work another job, in fact I actually did the whole project from Spain without ever having seen the property (that's another story!). So all in all, I can't complain...the issue I have is mostly that I feel like I should have known better...and I intend to be smarter moving forward!
To be more specific, here were some of the issues that I was hard on myself for.
1. I was wishy washy about whether I'd flip it or turn it to a rental.
2. I decided late in the renovation to replace the roof.
3. I tried doing some plumbing work without a licensed plumber and got dinged by the city...
@Nik S. my area is the same...This house sold before it hit market, and my last one sold within 24 hours...that's in a market where the average time on market is more than 90 days! So, I always feel confident that the work will sell the house quick, but sometimes worry about the appraisal. This time, our appraisal just squeaked out above the offer price.
I'm already onto my next project and I think that some of the lessons from this place will help me moving forward!