I admit I was surprised to hear so many people voice that they would shy away from this. I usually feel like BP members are tilted more towards cashflow than I am, so it was good to get some different perspectives.
It seems like I got two types of responses...people from markets where they can get that return for cheaper and they said that wasn't a good deal (surprised me) and those from higher end markets who perhaps couldn't imagine renting to somebody who might live in a house for that value. Interestingly, the house really is a pretty nice little thing. Neighborhood notwithstanding, it's a place I would have happily lived in as a bachelor or a young couple (lets be honest, as a 21 year old, I wouldn't have cared about the neighborhood either).
The house is currently rented to two people. The house is in good shape (photos below) but definitely not built in a way that it wouldn't really change much in value. The houses in that neighborhood, in my opinion, will always be about the same price.
I live out of state so it would be managed by a rental management company, but it was a good point that I would need to be sure my property manager wanted to take on this property...
Numbers would be like this:
500 income, less 50 property management, 40 taxes, 30 insurance. So that would be around 380 each month before capex, vacancy, etc. But regarding vacancies, there just simply aren't many houses in my area for 500 dollars so I really can't see it being difficult to get this rented out.
In the end, I am still a bit torn to be honest. It is a hard property to pass up, but I am likely going to pass it up anyways. This isn't the best use I can think of for 20k cash and I've got a few other irons in the fire. I considered using my bank who would do a commercial loan at 7.5% (and perhaps I still will) but at this point, I'm leaning towards not moving ahead. All the help is much appreciated and I would take any more opinions you might have!