Insurance for a Cheap Rental in Cincinnati

[Paul Gwilliam]

I just bought two very cheap houses in one deal for $26,000.  They are decent sized for the price, but they're not worth much more than the purchase price.  Maybe $20,000 each.

When it comes to insurance, I talked to my broker about it, and he could only come up with a $50k minimum policy, which is $90/mo for each property.  That's about as much as I pay for my homeowners insurance on the home I live in.  I can't help but think there has to be a better value than that.  

What other options are there?  This is my first super cheap house, but I'm sure there has to be a better option.

Thanks,