True story of a Realtor saving clients $121,000

True story of a Realtor saving clients $121,000

China, ME · Member since 2014 · 3k+ posts · 4k+ votes

I'm not a fan of wholesalers - especially those that are unlicensed and make their living by stealing equity from sellers who are uninformed or so desperate that they have to take a bad deal to get out of a jam.

Well, here's a real life story of one of those situations.  I'm the Realtor and let's call my clients Jack and Jill (not their real names).  They're a nice young couple, just starting out in life with a premature newborn and 2 1/2 year old toddler.

I met Jack and Jill a few months ago.  They came to me as buyers who were looking for their next home.  In the course of conversation, I asked them whether they were renting or had a home to sell.  Jack responded that they had an offer on their current home that they were about to accept.  It was from someone who had contacted them directly, interested in buying their home (a wholesaler).

I probed a little further.  They had a 3 bed, 2 bath ranch in West Plymouth, MA (where I also live).  It has 1,471 sq ft, an attached 1 car garage, 0.47 acre and is in a nice quiet neighborhood on a side street.  It had granite in the kitchen, hardwoods throughout and was overall in decent shape.  Plus, West Plymouth is one of the nicest parts of town.  The actual home is pictured below.

It did need some work - there was a dilapidated in-ground pool that needed to be demolished, filled in, graded and seeded (we got a quote for $3,500 and credited the eventual buyers $3,000 at closing).  The back screened in porch needed paint and the door removed or repaired.  The backsplash in the kitchen was missing.  It needed a replacement or at least paint to cover the old glue.  The carpet in the partially finished basement smelled of cats. 

All in all, no more than $5,000 in repairs.  Sadly, the sellers were not able to do the work.

I know the market here like the back of my hand.  This is an entry-level home and those are in a white-hot market segment.  In spiffed-up condition, it should sell for $360,000 - $370,000.  In this condition, $340,000 - $350,000.

The wholesaler came to their home and bamboozled them to the point that they believed that their home was a dump (it's not) and that he would make them the best offer that they would ever get. 

$223,000.

Fast forward - I ran comps for them, and the numbers revealed exactly what I thought they would.  We should list at $350,000 and expect to close between $335,000 and $350,000.  Sure enough, we closed last week at $347,000 with a $3,000 concession at closing for the pool.  That was a net of $344,000 in as-is condition.

I got true market value for my sellers which was $121,000 more than that lying thief of a wholesaler almost convinced them to take.

That kind of a loss would follow them for the rest of their lives.  They would not only lose the equity on this sale, but every subsequent home purchase would be that much less in value.  And as prices rise over time, that's $121,000 that's not growing in value.

It's true that they were not well educated on market values, but they made one mistake.  They believed the wholesaler's lies.

This is why Massachusetts and many (if not most) other states have licensing laws in to protect the public.  Licensed real estate agents cannot legally screw a seller and then instantly resell for a profit, because that's virtually indistinguishable from a net listing.  Plus, we are required to deal fairly with the public.  

But wholesalers flaunt these laws everyday.  There's virtually no enforcement here in MA, though te Board of Registration has agreed to review a test case.

I'm glad that I was able to stop this particular fraud - and yes, to make a commission too - but I wonder how many others are getting screwed right now as you're reading this.

14Reply
107 views

Most Popular Reply

Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
7y

good work Charlie..   It always cracks me up when the wholesalers on this site talk about a service they provide that agents simply cannot. its just them regurgitating some guru or others they have listened to .. there is no service a wholesaler can provide that a decent agent could not do and do better..  I call them financial sociopaths.. they could give a rip about the seller its all about them.. nothing more nothing less and they wont admit it.. LOL

See this reply in the discussion

20 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    7y

    good work Charlie..   It always cracks me up when the wholesalers on this site talk about a service they provide that agents simply cannot. its just them regurgitating some guru or others they have listened to .. there is no service a wholesaler can provide that a decent agent could not do and do better..  I call them financial sociopaths.. they could give a rip about the seller its all about them.. nothing more nothing less and they wont admit it.. LOL

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    7y

    PS I bet they send U a Christmas card every year and they give you referrals..  

  • Real Estate Broker · Naples, FL · Member since 2013 · 9k+ posts · 6k+ votes
    7y

    Charlie I refer to them as scabs. Has not gone over well with many of them LOL.

  • Niles, MI · Member since 2015 · 38 posts · 6 votes
    7y

    If a wholesaler is acting in such an abusive manner, I see no issue outing them as a warning for others in the area. It may have been a genuine mistake on their end, but I have a hard time understanding how someone could be $121,000 on home value?

  • Wholesaler · Mansfield, TX · Member since 2015 · 216 posts · 146 votes
    7y

    Actually wholesaler wasn’t super far off. Let’s say the home fixed up was worth $365,000. $365,000 x .70 = $255,000. Let’s say repairs are around $5,000-$10,000 so that brings us to $240k-$245k.

    That’s what a investor would need to buy it at with rule of thumb numbers.

    So now we factor in the wholesaler fee. At $223k he would have made around a $20kAssignment Fee. Maybe a little high or maybe not as it's about 6-7% of the ARV.

    Let me ask though How much money did the wholesaler have to spend in marketing dollars to find that lead? Why didn’t the owner reach out to a realtor instead of responding to mailer. Maybe that fees high and maybe it’s not.

    Everyone wants to bash the wholesaler but then not factor in that he wouldn’t have made $121k. He would have still needed to sell it to the investor. And he spent potentially a lot of money to get that lead.

    Ultimately I always tell my sellers if the house is perfect and they have all the time in the world call my realtor, list it on the mls, and get as much money as you can.

    If sellers distressed for one reason or another and doesn’t want to go down that route then I step in and either buy it myself or find a buyer aka Assignment at a price that is works for me. Nothings personal just business.

    Anyway just sharing my thoughts as both a fix and flip investor and a wholesaler

  • China, ME · Member since 2014 · 3k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    7y

    @Account Closed Just to be sure I understand your position, are you saying that you have no problem with:

    1. The wholesaler lying to the sellers about the value of their home?
    2. Offering $121,000 less than what the actual market value was?

    Just to clarify, they were not distressed in any way. 

    There was no hurry to sell - only a recognition that with a newborn on the way, they would like more space.  They responded to an offer that came in the mail and invited the wholesaler in.

    They listened to his pitch and were about to accept what he convinced them was "the best offer that they would ever get" at $223,000, which was $121,000 less than the actual sale price.

  • Real Estate Professional · West Palm Beach, FL · Member since 2012 · 23k+ posts · 13k+ votes
    7y

    @Account Closed You are confusing “what the property is worth as is on the open market” as opposed to “what price will a flipper pay, who is looking to make a 10-15% profit after paying hard money rates, closing costs on both ends, carrying costs, etc. and also deducting out a $20k wholesaler fee”.....two completely different “values”.

  • Flipper/Rehabber · Wilton, CT · Member since 2015 · 4k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    7y

    I just truly do not understand why you go to a wholesaling board to badmouth wholesalers. Do you seriously not agree this is getting boring and childish?  Lisenced, unlicensed.. who the hell cares anymore man. Start your own "Ihatewholesalers website for all I care and have fun there. But please.. stop..

    really.

    I wil repeat this:



    Do you seriously not agree this is getting boring and childish?

    You are not providing ANY value to this forum. Actually you are an instigator. You just want conflict. How old are you man. Gaadamnit!!

    We all know you hate  unlicensed wholesalers. And just like you could find an instance where a wholesaler did something bad, to use that to slap all "unlicensed" wholesalers is low, lame, childish and stupid. Is it illegal?? Then let the authorities deal with it.

    I can see it already all the wholesaler haters now stroking each others ego and talking each-other up.

    Let it go already dudes. Damn!

  • Asheville, NC · Member since 2017 · 170 posts · 242 votes
    7y

    @Charlie MacPherson

    If this wholesaler was your client, an investor, who came to you and said “I want to make on offer on this home. To me, it’s only worth $223k”. Would you tell your client to get lost because he’s screwing the seller? Or would you put in your clients offer and expect the seller to make their own informed decisions? (Isn’t this exactly why the seller hires a realtor? For professional advise?)

    I do agree! There are some wholesalers who’s actions are egregious.

    I just think there are more egregious things happening in real estate than individuals making low offers to homeowners without a realtor. Maybe I’m biased, Because i find my own leads and make my own offers with what a property is “worth to me” (without making representations about a retail market / or what other individuals or investors are likely to offer).

    Lying or fraud is reprehensible. Telling them they “won’t get a better offer elsewhere” is crossing a line for me. But making a lowball offer isn’t morally offensive in my opinion. If you’ve listed anything on Craigslist recently, you’ll know this is par for the course.

    And a distressed situation doesn’t make any difference in morals or ethics.

    Also! It’s fantastic you were able to help your clients get the full value of their property. I applaud you.

  • Realtor · Tempe, AZ · Member since 2017 · 541 posts · 442 votes
    7y

    It boggles my mind how people on this site want to buy properties at 70% of ARV minus repairs while at the same time wanting to make sure the home owner gets ever penny a house is worth.

  • Specialist · Nashville, TN · Member since 2019 · 187 posts · 83 votes
    7y

    @Charlie MacPherson you are so rude.

    Did anyone point a gun in their head to sell the house for 121K less?

    NO.

    It is a wholesaler offer, it is their responsibility to bring a pro to get a real estimate on their property.

    Same case I can buy an IPhone for 1300$ instead of buying a phone with same quality for 300$, does it make Apple thieves?

    just like it is my choice how to spend my money it is their choice for how much to sell their asset.

    And outing people like that that are trying to make a living is so childish, and I am not even a wholesaler.

    Funny part if you were representing a customer to buy a house and he was asking you offer below MV offer you would work so hard to get the offer and get the price there.

    And yes also agree people on this site are doing everyday what this wholesaler is doing - getting properties for 30%-50% less, thats how this business works!

    LIFE IS TOO SHORT TO HATE, BOTTOM LINE, GROW UP.

  • Specialist · Nashville, TN · Member since 2019 · 187 posts · 83 votes
    7y

    @Charlie MacPherson Funny that his profile says:

    “PS- if you’re a wholesaler who wants me to shoot out dozens of lowball offers I will do so at 200.00$ per offer..”

    Guess they are scammers when they do not lowball through you.

    Fake fake fake and rude.

  • Chris MasonPro Member
    Moderator
    Lender · CA · Member since 2015 · 9k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Mario Am:

    @Charlie MacPherson Funny that his profile says:

    “PS- if you’re a wholesaler who wants me to shoot out dozens of lowball offers I will do so at 200.00$ per offer..”

    Guess they are scammers when they do not lowball through you.

    Fake fake fake and rude.

     Eh, that's actually a polite way of saying "F you, wholesalers." It's internally consistent and rational, given that context. 

  • Wholesaler · Mansfield, TX · Member since 2015 · 216 posts · 146 votes
    7y

    Because I have a full-time W2 job, run a wholesaleing and investing business, Husband, Dad, etc I didnt have time to repond yesterday when I got the notifications about @Charlie MacPherson and @Wayne Brooks responses.

    By the time I had a chance to log in and respond @Jerryll Noorden @Lauren B. @Mario Am had already responded. I couldn't have responded much better than a combination of what those three had to say so I wont other than to say a wholesaler should not lie. I present what the properties worth to me. Most of the time it doesnt work for the seller, but 1 in around 10-20 sellers do take my offer hence my business and conversion rate.

    Anyway I'm to busy living life, running my business, etc to spend anymore time on here arguing it out with anyone. We each have our own opinions and will all answer to the man / woman upstairs for our actions one day. Live by the golden rule and all will works itself out.

    Peace Out.

  • Rental Property Investor · CA · Member since 2018 · 225 posts · 180 votes
    7y

    @Charlie MacPherson if you clients offered a similar discount to a seller would you forbid it?

  • Real Estate Broker · Naples, FL · Member since 2013 · 9k+ posts · 6k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Bryan S.:

    @Charlie MacPherson if you clients offered a similar discount to a seller would you forbid it?

     Charlie did his job. He EDUCATED the sellers as to value. Then it was their decision to accept the offer or reject it. GREAT job Charlie. 

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Bryan S.:

    @Charlie MacPherson if you clients offered a similar discount to a seller would you forbid it?

    its not up the agent to accept or reject offers for their clients.. what their job is include providing REAL data to market conditions

    and values.. once that is established then the sellers may choose to sell for whatever they want.

    what happens is sellers just don't know what they don't know and yes many times just agree to sell for a price way below market . However if presented with the facts the VAST majority would not sell for a price that leaves 6 figures on the table..  Would you ?  would any rational educated person do that ? anyone on BP do that ?

  • Realtor · Tempe, AZ · Member since 2017 · 541 posts · 442 votes
    7y

    I'd like to know how anyone on this site buys properties at way below market value while at the same time ensuring that the public is protected and that the seller gets absolute top market value for their house. Can anyone explain this to me?

  • Flipper/Rehabber · Wilton, CT · Member since 2015 · 4k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:
    Originally posted by @Bryan S.:

    @Charlie MacPherson if you clients offered a similar discount to a seller would you forbid it?

    its not up the agent to accept or reject offers for their clients.. what their job is include providing REAL data to market conditions

    and values.. once that is established then the sellers may choose to sell for whatever they want.

    what happens is sellers just don't know what they don't know and yes many times just agree to sell for a price way below market . However if presented with the facts the VAST majority would not sell for a price that leaves 6 figures on the table..  Would you ?  would any rational educated person do that ? anyone on BP do that ?

    dude listen!

    You all are simply wrong. I know you may not see it, but you honestly are! I will try to explain it so everyone can understand this for once and for all.

    First,

    We are not dealing with the "VAST" majority of people. We are dealing with people that want to sell NOW in cash. And if it is worth for them to accept a HUGE price cut for selling fast in cash who are you him her or the agent to judge, disagree or complain?

    Second,

    You all keep making the same old mistake that wholesaling = lying and taking advantage of people.

    Wholesaling is a niche, it is not a personality of a person.

    Again, we tell people exactly how much money they are leaving on the table. We tell people exactly how much they could get with an agent. YET they choose us to wholesale it as long as they can close within weeks vs months. We give them an option. And I know what you are going to say.. "You are an exception" thank you but that is completely irrelevant. We simply do wholesaling right. If the other 99.999 % does it wrong, that doesnt make it right to talk crap about wholesalers because guess what... I am one too and you are then insulting me along with all the rest of "said scumbags". 

    Now.. what is the problem here?

    If you all want to bish at wholesalers you are simply wrong. You guys are complaining about BAD people doing wholesaling wrong. That is VERY different from "Wholesalers are scumbags". I am sick and tired of people saying crap like "I hate wholesalers", "they are the scum of the earth". It is not that they are scum of the earth it is simply that whom ever makes these stupid claims is simply uneducated, (maybe just stupid?) , that doesn't know the difference between wholesaling, and a thief that wholesales. 



    what happens is sellers just don't know what they don't know and yes many times just agree to sell for a price way below market

    bla bla bla.." WRONG!! You are again describing a dishonest person trying to wholesale. This is not "Wholesaling".

    AGAIN, wholesaling is putting a house under contract and selling the contract to a cash buyer at an other price.

    Thats IT> Nothing in the definition of wholesaling describes HOW you do that. Its like a gun, guns are not bad. Bad people using guns in a bad way are bad. 

    For petes sake, I would love to believe some of you are intelligent but you all keep proving me wrong here.

    And I will say it again.. we are not dealing with the "VAST" majority of people. We are dealing with people that WANT to accept a pay cut as long as they can sell it now. Dude not everyone is money greedy. Some people choose no hassle over 6 figures. Obviously not you, but that is the point. YOU are not a desperate seller. And although we simply try to make our minimum profit, some people take as much as they can get and this is not wrong if the seller is ok with it.

    So seriously.. NONE of you have a valid point here. You all are simply manipulating a definition of a niche to paint it bad using ONE example of a bad case. 

    It is just moronic!

  • Flipper/Rehabber · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2014 · 173 posts · 121 votes
    7y

    The second deal I ever did on the open market, my offer was $120,000 cash 10 day close. There was a competing offer of $160,000 45 day.

    Seller chose my offer. Value comes in many different ways agree with 
    @Jerryll Noorden 

    Also sounds like you did your job in selling your value, to ultimately provide your value. Who knows what the actual conversation actually was between wholesaler and seller. What if he didn’t say that and the spread was lower like $5,000, $10,000 etc where does that line end of what’s acceptable. (To be fair as flip that seems like a fair spread but for adding no value that’s rediculous)

    Also maybe the wholesaler hit them with a stupid low number expecting them to negotiate...


    Side note about realtors fees/mls effectively creating price collusion 

    https://www.google.com/amp/s/w...
     

    @Account Closed agree golden rule 

    Ultimately whether your a realtor or whoever great job selling your value, making your client some more money!! All of our jobs is to bring value to people around us and pay our own bills. 

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.