Going Crazy!!! Please tell me if these are good comps

[Darius M.]

House that I'm looking to wholesale:

4bd/1ba, 1725 sqft, unfinished basement, brick, 2 car garage

I looked for similar homes between 1500-2000 sqft, but couldn't find any. But these are what I came up with:

Comp #1

- 4bd,2.5 ba, 1125 sqft, finished basement, brick, 2 car garage
- 0.6 miles away, sold for 121,000 in 5/2010
- newly rehabbed, seems like it used to be a 1ba but 1.5 bath was added

Comp #2

- 4bd,1ba, 1248 sqft, unfinished basement, brick, 2 car garage
- 1 mile away, sold for 117,000 in 6/2010
- newly rehabbed

Comp #3

- 4bd,1 ba, 1196 sqft, finished basement, brick, 2 car garage
- 0.9 miles away, sold for 140,000 in 5/2010

Any feedback would be helpful, thanks.