50 gallon vs 75 gallon water heater for an 8 bed, 3 bath SFH?

50 gallon vs 75 gallon water heater for an 8 bed, 3 bath SFH?

Member since 2021 · 22 posts · 7 votes

The water heater at my house just went out and now tenants are complaining about there being no hot water. It was almost 19 years old and has a water capacity of 50 gallons. The first hour water rating is 80 gallons. So, it's time to replace the water heater ASAP.

Initially, the house was 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms with a private bath in the master bedroom. Since I am house hacking, I added 4 more rooms for a total of 8 bedrooms. Currently, there are 5 tenants living in the house. I plan to rent out two more bedrooms, so there will be a total of 8 people in the house including me. In total, 3 people would share the upstairs bathroom, and another 3 people would share the bottom bathroom. The person in the master room would just use their private bath. This is the current showering pattern of the tenants:

Tenant A doesn't have a specific time when taking showers, but takes 1 hot shower a day and it's around 20 minutes long.

Tenant B takes one hot shower a day and it depends at what time he comes home from work.

Tenant C takes one hot shower nightly at 9pm and it's around 30-40min.

Tenant D takes one hot shower in the morning for 10-15 minutes usually.

Tenant E takes one hot shower every other afternoon for 15 minutes.

Personally, I take cold showers. There is one washer and people don't use the dishwasher. There's a total of 4 sinks.

I talked to my plumber and the quote he gave me for replacing the water heater (parts and labor) with a new Rheem 50 gallon water heater with a 6 year warranty from Home Depot is about $1450. If I opt for the 12 year warranty, the total goes up to $1650. On the other hand, getting a Rheem 75 gallon water heater with a 6 year warranty from Home Depot would total $2250. 

Based on the shower schedule data, which water heater capacity should I go with? I'm thinking it's safer to go with the 75 gallon water heater to be safe, but it's an extra $800 and I don't know if it's worth going that high if the 50 gallon will suffice.

Thanks.

0Reply
241 views

Most Popular Reply

Investor · Milwaukee - Mequon, WI · Member since 2010 · 5k+ posts · 7k+ votes
3y

You could also get a tank-less water heater, which can make endless hot water supply. My only question is who ays for the water bill? 30 minute showers....

https://www.homedepot.com/p/Rheem-Performance-Platinum-9-5-G...

See this reply in the discussion

31 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Alan AsriantsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Philadelphia, PA · Member since 2019 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    3y

    Is the cost of labor the same for replacing the 50 gallon to a 75 gallon?

    With that many people in your house, I think bigger is better. lol

    Less complaints and more hot water for everybody.

    Especially if its going to cost you the same to replace a 50 gallon to a 75 gallon.

    Which i believe it should...

    Alan Asriants - New Century Real Estate 592 Reviews
    View Page
  • Real Estate Consultant · Cleveland · Member since 2020 · 6k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    3y
    Quote from @Bruce Tieu:

    The water heater at my house just went out and now tenants are complaining about there being no hot water. It was almost 19 years old and has a water capacity of 50 gallons. The first hour water rating is 80 gallons. So, it's time to replace the water heater ASAP.

    Initially, the house was 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms with a private bath in the master bedroom. Since I am house hacking, I added 4 more rooms for a total of 8 bedrooms. Currently, there are 5 tenants living in the house. I plan to rent out two more bedrooms, so there will be a total of 8 people in the house including me. In total, 3 people would share the upstairs bathroom, and another 3 people would share the bottom bathroom. The person in the master room would just use their private bath. This is the current showering pattern of the tenants:

    Tenant A doesn't have a specific time when taking showers, but takes 1 hot shower a day and it's around 20 minutes long.

    Tenant B takes one hot shower a day and it depends at what time he comes home from work.

    Tenant C takes one hot shower nightly at 9pm and it's around 30-40min.

    Tenant D takes one hot shower in the morning for 10-15 minutes usually.

    Tenant E takes one hot shower every other afternoon for 15 minutes.

    Personally, I take cold showers. There is one washer and people don't use the dishwasher. There's a total of 4 sinks.

    I talked to my plumber and the quote he gave me for replacing the water heater (parts and labor) with a new Rheem 50 gallon water heater with a 6 year warranty from Home Depot is about $1450. If I opt for the 12 year warranty, the total goes up to $1650. On the other hand, getting a Rheem 75 gallon water heater with a 6 year warranty from Home Depot would total $2250. 

    Based on the shower schedule data, which water heater capacity should I go with? I'm thinking it's safer to go with the 75 gallon water heater to be safe, but it's an extra $800 and I don't know if it's worth going that high if the 50 gallon will suffice.

    Thanks.


     WOW, talk about overthinking, A LOT of writing to ask if you should put in a 50 or 75 Gollon, of course the bigger, Stop overthinking about such a small thing.

    Good luck 

  • Rental Property Investor · Member since 2020 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    3y

    I'm also voting go for the bigger one. Sure the 50 gallon will suffice for today with the current tenants in place but they aren't going to be here forever.  Go with the 75 gallon to avoid future hassles.  

  • Investor · Milwaukee - Mequon, WI · Member since 2010 · 5k+ posts · 7k+ votes
    3y

    You could also get a tank-less water heater, which can make endless hot water supply. My only question is who ays for the water bill? 30 minute showers....

    https://www.homedepot.com/p/Rheem-Performance-Platinum-9-5-G...

  • Member since 2021 · 22 posts · 7 votes
    3y
    Quote from @Alan Asriants:

    Is the cost of labor the same for replacing the 50 gallon to a 75 gallon?

    With that many people in your house, I think bigger is better. lol

    Less complaints and more hot water for everybody.

    Especially if its going to cost you the same to replace a 50 gallon to a 75 gallon.

    Which i believe it should...

    Cost of labor is $250 more for the bigger tank.
  • Member since 2021 · 22 posts · 7 votes
    3y
    Quote from @Bob S.:
    Quote from @Bruce Tieu:

    The water heater at my house just went out and now tenants are complaining about there being no hot water. It was almost 19 years old and has a water capacity of 50 gallons. The first hour water rating is 80 gallons. So, it's time to replace the water heater ASAP.

    Initially, the house was 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms with a private bath in the master bedroom. Since I am house hacking, I added 4 more rooms for a total of 8 bedrooms. Currently, there are 5 tenants living in the house. I plan to rent out two more bedrooms, so there will be a total of 8 people in the house including me. In total, 3 people would share the upstairs bathroom, and another 3 people would share the bottom bathroom. The person in the master room would just use their private bath. This is the current showering pattern of the tenants:

    Tenant A doesn't have a specific time when taking showers, but takes 1 hot shower a day and it's around 20 minutes long.

    Tenant B takes one hot shower a day and it depends at what time he comes home from work.

    Tenant C takes one hot shower nightly at 9pm and it's around 30-40min.

    Tenant D takes one hot shower in the morning for 10-15 minutes usually.

    Tenant E takes one hot shower every other afternoon for 15 minutes.

    Personally, I take cold showers. There is one washer and people don't use the dishwasher. There's a total of 4 sinks.

    I talked to my plumber and the quote he gave me for replacing the water heater (parts and labor) with a new Rheem 50 gallon water heater with a 6 year warranty from Home Depot is about $1450. If I opt for the 12 year warranty, the total goes up to $1650. On the other hand, getting a Rheem 75 gallon water heater with a 6 year warranty from Home Depot would total $2250. 

    Based on the shower schedule data, which water heater capacity should I go with? I'm thinking it's safer to go with the 75 gallon water heater to be safe, but it's an extra $800 and I don't know if it's worth going that high if the 50 gallon will suffice.

    Thanks.


     WOW, talk about overthinking, A LOT of writing to ask if you should put in a 50 or 75 Gollon, of course the bigger, Stop overthinking about such a small thing.

    Good luck 


     You're right, I am overthinking. Will go will 75 gallon on move on.

  • Real Estate Consultant · Cleveland · Member since 2020 · 6k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    3y
    Quote from @Bruce Tieu:
    Quote from @Alan Asriants:

    Is the cost of labor the same for replacing the 50 gallon to a 75 gallon?

    With that many people in your house, I think bigger is better. lol

    Less complaints and more hot water for everybody.

    Especially if its going to cost you the same to replace a 50 gallon to a 75 gallon.

    Which i believe it should...

    Cost of labor is $250 more for the bigger tank.

     So what, its 250 bux, 

  • Investor · CO · Member since 2016 · 757 posts · 1k+ votes
    3y

    I'd go with the bigger one or ask the plumber.

  • Investor · Buffalo, NY · Member since 2019 · 165 posts · 116 votes
    3y

    @Bruce Tieu where are you located? Price sounds high to me but could be on-par with your locale. FWIW, you can usually get a better quality product from a plumbing supply dealer, even if it is the same brand. Honestly, I’d consider doing tankless with that many people in the house. High cost, but cheaper to operate and you’ll never run out. Just my $.02

  • Member since 2021 · 22 posts · 7 votes
    3y
    Quote from @Timothy Smith:

    @Bruce Tieu where are you located? Price sounds high to me but could be on-par with your locale. FWIW, you can usually get a better quality product from a plumbing supply dealer, even if it is the same brand. Honestly, I’d consider doing tankless with that many people in the house. High cost, but cheaper to operate and you’ll never run out. Just my $.02


     Located in Aurora, Colorado. Quote for a tankless is over $5k

  • Member since 2023 · 243 posts · 199 votes
    3y

    I have a new 75 gal. It’s laughably big and the installers made a lot of grunt noises placing it into the basement. It’s one of my favorite feature about the house as it’s never run out.

    If you get the 50 gal, you’ll initially “save” but you’ll spend years and years with the inconvenience and regret and stress.

    Once you buy it, it’s yours to live with. Just choose how you want to live.

    The concept of tankless sounded great but there is maintenance on the heater coils and, for some models, there is a longer delay in getting hot water out the faucet.

  • Minneapolis, MN · Member since 2021 · 13 posts · 8 votes
    3y
    Quote from @Marcus Auerbach:

    You could also get a tank-less water heater, which can make endless hot water supply. My only question is who ays for the water bill? 30 minute showers....

    https://www.homedepot.com/p/Rheem-Performance-Platinum-9-5-G...


    Tankless all the way. 

  • Minneapolis, MN · Member since 2021 · 13 posts · 8 votes
    3y
    Quote from @Marcus Auerbach:

    You could also get a tank-less water heater, which can make endless hot water supply. My only question is who ays for the water bill? 30 minute showers....

    https://www.homedepot.com/p/Rheem-Performance-Platinum-9-5-G...


    Tankless all the way. 

  • Alecia LovelessPro Member
    Member since 2019 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    3y

    @Bruce Tieu The Bigger one for sure. All of a sudden I’m having problems with my 50 gallon hot water heater keeping up in my 8 bedroom apartment building and we’re discussing putting in an extra holding tank.

    I had an 80 gallon at my 8 bed/8 bath B&B and never had an issue even with 4 tubs and 4 showers running at once.

  • Investor · Milwaukee - Mequon, WI · Member since 2010 · 5k+ posts · 7k+ votes
    3y
    Quote from @Todd Jones:

    I have a new 75 gal. It’s laughably big and the installers made a lot of grunt noises placing it into the basement. It’s one of my favorite feature about the house as it’s never run out.

    If you get the 50 gal, you’ll initially “save” but you’ll spend years and years with the inconvenience and regret and stress.

    Once you buy it, it’s yours to live with. Just choose how you want to live.

    The concept of tankless sounded great but there is maintenance on the heater coils and, for some models, there is a longer delay in getting hot water out the faucet.


    Yes, there is maintenance, but it is less than on forced air furnace: you are supposed to clean the filter (which is a wire mesh). Technically you are supposed to flush your conventional water heater tank once a year, which is a major task, but in reality nobody does that.

    There is no significant delay between tankless than with a tank. it's mostly however long it takes for the hot water to run through the pipes to your faucet. That does not change based on how you heat the water.

    When you think about it, keeping 75 gal of water hot all the time (even when you are on vacation) and reheadingis really a crude concept, not very efficient. 

    But it is what we are used to and what everyone knows.

  • House Hacking Specialist · Denver, CO · Member since 2016 · 411 posts · 396 votes
    3y

    @Bruce Tieu congrats on the recent closing again! 

    Based on your rental strategy and capacity of tenants living there I would go with the larger water heater. 

    With this being your first big expense, I would recommend getting 1-2 more quotes. I'll DM you some referrals

    Additionally, some good points were brought up. How are you handling your utilities?

  • Rental Property Investor · Boston, Massachusetts (MA) · Member since 2016 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    3y

    With you living there I would go tankless. You should be able to deduct a good chunk of that as a rental expense, it’s a real improvement that should add value to the property. Not an accountant. 

  • Rental Property Investor · North Wales, PA · Member since 2019 · 8 posts · 4 votes
    3y

    @Bruce Tieu

    I agree with going with a plumbing supply company and not from a big box store when replacing your HWH. I just replaced one about 7 months ago with a Bradford White brand, which my plumber recommended from the plumbing supply store.

    Go with the larger capacity. It’s a no brainer, especially with the number of folks talking leisurely long showers!

  • Investor · Hopedale, MA · Member since 2021 · 321 posts · 213 votes
    3y

    just get the bigger one. it's not that big of a price difference in the grand scheme of things, and you're also gonna be using HW for laundry, dishwasher, dishes, etc. you'll be raking it in with all those rooms rented so i think you can handle it hahah. kudos to you!

  • Member since 2021 · 22 posts · 7 votes
    3y
    Quote from @Ben Einspahr:

    @Bruce Tieu congrats on the recent closing again! 

    Based on your rental strategy and capacity of tenants living there I would go with the larger water heater. 

    With this being your first big expense, I would recommend getting 1-2 more quotes. I'll DM you some referrals

    Additionally, some good points were brought up. How are you handling your utilities?


    Each tenant is paying a fixed amount of $50 for utilities.

  • Member since 2021 · 22 posts · 7 votes
    3y
    Quote from @Jonathan R McLaughlin:

    With you living there I would go tankless. You should be able to deduct a good chunk of that as a rental expense, it’s a real improvement that should add value to the property. Not an accountant. 


     Ended up going with the 75 gallon water heater. I'll look into tankless water heaters for the next property. Thanks!

  • Member since 2021 · 22 posts · 7 votes
    3y
    Quote from @Jessie Dillon:

    just get the bigger one. it's not that big of a price difference in the grand scheme of things, and you're also gonna be using HW for laundry, dishwasher, dishes, etc. you'll be raking it in with all those rooms rented so i think you can handle it hahah. kudos to you!


     Thanks Jessie. Ended up going with the bigger tank as others have suggested.

  • Real Estate Broker · Minneapolis, MN · Member since 2011 · 5k+ posts · 6k+ votes
    3y

     None of the above. 

    I would be going with an on-demand water heater, wouldn't even second guess it, would only look at on-demand system. 

  • Colleen F.Pro Member
    Investor · Narragansett, RI · Member since 2013 · 8k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    3y

    @Bruce Tieu when you consider on demand heat source seems to water.  We had on demand electric and it was great. On demand propane is just terrible, not sure why.  But 75 gallons was a good call for so many people.

  • Realtor · Charlotte, NC · Member since 2017 · 359 posts · 293 votes
    3y

    Honestly. For 8 people, tankless would be the best option. Hot water is not something that is an unreasonable demand, and with adding two more people, it sounds like you'd be putting a big load on that water heater. Just my two cents. It's more expensive, but your tenants will appreciate it.

    Just out of curiosity, how big is this house?!

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.