Warning : Horrible Property Manager in Milwaukee

[Brie Schmidt]

I made the mistake of hiring Renters Warehouse in Milwaukee as my property manager ( @Andrew Noegel ) .  They took over May 1 and from the get go the communication was terrible.  I have to ask multiple people multiple times to answer simple questions with no response for weeks.  

We decided to terminate our contract within the first 30 days because it wasn't fixable, and they acted surprised and wanted a chance to fix it.  Nothing changed and we fired them for the second time in 6 weeks.  It is scary to think these people are responsible for investors and property management.  I am still fighting to get my keys and security deposits back from them!  Beware!

12 years as a landlord and 9 years as a managing broker and I have never in my life had to deal with such an awful company

[Marcus Auerbach]

A word of caution. Not every good property manager is a good fit for every property. So your experience can differ, depending on what type of property you have. Every one of the Milwaukee PMC's has their focus and strength depending on geography, demographics, rent range - so it is not as simple as "who is the best PM", the real question is "who is the best choice for your particular property. But also, if you do this long enough, you do see patterns on which companies getting a lot of complaints..