What questions do you ask in the pre-screen, for potential tenants?🤔

Question

Hello BP community, I self manage my properties and will be soon completing a full gutt renovation. I am looking to open a conversation about the pre-screening for potential tenants. I currently have a 25 questions page to be filled by every potential tenant. After I interview them it will be decided who will go to the next step which is having them do thier background and credit check. What questions do you ask in the pre-screening? And how many properties did you have, when you decided to handed to a property management company?

Thank you all in advance for your input!

Happy investing!

Charles Carillo · Answer

@Sergio A. Chucaralao I have never done a pre-screening questionnaire, or even heard of it. When I self-managed C Class properties, I would put the requirements for tenancy in the rental listing (3x rent in income, 1-month security deposit, criminal check, etc.), and then when the potential tenants called in, I would speak to them for a few minutes, explain the requirements, get some sort of verbal confirmation on some or all of the requirements, and then invite them to different showing times I had set up. If they liked the apartment, they could apply (pay the application fee per adult, and complete the application), and I would perform screening, and provide an answer within 24-48 hours. This process allows for a few different filters. First is the initial call. You will filter out people just by talking to them for a couple of minutes (people trying to negotiate your terms, storytelling, or people being just plain rude). The next filter is them showing up at the set time for the apartment showing. I usually would put the appointments 15 minutes apart, and do a few at once unless I get a very good feeling about an applicant. The next filter is them applying. They like the unit, they like the neighborhood, etc., and they are willing to apply. They are putting money out there to get approved. The final filter is your screening after they formally apply. With C Class properties, you will start with a large funnel to get it down to a couple of actual people showing up to see the unit (and no one else will call to formally cancel). The goal of this whole process is to find good tenants who will pay rent on time, respect the property, and respect their neighbors.

Sergio A. Chucaralao · Answer

Thank your for your answer, definitely agree with you. That is why I only ask yes or no questions which are the same ones I go over the phone to look for consistency.

Lynn McGeein · Answer

@Sergio A. Chucaralao I have a set email response for inquiries that states my typical qualifications, attaches my application, states if they meet those requirements, I’m scheduling appointments x date between 12-3, send preferred time and I’ll confirm, and that I do not accept applications until after meeting at the appointment. If asked, I tell them I’ll discuss possible minor exceptions to typical qualifications at appointment, but absolutely no judgments or evictions. I overbook as usually a few no-shows. If they say they can’t make that day, I let them know I’ll set up another date if an applicant is not accepted from this session. I don’t really want the ones who are already being difficult before they apply, so helps to weed them out.

Greg Scott · Answer

We don't have a pre-screening process. We do screening.Unless you have specific, written criteria for what constitutes acceptable answers to the 25 questions, you open yourself up for a Fair Housing violation complaint. Having an open-ended interview process with no set criteria sounds like an easy way for an attorney to argue for discrimination, whether or not any actually occurred.

Sergio A. Chucaralao · Answer

Thank you for taking the time to reply, I was curious to see how other landlords pre-screen or screen potential tenants.

DaVaughn Reed · Answer

This is a great response and very helpful!

Colleen F. · Answer

@Sergio A. Chucaralao the only pre-screening I ask is number of people, number and type of animals, number of vehicles, and do you smoke? If they volunteer anything else I make note of it. After they answer I review key points in the ad. I do it this way because I often get people who want to look at things and haven't read the ad. They either don't qualify, misjudge what is acceptable occupancy, or didn't read key points about the property. I added the vehicle question after getting people with 3 vehicles for 1 bedroom apartments. Then you have the 4 cats... I am not sure I could come up with 25 questions though.

Richard F. · Answer

Aloha,You are definitely losing out on otherwise perfectly good prospects with your full interrogation before they even view the property. Keep in mind, Fair Housing. Limit an initial conversation or questionnaire to no more than 3 to 5 questions:What is total household gross income?How many Adults (of local, legal, age...18, 20, 21) ? (do not ask about children, should not matter at this point) How soon do you hope to move?How long have you lived in your current residence, and is it within this (City, Region, State)?Have you ever been evicted or not renewed, or do you have current Collection items?Be sure your marketing and your application include whether you have a pets/no pets policy; assistance animal policy; ALL adults must complete application and will be named on the Rental Agreement; utility responsibilities; SD requirement; when and how various funds are due (app fee, SD, initial rent, etc).

Michael Smythe · Answer

25 questions?You are over-thinking the process and will be sitting on vacancies as the market slows and tenants become harder to find.Get a YTD paystub, last year's W-2, recent bank statement, government picture ID and SSN card. Run a background check and evaluate the SAME way every time to avoid Fair Housing lawsuit.

Sergio A. Chucaralao · Answer

Thank you for taking the time to answer my question, it is very similar of what I do. I only ask yes or no questions example : do you have proof of funds? Do you have any pets? Do you have any eviction? Are you currently employed?. The reason why I do it this way is because I do a open house style, for showings.