My 5 Intuitions Surrounding Investing in 2020

My 5 Intuitions Surrounding Investing in 2020

Real Estate Consultant · Kansas City, MO · Member since 2013 · 388 posts · 200 votes

With a professional career in real estate investment and management in the small investor space, I have had the privilege to witness many pivots to the industry. I have seen economic busts and impacts. I currently managed over $50M in real estate property management assets with dozens and dozens of clients. I have been involved in several hundred transactions of small, usually SFR, real estate transactions over the last 16 years. This is a short run list on why I believe I can share MY expectations of real estate in 2020. This is NOT designed to be about COVID-19, but it is the news story of the year and plays an important role in the conversation. All of this experience has come from the Kansas City, MO market area, but the insights are likely similar across many middle markets, and potentially beyond.

So, MY 5 Intuitions of Real Estate in 2020

C class is prime for a spike -
C class is prime for a spike because of economic fear.  Many millions of people have been impacted by the pandemic economically.  Many of them have witnessed or weathered 2008.  In the years since 2008, there has been a very steady growth of comfort surrounding stability and the expectation of economic safety.  The paycheck to paycheck class has gathered confidence over more than a decade that they could comfortably afford more and more.  With the immediate impacts of the pandemic, that realization immediately vanished.  Statistically speaking, we have a very strong leasing season in the "middle" (Kansas City is in the middle of America).  Our season typically starts in late February, gathers tremendous strength through the spring and into early summer.  This year, during the stay at home orders, we have seen a significant increase in the number of inquiries for class C properties.  In fact, we are currently receiving 5 leads for C class for every one lead for A/B class.  We also have more A/B class properties managed and available currently than C.  So, my intuition is that C class will continue to be in high demand for a few years as people determine their new economic realities.  Well managed C class is prime for strong years ahead.  More about A/B later....

SFR investing will be more important than MFH -- Think social distancing. Think millennials raising families. Fenced yards, green grass, and fresh air, and maybe cheap gas. Over the half decade (longer in some markets) we have seen a surge in MFH construction in downtown areas. A resurgence, even much needed, to bring residents to the center of life, action, work, and play designed around inner neighborhoods. The millennial surge created significant markets, many prime with increasingly strong, disposable incomes. Those same 20-somethings +/-, are turning 30, getting married, having children, and....moving back to suburbia. We dont have statistics on this, but intuitively, we are seeing a measurable increase in the number of applicants moving to our suburban neighborhoods. Some of this is for the fenced yards, green grass, fresh air, but a lot of it also revolves around the school systems. Not unlike many Secondary markets in the country, KC has a struggling school system in the middle and the decades strong suburban schools continue to thrive and flourish. Back to the point surrounding social distancing. With a great need for space and desire to share anything together at the moment with a stranger, the same lies true with housing. Many multifamily residents are seeking refuge of "safety" in an SFR, regardless of the location. This pandemic marketing season has been very strong for our SFR class, with slower traction on our few MFH listings. Personally, my downtown dwelling, millennial child, has a career now in a primary market, A class MFH community and lives in another. Both buildings have a case of COVID and these are very concerning to this 20-something.

Real Estate will see minimal impact from this recession -- Lets face it, 2008 was caused by the real estate (mortgage) industry.  The mortgage melt down and the resulting real estate crash were the effects of the very cause.  In 2020, we will see a recession from this pandemic, but I believe that very little will impact real estate.  Will there be foreclosures, most definitely, but nothing close to the scale of 2008.  Further, the stimulus provided for this event is substantially stronger than the stimulus provided to prop up the economy in 2008.  Between a lack of cause and the economic prop, I believe that real estate will see very little overall impact.  Sales are significantly down in terms of numbers, but that is not being reflected in sales price, only volume.  In fact, there are more buyers for the limited inventory, which in other years would indicate appreciation.  Without a big history lesson, we are due for a small correction, but not necessarily a large recession.  Will there be opportunities?  Probably, but not in vast numbers, IMHO.  Will we all lose years of appreciation?  Unlikely.  More on this topic in the next.

A/B Class will see significant stability -- Each marketing cycle, it is typical for a reasonable range of residents to buy a house instead of continuing to rent.  Interest rates are designed to be significantly low as a result of the pandemic, but to obtain a loan in the current environment, has become substantially more difficult.  Some of the nations largest lenders have sharply tightened standards.  Some requiring 20% down and 700+ credit scores.  This will limit the number of tenant class that will be able to purchase, some for years to come.  Other constraints come from a limited supply as fewer sellers are willing to allow in person showings of their homes, and therefore, are choosing to stay in place longer.  Because of these constraints and the fear of the market that will likely last fresh in our minds for a few years, I believe there will be fewer A/B class residents buying houses over the next few years, which will continue to support the current inventory of this class.  

Biggest Winners/Biggest Losers -- As always, sideline investors regret sidelining opportunity.  Be smart, be safe, but be investors.  As mentioned, I believe that MFH will see a slowing impact from this market.  I believe that the SFR class, formulated around upgraded and well maintained assets, will flourish for several years to come. Many would be homeowners will be looking for more "home" and less "house.

Always open for conversation.  Share your thoughts and ask questions.  My goal from my 7 years on BP is to help educate where I can, within the constraints of managing our real estate company.  Be well, be wise.

11Reply
23 views

Most Popular Reply

Investor · UT · Member since 2020 · 84 posts · 91 votes
6y

@William Robison thanks for the thoughtful, informed post. In the KC area, I assume C class properties don't really appreciate very much? Do you have any thoughts on areas that will show a short term drop in prices and/or have some built in appreication?

See this reply in the discussion

10 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Real Estate Agent · Kansas City · Member since 2018 · 4k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    6y

    @William Robison

    Great points!

  • Steven MayBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Kansas City, MO · Member since 2018 · 262 posts · 250 votes
    6y

    @William Robison

    Couldn’t agree more! Real estate has been booming last couple of years and it’s easy to get lackadaisical with your systems when everything is going right. I could argue this short hiccup in the economy is what many investors needed for a refresher to strap down any loose ends and to get ready for the next big surge in demand.

    Mortgage industry hopefully will continue to see these low rates.

    I see you work with out of state investors. Do you ever see Kansas City becoming over saturated with investors and with continual tech boom going on, are you worried about sudden increases of cost of living in comparison to places like San Fran and Boulder, CO?

  • Investor · NV and CA · Member since 2016 · 373 posts · 227 votes
    6y

    @William Robison- Thank you for your insights.  

    For C class properties, are you seeing tenants who could qualify for A / B class units downtrend into C class?  Is that how fear is translating into more interest in C class?

  • Real Estate Consultant · Kansas City, MO · Member since 2013 · 388 posts · 200 votes
    6y

    @Steven May

    Yes, it is absolutely a great opportunity to tighten systems and processes.  There is likely to be a boom in opportunity, not just from a buying standpoint, but also from a demand standpoint.  I doubt the windfall of opportunity will measure some expectations though. 

    My opinion of mortgage rates are that they are here to stay for a while.  I think we have 12+ months of rates in this range.  Not only from a recovery standpoint, but also from a politically influenced perspective.

    Yes, we operate a hybrid turnkey company through Plaid Management for mostly our of state investors.  Could KC become saturated?  Certainly. I doubt it will hit the level of a primary city level, but we could eventually reach the levels of Denver.  I think we are distanced from that spot.  Part of the Denver/Boulder market are land constraints that we do not have, so we have continued ability to grow and infrastructure in place for such.  

  • Investor · UT · Member since 2020 · 84 posts · 91 votes
    6y

    @William Robison thanks for the thoughtful, informed post. In the KC area, I assume C class properties don't really appreciate very much? Do you have any thoughts on areas that will show a short term drop in prices and/or have some built in appreication?

  • Real Estate Broker · Kansas City Metro · Member since 2015 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y

    @Cj Powderhorn

    C properties in B areas appreciate fast in the urban core of KC. C properties in independence, raytown, grandview etc...may take a bit longer to appreciate but still are growing. It is a growing progressive city with all sorts of job sectors that support it. Hope that helps!

  • Real Estate Consultant · Kansas City, MO · Member since 2013 · 388 posts · 200 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Ryan Fox:

    @William Robison- Thank you for your insights.  

    For C class properties, are you seeing tenants who could qualify for A / B class units downtrend into C class?  Is that how fear is translating into more interest in C class?

    Ryan..that is our expectation.  Would be C move up tenants are slowing pace and staying put, just as A/B is yielding away from buying.  Some B class residents who over committed are moving back to C class proactively.  We are currently experiencing this trend with some of our residents and transitioning some of them to less expensive options, while retaining the good resident history when available.  

  • Real Estate Consultant · Kansas City, MO · Member since 2013 · 388 posts · 200 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Cj Powderhorn:

    @William Robison thanks for the thoughtful, informed post. In the KC area, I assume C class properties don't really appreciate very much? Do you have any thoughts on areas that will show a short term drop in prices and/or have some built in appreication?

    As Alex mentioned, several areas of the urban zone C class stand to have better appreciation than some suburban C class areas.  These would be those that are in or very near gentrification zones.  Sometimes, this is a speculative class to be considered.  But, C class in the urban zones typically are in the lowest rated school districts as opposed to suburban C class that may benefit from better schools comparatively.  For many years, there has been an exodus of residents from urban zone C class to that of the suburban neighbors with better rated schools.  

    Mathematically speaking, all classes have seen a substantial increase in return of valuation, and followed by appreciation with move up residents.  Areas near the gentrification areas, appreciation has been much stronger.

  • Investor · UT · Member since 2020 · 84 posts · 91 votes
    6y

    @William Robison

    'C properties in B areas appreciate fast in the urban core of KC', what zipcodes/areas are these? Thanks!

  • Real Estate Consultant · Kansas City, MO · Member since 2013 · 388 posts · 200 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Cj Powderhorn:

    @William Robison

    'C properties in B areas appreciate fast in the urban core of KC', what zipcodes/areas are these? Thanks!

    We have a map of these that we share.  Feel free to message me directly and I can get you the map.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.