Turning $55k into $1M+ [CONTINUED using BRRRR]

[Steven Baca]

Expert advice needed!!

I bought a townhouse in 2016 for $95k and have been renting it out since 2018 (creating ~$300+ monthly cash flow), as of today current mortgage due us $74k.  This townhouse has now appreciated to a value of ~$140k.

I bought a 3bd/1.5 bath home in 2019 for $113k, rehabbed it for 3 years and sold it for cash ($165,5k) and walked away with ~$55k in cash which I closed 9/2/22.

I just started reading the BRRRR book two days ago and need some solid advice on the direction I should take as this could narrow my road to that $1M+ goal sooner...

Which option should I take?

Option 1: HELOC/ Cash Back refinance my townhome and pull out enough equity to add to my $55k in purchasing a 2nd property? With rates being as high as they are this is a worrisome option

-OR-

Option 2:  Pull out $19k from my 401k, add that to my $55k and pay off the townhouse note. Invest a small amount of capital into it by adding some make up and then refinance it in order to purchase my second investment property?

My current situation: I just moved my family of 3 into my folks home while making this next investment transition and would like to have my next property by end of year.  My tenant moves out of townhome on 11/11/22 which I plan to move my family into the townhome for a 6-8month stint until a 3rd property is purchased which would be out slow-2-3yr-primary-residence-rehab-project.

Any straight forward advice would be GREATLY APPRECIATED. Or if there is a 3rd option I'm missing please indulge me!

Thank you in advance BP colleagues!