1st Rental Prop Insured today and quoted $134/month! expensive?

[Joshua Wilson]

Details, older house, 1910, but newly renovated, I know there's tons of variables that go into homeowners insurance but for a house valued less than 80k, $1,700 annual insurance seemed extremely high to me. That's with highest deductibles and minimum coverage. 

This is in Indianapolis. Can someone point me in the direction of a local insurer that has cheaper rates?