Best Landlord insurance quotes in Toledo, OH

[Tadek Stadniczuk]

Hello - Can anybody recommend reasonable insurance companies for a duplex rental property?

I currently have my other property (single family rental) and my home owners through Liberty Mutual and the rates are decent.  But for my new purchase they quoted me $2400 for it! It is a 1700 square foot duplex that I am buying for a measly $45,000.  

I also ran it through Travlers insurance and they quoted $1200.  That's better but I expected around $700 or so.  My other rental is only $600 a year.

Anybody have any recommendations?  Thanks.