Is tenant responsible - need opinions

[Brian Karlow]

I need some opinions from the community....

My tenant informed me today the front door was kicked in by her daughter's 19 year old boy friend when she would not allow him into the home. Upon arriving home from work, my tenant called the police and filed charges. A warrant has been put out for his arrest and police are actively pursuing his apprehension.

Is the tenant responsible for the cost associated with the required repairs? The reason for him even being at the property was the result of a relationship with the tenant's daughter; however it was against her will and a criminal act. 

Let me know what everyone thinks....I really appreciate your feedback.

Thanks

[Jorge Rullan]

It is going to depend on how your lease is written. Your tenant should be responsible for intentional damage not caused by normal wear and tear.  That is also why landlords take security deposits.  This is more of a who's liable question.  First, your tenant is responsible for the property, so if the lease has the right wording, she would be responsible for repairs.  Now, she can request the presiding judge order restitution as part of the judicial process.  Either way, at the end of the day,  it depends on your lease and what type of landlord you are. Good luck and definitely seek the advise of an attorney.