HELP! Need CPA Accountant Tax Preparer ASAP!

[Arjun K.]

I followed a referral for tax preparation from BiggerPockets and its been a disaster. It's May 4th and don't know where my tax preparation stands; except that I belatedly submitted a payment voucher and I believe a tax extension was sent.

So I am back on the site asking for recommendations! I prefer someone East of Mississippi. Ideally in NY metro area. But really someone who is communicative and doesn't drop balls. Someone who is not good, but GREAT. Who is not overly stretched. Who doesn't kick the tax work down the chain and thus really has no control over the process.

I am in NY, the properties are in TX, and I have mainly W-2 income. I have all of my documents really well organized. I am looking for someone to do both my, and my father-in-laws, W-2 & property income taxes.

THANK YOU IN ADVANCE!