Skip to content
Get started
Resources & Media
Resource Hub Bookstore Blog Guides Pro-Exclusives PRO Podcasts Pro Partnerships Newsletters NEW
Events & training
BPCON2025 Webinars Bootcamps Upcoming Events Free Courses
Strategies
How to Manage Your Rental Property How to Operate a Short-Term Rental How to Passively Invest in Real Estate How to House Hack How Does the BRRRR Method Work How to Flip a House How to Invest in Commercial Real Estate How to Invest in Real Estate How to Invest in Multifamily Real Estate How to Build Wealth
BPCON2025
This is your chance to learn from the best, network with the best, and become one of the best in the game.
Build Wealth Without Tenants
Become a stronger passive investor with proven frameworks, actionable insights, and lots of networking.
Pick markets
Pick markets
Market Finder - NEW PRO Picking a Market Workshop PRO Picking a Market Worksheet Top 100 Cash Flow Markets Market Insights - Sunbelt Region
Market finder
Pinpoint the best real estate market for your specific goals with expert recommendations and real-time data on appreciation, affordability, rent to price ratio, and more.
Find deals
Find deals
On-Market Deal Finder - New PRO Off-Market Deal finding PRO Real Estate Syndications Investor-Friendly Agents Find Foreclosures Community Listings (FSBO) Business Directory
Deal finder
Quickly find your perfect investment property based on your cash flow and ROI goals.
Invelo - Off market deals
Scale your portfolio with off-market deals
Analyze deals
Calculators
Rental Property Calculator PRO Rehab Estimator PRO Rent Estimator PRO BRRRR PRO Fix & Flip PRO Short-Term Rental PRO Sell vs. Keep PRO Landlord Insurance Calculator by Steadily All Calculators
Rental property calculator
Is it a good deal? Run your numbers like a pro with this simple yet powerful calculator.
Rent estimator
Understand how much rental income you can expect based on recent reports and data for your specific property.
Manage properties
Manage properties
Managing Properties 101 Find a Property Manager RentRedi Property Management Software PRO Property Management Tools Ask a Management Question Finding Tenants PRO Screening Tenants PRO Leases + Landlord Forms PRO Accounting/Bookkeeping PRO Property Insurance Property Maintenance / Rehab PRO Baselane Banking and AI Bookkeeping
Property management software
Manage tenants, tasks, and your entire portfolio with one simple tool.
Property manager finder
Find reliable property management partnerships that last.
Forums
For You
Newest Trending Unanswered My Discussions Followed Discussions Followed Categories Followed Locations Followed People
General Real Estate
General Real Estate Investing Starting Out Deal Analysis Buying & Selling Business & Marketing Landlording Property Management Reviews & Feedback
Real Estate Strategies
House Hacking BRRRR Short-Term Rentals Mid-Term Rentals Multi-Family Fix & Flip Other Strategies
Finance & Financing
Lending Creative Finance Personal Finance Taxes & Legal Issues
News & Announcements
Official Site Announcements Market Trends & Data Real Estate News & Current Events Pro Exclusive Area PRO
Events & Networking
Events & Meetups Classifieds
Store
All Books
Best Sellers Browse All New Books & Pre-Orders PRO Bundle & Save Books for Beginners
Flip your way to financial freedom
Scale your investment framework with this valuable guide to compounding real estate success.
Outsmart the short-term rental competition
Cash in on the exploding STR market with this must-have guide from expert Avery Carl.
Pricing
Plans and Pricing
Pro Membership Business Membership
TRY PRO FOR 7 DAYS COMPLETELY FREE
Avoid mistakes and make informed decisions with Pro.
GROW YOUR BUSINESS
Promote your business on BiggerPockets and make quality connections with the right investors
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 54%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$69 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Take Your Forum Experience
to the Next Level
Create a free account and join over 3 million investors sharing
their journeys and helping each other succeed.
btn_google_dark_normal_ios Created with Sketch.
Continue with Google
Continue with Apple
Use your real name
By signing up, you indicate that you agree to the BiggerPockets Terms & Conditions.
Already a member?  Login here
Followed Discussions Followed Categories Followed People Followed Locations
General Real Estate Investing
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
Market Trends & Data
Buying & Selling Real Estate
Out of State Investing
Real Estate News & Current Events
Real Estate Technology
Investor Mindset
General Info
BiggerPockets Exclusive PRO Area
PRO
General Real Estate Investing
BPCON
New Member Introductions
Questions About BiggerPockets & Official Site Announcements
Off Topic
Starting Out
Real Estate Success Stories
Real Estate Horror Stories
Real Estate Strategies
House Hacking
Commercial Real Estate Investing
BRRRR - Buy, Rehab, Rent, Refinance, Repeat
Innovative Strategies
Mobile Home Park Investing
Multi-Family and Apartment Investing
Land & New Construction
Wholesaling
Rehabbing & House Flipping
Short-Term & Vacation Rental Discussions presented by
Tax Liens & Mortgage Notes
Medium-Term Rentals
Buying & Selling Small Businesses
Outdoor Hospitality
Landlording & Rental Properties
General Landlording & Rental Properties
Managing Your Property
Marketing Your Property
Tenant Screening
First-Time Home Buyer
Real Estate Professionals
Mortgage Brokers & Lenders
Contractors
Real Estate Agent
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Creative Real Estate Financing presented by
Personal Finance
Private Lending & Conventional Mortgage Advice
Insurance
Tax, SDIRAs & Cost Segregation presented by
Foreclosures
1031 Exchanges presented by
Goals, Business Plans & Entities
Legal & Legislation
Real Estate Classifieds
Classifieds
Real Estate Events & Meetups
Reviews & Feedback
Ask About A Real Estate Company
Real Estate Deal Analysis & Advice
Guru, Book, & Course Reviews
Syndications & Passive Real Estate Investing

Updated over 3 years ago on . Most recent reply

Kenny Hall's profile image
Kenny Hall's profile image
Kenny Hall
  • Property Manager
  • from Indianapolis, IN
  • Member since Aug 25, 2020
Connect

User Stats

121
Posts
62
Votes
Kenny Hall's profile image
Kenny Hall's profile image
Kenny Hall
  • Property Manager
  • from Indianapolis, IN
  • Member since Aug 25, 2020
Connect
Kenny Hall
  • Property Manager
  • Indianapolis, IN
62
Votes |
121
Posts
General Real Estate Investing

Decision: Flip it or Buy and Hold?

Kenny Hall
  • Property Manager
  • Indianapolis, IN
Posted

I have a property under contract in Indianapolis and trying to decide if I should flip it or keep it as a rental.

What criteria do you look at when deciding between the two? Do you account for taxes in your analysis? Other fees like agent commissions or property management fees?

I’d like to build a model that would be easy to plug in a property’s estimated numbers and it tell me if it will be a better flip or buy and hold investment. Looking for your thoughts to consider while I build this out. Thanks!

1 Vote
Follow
4 Replies
Jump to Last Reply
Log In or Sign Up to Reply

Most Popular Reply

Nick Giulioni's profile image
Nick Giulioni's profile image
Nick Giulioni
  • Rental Property Investor
  • from Carmel, IN
  • Member since Aug 25, 2016
Connect

User Stats

1,198
Posts
590
Votes
Nick Giulioni's profile image
Nick Giulioni's profile image
Nick Giulioni
  • Rental Property Investor
  • from Carmel, IN
  • Member since Aug 25, 2016
Connect
Nick Giulioni
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Carmel, IN
590
Votes |
1,198
Posts
Nick Giulioni
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Carmel, IN
Replied

Hi Kenny, I'm a flipper myself. I would love to give you insights and share my thoughts if you're interested.

  • Nick Giulioni
    • 3 Votes
    Log In or Sign Up to Reply
    Sort By:

    Loading replies...