Is a paid roof inspection more credible than "free estimate"?

[Dean Ng]

I had a property tented for termites, which broke some concrete roof tiles.  I got free repair estimates (inspections) from two roofing companies.  The first estimator, who climbed on the roof, said there were 70+ tiles broken.  The second guy, who used a drone and didn't climb on the roof, said there were 15-20 broken. 

That's a big discrepancy.  I don't know who to believe, so I'm considering paying for a RE roof inspection.  There is a company in Calif called HomeGuard that listing agents use for pre-sale inspections.   Would a paid roof inspection be more credible than a "free estimate" from roofing companies?   HomeGuard is not cheap so I want to make sure this is worth spending money on.

[Michael Diossa]

My guess. the guy who said less tiles is probably the cheaper option. Possible his drone showed the most evident damage and not so much like being on the roof. (is there any reviews or history on his business online)

The inspector that said 70+ is probably one of those everything needs to be replaced don't risk type, however will probably be the more expensive guy. Look at reviews and years in the business.

Regarding paid inspections ....Not quite sure. I do think you can't go wrong with home guard.