Investor · San Jose, CA · Member since 2012 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
Hi BP veterans,
My buddy and I were fortunate enough and bought a couple of handful properties in the San Francisco Bay Area in the recent years. Since they have appreciated substantially, we're thinking of 1031 some of these into income producing properties. Looks like we might have to go out of state to achieve this goal.
If you have an option, would you buy 4-plexes or bigger? We have about two to three hundred of equity in each property. So every two sales would generate about a half mil.
Thoughts on where to buy and what size of complex we should look into?
What's you and your buddy's goal?? Hold for retirement with little cash flow, hold for mainly cash flow, or do another value play where you sell in a few years??
I have clients all over the country and some international. They look to Atlanta for yield and also other states as well. I work with them all over the country for multifamily.
If you are planning on buying out of state I certainly do not recommend buyer a duplex, tri-plex, four plex etc.
What you need is about a minimum of 50 units or more. You can have a full time manager that way and a maintenance person. Costs here you can land a per unit cost of about 500 to 600 rent for between 25,000 a door to 50,000 a door. The cost difference is in the tenant base, location, and age of the buildings, and construction type (all brick, hardi-plank, etc.)
Most deals are leveraged in multifamily. My typical deals right now if you have 600,000 to invest together for the 1031 you can go up to 6 million in purchase price.
10% buyer down
15% seller second
75% bank first mortgage
Rates on fully performing about a 10 year term with 25 year amort. at around 4.25% fixed. By leveraging you increase your cash on cash returns going in.
Anymore questions just ask. You can go from 4 to 5 million and set the rest of the cash as reserves if desired. Also if you are willing to partner with others you can take down and even larger newer building hundreds of units.
What's you and your buddy's goal?? Hold for retirement with little cash flow, hold for mainly cash flow, or do another value play where you sell in a few years??
I have clients all over the country and some international. They look to Atlanta for yield and also other states as well. I work with them all over the country for multifamily.
If you are planning on buying out of state I certainly do not recommend buyer a duplex, tri-plex, four plex etc.
What you need is about a minimum of 50 units or more. You can have a full time manager that way and a maintenance person. Costs here you can land a per unit cost of about 500 to 600 rent for between 25,000 a door to 50,000 a door. The cost difference is in the tenant base, location, and age of the buildings, and construction type (all brick, hardi-plank, etc.)
Most deals are leveraged in multifamily. My typical deals right now if you have 600,000 to invest together for the 1031 you can go up to 6 million in purchase price.
10% buyer down
15% seller second
75% bank first mortgage
Rates on fully performing about a 10 year term with 25 year amort. at around 4.25% fixed. By leveraging you increase your cash on cash returns going in.
Anymore questions just ask. You can go from 4 to 5 million and set the rest of the cash as reserves if desired. Also if you are willing to partner with others you can take down and even larger newer building hundreds of units.
If you have an option, would you buy 4-plexes or bigger?
That depends Minh...
Are you comfortable with commercial properties?
Do you want do go into commercial properties (over 4 units)?
How do you feel about exchanging into several new fourplexes?
Returns are very favorable in states like Texas and the mid-west.
My buddy and his wife will relocate to Brazil later this year. They can live comfortably with $3k to $4k down there. For me, I need a lot more since I'm staying here. We're primarily looking for cash flow at this point. Basically, we want to convert our appreciation play into income play. The ROE is really low given most of our holdings have almost doubled in value.
As much as we don't believe interest rate will rise above 5% in the foreseeable future, we're a little leery about commercial properties due to the fact that you have to refinance every 5 years or so. Perhaps it's our lack of knowledge that's holding us back.
We have thought of liquidating everything and buying a multi-plex for cash then do a cash-out refinance to tap the equity tax-free for now. That way, we have more control of what to do next with the money instead of being constrained with 45 and 180 days of 1031 exchange rules. What kind of cash-on-cash return do you typically see with leveraged?
Marco Santarelli,
We checked out your website a couple of weeks ago. We can buy two of your 4plexes with one of our sale, and that would increase our cash-flow significantly. At this point, we're still studying several markets to see where we would put our money.
We welcome suggestions for other markets. Let us know if you don't mind a little competition in your market.
When it comes to fourplexes specifically, I don't know of any competition. That doesn't mean there isn't any, but you don't see a lot of builders constructing fourplexes these days. (That will change though.)
Outside of Saint Robert (MO) and San Antonio (TX), I don't know any other fourplex project. :(
You have a great business model. We ran the numbers, and this is what we came up with. Say we buy 10 fourplexes from you at $400k each. We will be paying $4,400/month in property management. That's a little steep to charge for managing brand new buildings in our opinion. Also, is property tax around 2.5% for those buildings?
There are 10 year term loans available so the note does not come due until 10 years in. The amort. is typically set at 25 years. You can land a longer term loan sometimes from other than banks but the interest rate that is fixed will rise to in the 5's. The higher debt service affects the COC you are getting as the spread is smaller.
Everyone plays in a different space. I do not like the small buildings 2,3,4 units etc.
The reason I do not is they are not scalable. I have to also depend on other investors around me to keep up their properties. I can make my building look like a mansion but the potential tenants if they have to drive by other buildings not as nice they won't rent there. I speak from experience on this owning 5 quads for 20 units.
A larger complex you control the whole street and complex, the tenants that are renting there, and the upkeep of the look and feel of your investment. You are not as open to outside forces affecting your investment.
COC can be double digits between 15% into the 20's for the right property.
I would encourage you to research and decide what the right next step forward is for you and your investing. Could be 4 plexes or could be large apartment buildings or could be something all together totally different.
I talk to people many times where I tell them what I focus on might not be the right investment for them. It just depends on what goals the investor has and how they look at things.
The management fee on those projects are only 8%, not the typical 10% you find with many other management companies. Of course fees are almost always negotiable, and that's how we got it down to the 8%. However, you're free to discuss it with the local property manager to see if you can get a better "volume discount". I'd be happy to put you in touch with them.
My records show the local property taxes are 2.5%.
"COC can be double digits between 15% into the 20's for the right property."
There is pre-tax COC and post tax COC. I am talking pre-tax for returns and wanted to clarify.
Thanks
Joel Owens,
I understand. I didn't expect it to be post tax CoC. I believe my buddy likes your business model. He's more into value add.
We will have to make arrangement to travel to several targeted cities to check them out in the next couple of months. We'll connect with you and some other BP members as we travel out there. Hope you guys will show us around.
Unfortunately, no. You can exchange foreign property for other foreign property (i.e. non-domestic for non-domestic), but you cannot exchange U.S. property for foreign property (i.e. domestic for non-domestic).
Exeter 1031 Exchange Services, LLC and Exeter Trust Company4.826 Reviews
My buddy is Canadian and is here on a working Visa. So on the purchases that we've make this year (2013), he can can legally do a 1031 exchange in the future if I remove my name from the title now?
Actually, anyone can do a 1031 Exchange whether they are a U.S. citizen or otherwise. The issue is whether they ahve a taxable gain under U.S. Tax Law. If they are not a U.S. Citizen, they will most likely be required to comply with FIRPTA.
Exeter 1031 Exchange Services, LLC and Exeter Trust Company4.826 Reviews
I'm also Canadian (dual citizen) and originally from Calgary, Alberta. Where is your 'buddy' from? :)
Hi Marco,
He's from Vancouver and 100% white. He doesn't speak French. His wife is Brazilian so they're moving to her homeland. She will teach English there for a living. He's done working although he's trying to get a couple IT contracts before he leaves here just as a safety net. They estimate that their monthly living expense will be about $2,500/month, and that included renting a very sizable house. Natal is their destination in Brazil.
While I have your attention, I'd like to clarify a couple of things with respect to commercial lending. I understand that lenders are typically looking for a DSCR of 1.2 to 1.25. How do they determine the Total Operating Expenses? Is it based on the 50% rule or the Schedule E from the seller?
Bill Exeter,
I will have to read up on FIRPTA. I have seen it many times, but never read it thoroughly because it didn't impact me.
My experience is the bank will go by the actual records of the seller as to the performance of the property.
However the banks know what customary vacancy rates are for an area, market rents, operating and expenses, etc.
So if a seller has books that show 95% occupancy but the area is an average of 10% then the bank will use the average numbers. The bank isn't going to finance something that is out of the ordinary for the area and will take a very close look as to why that is. Usually the numbers or condition of the property spell it out.
If landlord is paying some utility I go 60% cost off current gross income regardless of the sellers numbers. It's so shameful when I look over many properties on LoopNet. You will see listings claiming to be 90% occupancy and a 12 cap. When you get into it the cap is 8.5 and occupancy is 85 etc. or worse.
I tell sellers to not waste people's time. I have very serious buyers I work with and do the heavy lifting. It doesn't make sense to spend a bunch of money on inspections and visits when the numbers are not as promised and the seller does not want to accept reality. The income numbers and the repairs needed are most critical. If after those things you can arrive at a fair price to both parties the rest is easier to negotiate and you start all the expensive items at that point.
One thing people tend to leave out as a factor in choosing an area to invest in is how favorable the landlord laws are. And sometimes thats on a county by county basis.
Here in Illinois, you could take 5 mos to evict someone in cook county.
To me, I would think that texas would be one of the top 2 or 3 states for investing. Seem like they have great cap rates on multifamily and great landlord laws. Also have an excellent economy bringing in more and more people as well.
re: Joel Owens
At what level do those loan example kick in?
Could I do the same thing with 100k? i.e. Buy a million dollar property? Or is that seller second financing only available once you start getting into the higher loan amounts?
Not that I'm in a position to do that right now. But it does make me think a little......
One thing people tend to leave out as a factor in choosing an area to invest in is how favorable the landlord laws are. And sometimes thats on a county by county basis.
Here in Illinois, you could take 5 mos to evict someone in cook county.
You said it Mike! I live here in beautiful sunny southern California, but it would be one of the last states I choose to invest in because of things like the pro-tenant landlord laws.
As I say, "Live where you want. Invest where it makes sense!"
Marco Santarelli, second that! I live in San Francisco. It cannot be more pro-tenant. Rent control. 60+% renter population with its super-voting majority. A very informed tenant pool and powerful tenant advocacy groups...