Go 4-Plex or stay with buy-hold SFRs? San Diego

Go 4-Plex or stay with buy-hold SFRs? San Diego

San Diego, CA · Member since 2013 · 55 posts · 12 votes

I am a fairly new (1 year) investor with 2 SFR investments in San Diego in addition to my primary. I am ready to pull the trigger on a fourth property which was going to be another SFR, but after discussing with my agent last night, he told me to at least look into getting a 4-plex.

Multi-family properties have always intimidated me I guess, as I have no knowledge about them, if I can afford one, or even how to find them here in San Diego.

Any advice is welcome.  Thanks!

0Reply
42 views

Most Popular Reply

Investor · Seattle, WA · Member since 2013 · 123 posts · 48 votes
12y

@John Yarenis  and @Joe P. are both correct: SFRs are awesome, holding period matters, and tailor your actions to your unique biz strategy.  

I have 2 SFRs, and they perform very well. I have zero intention to sell these. My favorite holding period is forever! :) If you need cash from a property, you can always layer a HELOC, 2nd mtg, or refi it. This is a tax-free cashout, whereas the sale could incur taxes (unless 1031'd) and will absolutely incur thousands of dollars in fees.

Nathanael, regarding your question of where to find the deals: my experience is that once a deal is on the MLS, it's too late. The property has been marked up to "retail" prices, and the potential ROI is not worth the effort.

To avoid this, become friends with wholesalers who are "in the know" for deals that are 'upstream' of the MLS. These deals have much better potential for meaningful ROI. To find those wholesalers, (1) start looking around BP for them and (2) go to a Meetup and/or REIA meeting.

See this reply in the discussion

23 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · Seattle, WA · Member since 2013 · 123 posts · 48 votes
    12y

    You achieve economies of scale with a multifamily.  There's only one roof, one location, and four units that are relatively similar.  

    Imagine having either 100 SFRs spread over San Diego, versus 2 50-unit properties.  The latter is much more manageable.  

    That's the magic of MF.  Put differently, you can simplify your life while growing your business.

  • Rental Property Investor · Phoenix/Lima, Arizona/OH · Member since 2012 · 4k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    12y

    Go for it!

  • Investor · Pasco, WA · Member since 2010 · 27 posts · 16 votes
    12y

    My advice is you need to learn learn learn. I would not take another persons investment advice blindly. If you want to be successful at investing you need to know everything you can about it to make informed decisions. Talk with people that have gone down the road you are thinking of traveling. Do you want to end up where they are?

    I would start with figuring out how to calculate your numbers on the properties you have. Then you have a way to compare to other investments.

    You also should consider your overall strategy. How long are you intending to hold these properties...are these the kinds of properties you still want to own 20 yrs from now or will you trade up etc...

  • San Diego, CA · Member since 2013 · 55 posts · 12 votes
    12y

    Thanks Andrew.  That all definitely makes sense.  I guess I'm looking more for information on where to find deals, how much I need to get in, etcetera.

  • San Diego, CA · Member since 2013 · 55 posts · 12 votes
    12y

    Joe,

    My SFRs I plan to have forever.  Already have one producing about 80% cash flow after only a year.  Are MFRs usually considered more temporary? (short or long-term)  Completely ignorant about it.

  • Real Estate Professional · Park Ridge, NJ · Member since 2014 · 42 posts · 6 votes
    12y

    @Andrew Kniffin is right about economies of scale, but @Joe P. hits a home run here when he talks about overall strategy.  What is your goal and your business plan?  The other thing to consider (from what I've read here) is that financing requirements for MFs are different than SFRs, but again as @Joe P. mentions, learn learn learn.

  • Sherman Oaks, CA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    12y

    http://www.loopnet.com/California/San-Diego_Apartm...

    To me this is a no brainer to take your agents advice seriously. If I could I would get this Old Town quad below under contract so fast it would make your head spin:)

    http://www.loopnet.com/Listing/18496502/2505-Jeffe...

    thanks,

  • Investor · Seattle, WA · Member since 2013 · 123 posts · 48 votes
    12y

    @John Yarenis  and @Joe P. are both correct: SFRs are awesome, holding period matters, and tailor your actions to your unique biz strategy.  

    I have 2 SFRs, and they perform very well. I have zero intention to sell these. My favorite holding period is forever! :) If you need cash from a property, you can always layer a HELOC, 2nd mtg, or refi it. This is a tax-free cashout, whereas the sale could incur taxes (unless 1031'd) and will absolutely incur thousands of dollars in fees.

    Nathanael, regarding your question of where to find the deals: my experience is that once a deal is on the MLS, it's too late. The property has been marked up to "retail" prices, and the potential ROI is not worth the effort.

    To avoid this, become friends with wholesalers who are "in the know" for deals that are 'upstream' of the MLS. These deals have much better potential for meaningful ROI. To find those wholesalers, (1) start looking around BP for them and (2) go to a Meetup and/or REIA meeting.

  • Investor · Seattle, WA · Member since 2013 · 123 posts · 48 votes
    12y

    @Matt R.  links to a 4plex on Loopnet in San Diego with a cap rate of 6.5%.  But note that the listed expenses on that link are only ~25% of gross revenue. 

    The general wisdom is that actual LT expenses (accruing for onetime expenses like roofs, boilers, and parking lots) run closer to 50-60% of gross revenues.  This would crater cap rate to ~3%.  That is not appealing, unless you're counting on huge increases in rent rates and/or ways to reduce expenses. 

    I don't know the SD market.  So I'm genuinely curious: what makes this a screaming good deal?

  • Accountant · Encinitas, CA · Member since 2010 · 62 posts · 33 votes
    12y

    @Andrew Kniffin 

    Just to throw in my $.02, I agree with you. I live in and love San Diego, but I cannot justify buying properties at a <5% true CAP rate. Has it worked in the past here ... absolutely! The appreciation has been nothing short of spectacular over the past few decades. But as they say in the investment world, "past performance does not necessarily guarantee future results."

    Some of the positives that come with that low cash flow are extremely low vacancy rates, generally low property taxes and expenses overall due to great weather, low crime, easy financing, and of course that high appreciation potential. So I am not saying that owning RE here is a poor choice, only that it doesn't fit into my business plan.

    John

  • Sherman Oaks, CA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    12y

    For sure this price would have to be less. I am throwing out as an example. Old Town is a very unique part of San Diego, its proximity to downtown and beaches and the vibe is unmatched. You can count on this to be in highest demand for decades. Force appreciation is going to be automatic. There could better deals, wholesale etc...  In a nut shell, it would be a privilege to own in Old Town. You should see the Victorians they restored. 

    Thanks,

    Matt

  • Investor · Honolulu, HI · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    12y
    Originally posted by @Andrew Kniffin:

    @Matt R.  links to a 4plex on Loopnet in San Diego with a cap rate of 6.5%.  But note that the listed expenses on that link are only ~25% of gross revenue. 

    The general wisdom is that actual LT expenses (accruing for onetime expenses like roofs, boilers, and parking lots) run closer to 50-60% of gross revenues.  This would crater cap rate to ~3%.  That is not appealing, unless you're counting on huge increases in rent rates and/or ways to reduce expenses. 

    I don't know the SD market.  So I'm genuinely curious: what makes this a screaming good deal?

    Long term capEx are not factored into NOI so they do not affect cap rates. Cap rates are set by market sales after the NOI was analyzed by an investor and then used cap rate comps to determine market value.

    Expenses can be considerably lower in mild climates like CA and expenses per sq are lower and rents per sq ft are higher than most areas.

  • Investor · Seattle, WA · Member since 2013 · 123 posts · 48 votes
    12y

    @Account Closed why would you exclude certain expenses when you are trying to calculate the operational profitability of an asset?  

    To me, the entire purpose of "Net Operating Income" is to determine the all-in ("Net") profitability ("Income") of an asset before considering its financing structure ("Operating").  

    If you exclude accruals for bigger expenses that happen less than 1x/year (capital expenses), then you are no longer capturing the essence of NOI.

    If you saw a 20-unit building being offered at a 11% cap rate (based on prior year's actual expenses), but over the next 5 years it needed new roof, new parking lot, and new HVAC systems, how would you value the accuracy of that asserted 11% cap rate?  

  • Investor · Honolulu, HI · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    12y

    That 11% is a made up number. A cap rate only looks at "operating" expenses against gross rents less v/c.  That is the definition of direct capitalization in real estate.  It tells you what the market is paying for  an income stream.   Any adjustments for anticipated capEx would NOT be capitalized but deducted "below the line" after market value was determined by using cap rate comps.  Is that clearer?

  • Investor · Cincinnati, OH · Member since 2013 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    12y

    @Nathaniel Donnelly a 4-plex isn't too much different from a single family home from a financing and operations standpoint. I'd say the learning curve for you is likely minimal since you already have  single family home/s. Once you get into 5+ units then it's a bit different but if you're looking at 4-plexes then I'd say you probably know most of what you need to know. 

  • Investor · San Diego, CA · Member since 2014 · 22 posts · 8 votes
    12y

    I like the idea of multifamily investments -- especially fourplexes to start out with. I find in San Diego the fourplex pickings are pretty slim (not a lot of fourplexes built for the size & population of the area) along with cap rates so low you'd be hard pressed to cashflow on them.

    That said, I'd be curious what places your agent has in mind and would definitely give an ear to his opinion.

  • Real Estate Investor · Salem, OR · Member since 2011 · 422 posts · 149 votes
    12y

    @Nathaniel Donnelly I think that advice is a over generalization. Make your choice based on the numbers. In some places multis make sense. In others SFR's make sense. Buy whichever makes the most sense to you. I can say that vacancy rate tends to be a lot higher in multi's compared to SFR's. Take that into account when your running your numbers. Best of luck expanding your portfolio

  • Brookfield, WI · Member since 2011 · 31 posts · 18 votes
    12y
    Originally posted by @Nathaniel Donnelly:

    I am ready to pull the trigger on a fourth property which was going to be another SFR, but after discussing with my agent last night, he told me to at least look into getting a 4-plex.

    I've owned five different 4-plexes, some larger apartment buildings, and many smaller properties.  We've also managed dozens of 4-plexes for others over the past 20 years.  In my experience, they the worst of all worlds -- you get all the problems of apartments, but not enough economies of scale to make it worthwhile.

    Apartments are more management intensive than single-families.  You start dealing with issues between tenants (noise, parking, etc.), building inspections, and common area maintenance.  This all costs time and money, but you only have 4 units over which to spread the burden.  As others have mentioned, economies of scale matter, but four units doesn't quite get you there.  Once you get to around 8-12 units, they start to make more sense.

    Apartments also tend to draw more transient tenants that single-families do. You'll be turning over units every 12-24 months, along with the maintenance, repairs, and vacancy periods that come with that.  With a single-family, your tenants are likely to be in the home much longer.

  • Sherman Oaks, CA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    12y
    Originally posted by @Roger Rouse:
    Originally posted by @Nathaniel Donnelly:

    I am ready to pull the trigger on a fourth property which was going to be another SFR, but after discussing with my agent last night, he told me to at least look into getting a 4-plex.

    I've owned five different 4-plexes, some larger apartment buildings, and many smaller properties.  We've also managed dozens of 4-plexes for others over the past 20 years.  In my experience, they the worst of all worlds -- you get all the problems of apartments, but not enough economies of scale to make it worthwhile.

    Apartments are more management intensive than single-families.  You start dealing with issues between tenants (noise, parking, etc.), building inspections, and common area maintenance.  This all costs time and money, but you only have 4 units over which to spread the burden.  As others have mentioned, economies of scale matter, but four units doesn't quite get you there.  Once you get to around 8-12 units, they start to make more sense.

    Apartments also tend to draw more transient tenants that single-families do. You'll be turning over units every 12-24 months, along with the maintenance, repairs, and vacancy periods that come with that.  With a single-family, your tenants are likely to be in the home much longer.

    These are great points. I would agree with all of them. The exception might be beach area SoCal quads. Think Melrose Place. Not to say you wouldn't have those issues just to a much lessor degree than average.Thanks, Matt

  • San Diego, CA · Member since 2013 · 55 posts · 12 votes
    12y

    All,

    Thank you so much. This is all great information!

    As @Christopher Covell said, the pickings are pretty slim in SD, and I've been doing very well with my SFRs so far. I've also always been very apprehensive about the possibility of n'er-do-wells that 4-plexes seem to attract.

    I've always strived to be the type of landlord that helps the community improve by attracting the best possible tenants, paying extra for quality of living and keeping great curb appeal by paying for good landscapers, etcetera. It's always helped me get higher-paying tenants, which I have great relationships with.

    So after considering all the pros and cons from you all, I think I'm going to stick with what's working for now.

    Thanks again for all the help. Can always count on BP to find great people with great advice!

  • Real Estate Coach · Venice Beach, CA · Member since 2012 · 6k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    12y

    Are any of these properties you're finding actually giving positive cash flow? Or are you buying for appreciation?

  • San Diego, CA · Member since 2013 · 55 posts · 12 votes
    12y

    Honestly, I haven't gotten that far, but I hope it would be both.

    Here in San Diego, however, I entertain anything that I can at least break even regarding cash flow. I know that's not ideal, but my plan is very long-term, and equity and appreciation have done very well by me and many of my associates in the past.

    Would you agree with that?

  • Investor · San Diego, CA · Member since 2013 · 125 posts · 82 votes
    12y

    Escondido and City Heights were 2 areas in San Diego that made sense from a cash flow standpoint back in 2009 and 2010 when there was blood in the streets. Now I would challenge anyone to find a 2-4 that makes 8% cash on cash in SD county. Please contact me if you do and we can work some deals together. 

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.