Help me choose between 2 multifamilies

[Lin Yin]

Which one would have lower turn over and/or easier to fill vacancy?

Property 1: asking 619k. 3 family. 1 bed, 2 bed, 3 bed. Total 6 bed 3 bath.

Property 2: asking 650k. 4 family. 3X 1 bed, 3 bed. Total 6 bed 4 bath.

On paper the coc return would be exactly the same based on rent. Assuming location and condition the same what would you choose?

Location: small town (100k pop) in upper MA near NH border.

Thanks!