Of these 2 REOs, which would you pick?

[Jordan L.]

I've got two homes I'm eyeing. Both built in 2005. Location the same. One's 1900 sq ft home selling for 190k. Will definitely rent out for $1500 a month. Another is 2950 sq ft home selling for 220k. Will definitely rent out for $1700k but if you're willing to wait a month, you might get up to $1900.

While I know neither of the 2 fit the 2-50 rule, and not even close, if you had to, which one would you do?