4 lessons in Short Sales You should NEVER forget

4 lessons in Short Sales You should NEVER forget

Residential Real Estate Broker · Payson, AZ · Member since 2009 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes

This is in response to: Sharing Experiences Thread created by Charles.

If you're doing short sales, new to the game or just new to your negotiator I'm going to give you the most important lesson I've ever learned. This one lesson will literally save your business from being destroyed by liars, snakes and people that straight up just don't do their job.

Trust what I'm about to say as 100% truth, I have nothing to gain from sharing with you and I personally am currently in repair mode from having my business shredded to nothing but a stack of worthless files due to not realizing this lesson until it was too late.

My business has two really main important factors in ensuring success. They are having a great Realtor which fortunately, I have as well as a 'provable', 'successful' and 'knowledgeable' negotiator.

I'll go into another post regarding finding that one special realtor, for now, this is how to save yourself from the negotiator.

Your negotiator should have many key areas of expertise. Not only quality negotiating skills for you as an investor, not a realtor. We're trying to get profitable spreads on our deals, not shorts for retail prices. Having an experienced negotiator that understands this and is already successful in this is one really important key.

1.) Your negotiator should be able to 'willingly' share a few of his/hers other clients to you so that you can check their references and make sure they're accurate. At first, I thought this wasn't a good idea but now I realize that was a mistake on my part. There is nothing that will negatively affect the negotiator from doing this, especially if they are successful. Its not like you're going to be stealing business away from him/her, you're just checking the reference. I didn't do this before, but I can assure you, that I will not do business with any negotiator if they are unable or unwilling to provide references. Don't just take their perceived credibility or online social status for granted. It very well may cost you dearly. Even if they appear to be knowledgeable and are great to speak to over the phone.


2.) You're negotiator should be easily and readily accessible. This mean either by phone, email, text and even smoke signals if it means you've got open and constant communication with your negotiator. I've been fortunate to never have this issue until very very very recently where I'm working on being on the same page with my new negotiator(s). I'm confident in a successful outcome regarding communications but nevertheless, its vital, more than vital, its life and death that you have excellent communication skills with your negotiator. My previous negotiator(s) have all been extremely easy to reach. Its just tough to gauge what they tell you as truth and lie. We'll get to how to determine that a little later.

3.) You should receive constant, detailed and TRUTHFUL updates regarding your files. How often should these updates be? That's up to you. I know some professional negotiators are using software systems that allow you to login into their systems and be able to physically see the progress (or lack thereof) without having to bother the negotiator constantly. Another and more common way is to send out a weekly email with the updates. This is fine, but when its as generic/vague update that doesn't really tell ya much and its the same thing week after week after week after week, you need to have a talk with your negotiator.

There is no reason why your negotiator cannot update you with more specifics. Called Tuesday, spoke to a Mary, authorization uploaded, request for BPO done with Mary. Expected BPO time frame between 8/10 and 9/10. Will follow up in 3 days.

You think thats too much? think again!! An excellent update like this only needs to really come once a week right? Also, wouldn't an update like this seriously reduce the amount of time you spend calling and emailing the negotiator for updates. Trust me, if I got updates like that from my previous negotiator, I might have had a mancrush. I was just called 'high maintenance' the other day. Updates like this would make me seriously 'low maintenance' but again, I'm working with the new negotiator and working out all the kinks, especially after some of these devastating lessons that I've learned just recently.

4.) Verify, verify, verify!!!

What do I mean? Let me tell you a true real life story of two separate people. First guy. This guy has had several lost files to foreclosure. This guy has also NOT closed a single file with this negotiator and this guy does NOT personally know anyone else who has. Maybe this negotiator has successfully gotten approval letters for some people, but unfortunately, not a single person I referred to or know that has. Well, after being lied to for so damn long, this guys Realtor asks this negotiator for proof of any sort that the file will not get foreclosed on. See, this negotiator has claimed that they deal with specific people inside the bank and their communications aren't always uploaded into the banks system. They have more email communications. Ok, fine, no biggie right? WRONG.

See, this guys realtor is only asking for this information because the seller of the property and the listing agent(sellers agent) just got off the phone with the lender and it didn't go so well (not to my surprise anymore). The lender told them they had no info about the negotiator, there was NO short sale file open and the property was going to foreclosure shortly(I don't remember the exact time frame but it was soon enough that it created extreme panic) We needed verification that the negotiator did indeed have someone within the bank that they were communicating with regarding this file. We asked for it, it was promised to be given to us. Guess what, never seen the damn thing!!!

Another investor from Texas, who I took under my wing and willingly helped out with anything he needed was also getting the exact same treatment from the exact same negotiator, not surprising.

This investor dealt with the exact same problem, property was foreclosed on and the investor asked for proof of communication. Specifically a name and phone # to the person they are dealing with inside the bank so that the investor can verify that everything was ok. This was asked by the investor on Thursday, the negotiator agreed to it, then sent the investor an email with the files they had and the lenders 1800#'s :roll:

On Monday, the investor called the negotiator, obviously upset at this point. Had a few words amongst each other regarding the files(I wasn't on that particular call so I don't know exactly). Apparently, a few minutes later, after the negotiator has continued to fail to provide ANY proof that they have ANY communication with the lender regarding ANY of the files, the negotiator tells the investor he thinks its best they don't work together.

Get this straight, the negotiator has failed to do his job properly, failed to provide any proof of his job being performed properly and now is quitting on the investor? There is a name for that, unfortunately, this is a family forum and names that start with a B-move aren't allowed :wink:

So, the lesson here. Get a damn authorization letter yourself!!! Don't take the word of someone who literally holds the success of your business for granted. If not you personally, then make sure your agent has an authorization at least.

Don't abuse this though, you certainly don't want two negotiators. You simply want to call and check status if you don't don't feel you're being told the truth. I'm sure once you get some approval letters, communications with your negotiator improve or are great then it wouldn't make much sense to have to check on the negotiator but in the beginning, you better make damn sure of it!!!! Every single one of my issues would have been solved if I had done this to begin with. I would have known the previous negotiator was flat out lying and I would have pulled them before it was too late, saved countless business relationships and salvaged my currently damaged credibility due directly to this negotiators actions.

If you do nothing else, please do this. I can't promise you enough how many problems this will save you from. I literally have a hard time sleeping at night lately because of the mistakes that I made in putting too much trust in my previous negotiator caused many families to lose out completely when I could have saved them from this persons unprofessional approach to how they do business. Think to yourself, how would you deal with knowing that you could have at least done something to help them. The sellers got the sh1t end of the stick and they don't even know who was faucking them.

I could probably put another few down but I felt that these were so important that adding anymore might take away from the importance of these. If you take these lessons that I've personally learned and apply them, I'm sure other issues will quickly become non-existent or an easily found solution.

this email is not meant to slander anyone. Nothing I've mentioned about anyone(notice I never mention any names) involved is even remotely false. I know the people involved might see this and they will know I speak the truth and I can PROVE my truthfulness of the claims that I've stated today. This is not television and there are NO reenactments and all parties are guilty with no chance of being proven innocent. I've made some pretty serious mistakes that have caused horrible problems for families involved. Please don't let my mistakes affect the lives of those homeowners you work with.

I hope this was of at least the smallest amount of help to you.

11Reply
45 views

25 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Residential Loan Officer · Santa Rosa, CA · Member since 2010 · 17 posts · 4 votes
    16y

    Good advice about dealing with negotiators

    I sometimes forgot that not everyone has the same values as me and therefore you have to do your due diligence in order to protect yourself from being screwed.

    I hope for the best in rebuilding your reputation and business.

  • Residential Real Estate Broker · Orange County, CA · Member since 2010 · 41 posts · 3 votes
    16y

    Thank you for sharing your experiences, great information. It is absolutely crucial to be on the same page with the negotiator and ensure they are clear with your goals for the project. (A main one being not to let the property get foreclosed on)

    Communication is key in the business period. I find often people are hesitant to reply if they have nothing new to say. They don't get how someone will appreciate the reply even if it is just to say that they contacted the lender and were told it would be x amount of time for an approval or whatever the case.

    Thank you again for sharing the unfortunate experiences you had to assist others in their future dealings.

  • Real Estate Investor · Denver, CO · Member since 2008 · 47 posts · 22 votes
    16y

    Nick,
    Thanks for the candid and raw info. This will help me (and many others) immensely. It really sucks that the families that you were trying to help got the short end of the stick, but with this posting hopefully you are helping a lot more families make the best of a bad situation. It's great that you are taking this nasty situation and making a good lesson and business requirement from it - for all of us.

    Here's to bouncing back...

    Cheers,
    John

  • Real Estate Investor · CA · Member since 2009 · 138 posts · 19 votes
    16y

    Thanks Nick for not sugar coating this post and really opening eyes to this (It opened mine at least) I do hope you bounce back from this

  • Real Estate Investor · Easton, MD · Member since 2009 · 12 posts · 9 votes
    16y

    Wow, thanks for your candor and I hope you are able to rebuild your business post haste.

    Was your negotiator a BP member?

  • Residential Real Estate Broker · Payson, AZ · Member since 2009 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    16y

    the negotiator was and still is a BP member. Oddly enough, he has yet to post/defend these accusations.

    I know he's been on because you can view his profile and see when the last time he was on. I know he's reading everything I post.

    If I were this person, I would atleast make an attempt to explain myself. He very well couldn't say that I was lying because even he knows, I'm not.

    Makes you think though, if I were lying and flat out slandering him, you know damn well he would respond in a heartbeat. His silence is only proof that what I say is truth and nothing but the truth.

    We're going to find out by the end of this week whether or not I still have a business. This persons actions(or lack of action) has literally made my business rely on a single deal(that he didn't even complete in getting an approval letter). If I don't get funding for the deal tomorrow morning, I'm done. Literally done. Realtor will no longer be able to work with me because of his broker will pull all the other files and whats left of my credibility is gone with him, his broker, the other agents that we have deals with. The lifeline will be pulled tomorrow. A serious ripple affect that I doubt this person even thought of while he was literally screwing me over this entire time.

  • Brian LevredgePro Member
    Investor · Chattanooga, TN · Member since 2009 · 1k+ posts · 903 votes
    16y

    It is very unfortunate that this great advice has to come at your own personal expense as well as that of your family and other people you have helped in the past. For me, this only crystallizes that we should be able to have some forum or outlet here to post about people's/member's shady business dealings with others.

  • Menifee, CA · Member since 2008 · 194 posts · 46 votes
    16y

    Let me give you rule #1 in S.S. flips... Please NEVER EVER EVER forget this 1 simple rule when flipping shorts. This will save your A$$.... DISCLOSURE, DISCLOSURE, DISCLOSURE....... I had a negotiator at one point that could not get that concept..... 'nough said. And YES.... They DO need to give you constant, accurate updates. I have a negotiator now that handles da bizniss.... Please be careful out there folks. Too many dipstick think that what we do is bad, we need not add to the idiocy.

  • Menifee, CA · Member since 2008 · 194 posts · 46 votes
    16y

    Oh.... BTW motiv8td... Great post!!!

  • Rehabber · Glen Allen, VA · Member since 2008 · 45 posts · 28 votes
    16y

    Nick, any way you can shed some light on this specific situation or what this person did or didn't do?

    Clearly you were under the impression you were getting a service that was not in any way provided.

    As someone who depends largly on Realtors to bring in deals (similar to yourself) I fully comprehend how this could affect your business.

    We bring in about 5-10 agent deals a week mostly through referrals from other agents. If we did something wrong or dropped the ball in an area we are supposed to be "experts" I can only imagine the adverse affects.

    Keep fighting the good fight man and I hope things pick back up for you. If in anyway I can help let me know.

    Btw reply PM sent.

  • Residential Real Estate Broker · Payson, AZ · Member since 2009 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    16y
    Originally posted by Chris Jefferson:
    Nick, any way you can shed some light on this specific situation or what this person did or didn't do?




    Unfortunately I can't. I've been hearing through the grapevine(my realtor and a few other people that I've referred to him) that this person is putting together a 'defamation of character' lawsuit. Why would you tell people you're going to sue someone for this? Who knows.

    Odd though, how can you completely screw someone, then try to sue that person for TELLING THE TRUTH. I haven't slandered this person, I haven't lied about a single individual fact.

    Ultimately, if this person does follow through with a lawsuit, I truly believe it will hurt his business even further. Once people realize that this person will NOT do his job, but will also sue you if you have a problem with the lack of his obvious ability. I don't think too many people will want to take that risk.

    We'll see what happens. I don't suspect this individual will ever make an appearance on these forums trying to defend himself simply because this person knows damn well, I'm not even remotely exaggerating the truth. I've said it before, if someone were giving even a hint at wrong information about me, it wouldn't take 2 seconds before I defended myself and proved that they were lying.

  • Real Estate Investor · Branson, MO · Member since 2008 · 32 posts · 13 votes
    16y

    So... how'd you come out on that one deal you mentioned that HAD to be saved the 19th? Were you able to pull that one off Nick?
    I sure hate hearing what all you've been through. It is so unfortunate some don't have as strong a work ethic as they should... families lives are hanging in the balance here!

  • Rehabber · Glen Allen, VA · Member since 2008 · 45 posts · 28 votes
    16y

    Very suprised that this post hasn't gotten more attention. Would still like to see the other party involved in this defend their actions or show why what's said is untrue.

    Then again why would Nick even need to lie about it in the first place?

  • Real Estate Investor · Craigmont, ID · Member since 2009 · 564 posts · 239 votes
    16y

    If you have ever been on either end of a lawsuit you would know the worst thing to do is show your cards on a public forum. I do not believe Nick made a smart choice by venting in public even if he is "right"

    The other party would be STUPID to show their cards here if they are indeed planning a defamation lawsuit and think they have a good case.

    It matters not who is willing to show their cards here. The lack of participation by the other party does not show who has the better hand it just shows who is better at poker.

    Catch 22 situation at best.

  • Residential Real Estate Broker · Payson, AZ · Member since 2009 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    16y
    Originally posted by Sam M.:
    If you have ever been on either end of a lawsuit you would know the worst thing to do is show your cards on a public forum. I do not believe Nick made a smart choice by venting in public even if he is "right"

    The other party would be STUPID to show their cards here if they are indeed planning a defamation lawsuit and think they have a good case.

    It matters not who is willing to show their cards here. The lack of participation by the other party does not show who has the better hand it just shows who is better at poker.

    Catch 22 situation at best.


    Sam, I'm a little surprised and worried by your response.

    I'm not venting, I'm simply educating and warning. If I'm not mistaken, you're experiencing the same thing with the same person. It seems as though you're defending that person with your response.

    Do you honestly believe by any of my posts, or in your case 'venting' that I've slandered, or anything that would be considered 'defamation' against this person?

    The only difference in this situation is I'm the only one who apparently has the courage to warn and educate others regarding this matter. Those, including yourself who I know for a fact that are experiencing the same thing seem to have their mouth shut regarding this.

    If I kept my mouth shut, and you didn't know any better and then put yourself unknowingly in business with this person, wouldn't you feel victimized when you could have been sufficiently warned if the handful of other BP members expressed their concerns and voiced their obvious long time negative experience.

    By me being the only one discussing this very serious matter does not mean I'm not better at 'poker'. It only means that I obviously give a sh1t about others. I could keep my mouth shut about the whole thing but if it means I get sued, at least I'm the better person in the whole matter.

    If it would please you and everyone else, I'll surely never use this forum to educate and warn others of very serious matters that could literally close their business down and keep my mouth shut as those handful of others, including yourself are obviously doing :roll:

    Funny how when I'm sought out for help, I don't clam up but when someone screws me and everyone else that I know that I referred to this person is screwed over and the homeowners involved lose out deeply, those same people seem to be under a rock scared of a little lawsuit.

  • Real Estate Agent · Jacksonville, FL · Member since 2009 · 100 posts · 39 votes
    16y
    Sam, I'm a little surprised and worried by your response.

    I'm not venting, I'm simply educating and warning. If I'm not mistaken, you're experiencing the same thing with the same person. It seems as though you're defending that person with your response.

    Do you honestly believe by any of my posts, or in your case 'venting' that I've slandered, or anything that would be considered 'defamation' against this person?

    The only difference in this situation is I'm the only one who apparently has the courage to warn and educate others regarding this matter. Those, including yourself who I know for a fact that are experiencing the same thing seem to have their mouth shut regarding this.

    If I kept my mouth shut, and you didn't know any better and then put yourself unknowingly in business with this person, wouldn't you feel victimized when you could have been sufficiently warned if the handful of other BP members expressed their concerns and voiced their obvious long time negative experience.

    By me being the only one discussing this very serious matter does not mean I'm not better at 'poker'. It only means that I obviously give a sh1t about others. I could keep my mouth shut about the whole thing but if it means I get sued, at least I'm the better person in the whole matter.

    If it would please you and everyone else, I'll surely never use this forum to educate and warn others of very serious matters that could literally close their business down and keep my mouth shut as those handful of others, including yourself are obviously doing :roll:

    Funny how when I'm sought out for help, I don't clam up but when someone screws me and everyone else that I know that I referred to this person is screwed over and the homeowners involved lose out deeply, those same people seem to be under a rock scared of a little lawsuit.



    Personally, I think it's very commendable and I would do the exact same thing given the situation. I would consider it my obligation.
  • Real Estate Investor · Denver, CO · Member since 2008 · 47 posts · 22 votes
    16y

    I agree with Audley. Doing the right thing is somewhat absent from many of the people I bump into in this field. Doing the right thing helps me sleep better.

    Still pulling for you Nick!

    Cheers,
    John

  • Real Estate Investor · Belvidere, IL · Member since 2009 · 169 posts · 65 votes
    16y

    I would have been very appreciative of someone like you more than once in the past when a business associate did not perform as promised. Unfortunately, when no one speaks up, the rest have to find out the hard way. I don't have a dog in this particular race, but as far as a lawsuit, its not libel or slander if its true and you can prove it.

  • Landlord · Seattle, WA · Member since 2010 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    16y

    Nick,

    Thanks for sharing this experience. It shows how even if your successful that there are some mistakes that can prove very costly. Pointing out areas of the business that are critical and wise choices need to be made can help many others avoid the mistake.

    I hope that you are able to obtain the financing you need so that some bridges can be mended and fewer people feel the pain of this experience.

  • Real Estate Professional · Schertz, TX · Member since 2009 · 72 posts · 30 votes
    16y

    As always, Nick great post!

    And that fellow investor you mentioned from Texas sounds very cool and handsome.

    I hope we can all recover and your situation with the realtor pulling all of their files is EXACTLY what I'm experiencing now with the job that the "person" did with my files. vI am confident we will pull through and start making some $$.

    At the sake of sounding too sappy, thanks for being a great mentor and great friend Motiv8d

  • Rehabber · Glen Allen, VA · Member since 2008 · 45 posts · 28 votes
    16y

    Had this post NOT been made, my business would have associated right around 20 files with this individual.

    This is how I feed my family (like most of us) and the affects of having my business crippled would be a bigger hit than we can afford to take.

    For that alone i'm grateful the post was made.

    I'm sure I'm not the only one that you helped here.

    From someone that's filed lawsuits on a few people nobody character has been slandered here. From what it seems anything said can be proven and I don't see anyones name mentioned anywhere in this post as well.

    Again, thanks for the heads up with the post. I'm sure I'm not the only one it helped. To those affected I hope your able to get everything back under control. The real loss isn't only to the investor in this situation, but more so the homeowner who had a little bit of hope that this would be resloved.

  • Valley of the Sun, AZ · Member since 2010 · 10 posts · 4 votes
    15y

    Does said negotiator reside in Florida?

  • Residential Real Estate Broker · Payson, AZ · Member since 2009 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    15y
    Originally posted by Ron H:
    Does said negotiator reside in Florida?

    yes, but don't a lot of 'negotiators' reside in Florida? :wink:

  • Contractor · Dana Point, CA · Member since 2010 · 44 posts · 9 votes
    15y

    As Chris said, "I didn't read any name" I have absolutely no idea who this negotiator is. I read these posts all the time. To slander him he has to prove you discredited him to lose business, I believe. Sounds like he did that well enough on his own. So without saying who he is, how can he prove any loss do to you? People working with him who are experiencing the same shoddy work don't need for you to tell them he's a bad apple, they already know...
    my .02

  • Flipper/Rehabber · Seminole, FL · Member since 2010 · 859 posts · 316 votes
    15y

    Im new here. Thx for the tips. Oh and this person is stupid if they think this thread is grounds for deff lawsuit

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.