Self-Storage Conversion: Should I stay or should I go now?

Self-Storage Conversion: Should I stay or should I go now?

Contractor · New Orleans, LA · Member since 2018 · 36 posts · 42 votes

So I've done residential real estate deals and seen some success. I work in construction, have done a lot of my own work and am a Civil Engineer by trade. In my hunt for another rental deal I stumbled upon an old warehouse for only $100,000. In my market, you can't buy any rental that's not in a rough neighborhood for less than approx. $150k. The building is two story with 4000 total sqft. I've always had a wild hair to convert an old building to loft style apartments but after analyzing the area and the necessary construction to convert I don't believe this is a viable option. 

HOWEVER, I thought of converting the property to mini self-storage. DISCLAIMER I have no experience in this field at all. I've never even rented a storage unit myself, only been to friends storage units. And I do understand the "stay in your lane" and "shiny object syndrome". However, I do believe it's worth pursuing even if it's just a learning exercise. 

So here's some rough numbers I came up with: 

$100,000 purchase (Definitely think I can get it cheaper)

    4000 sqft space resulting in 3000 sqft usable rental space. (I worked up a layout of common storage unit sizes trying to keep a good mix of units) 

    At 80% Occupancy I would be looking at roughly $2900 monthly rent. 

    To convert the property it would take roughly $50,000. 

    Property is zoned "Other Commercial". 

    So I would be in the property $150,000 with a monthly rent of $2900. 

    My biggest struggle right now is how to value the property to calculate Cap rate, etc. I typically utilize the BRRRR model on my residential property and have a very solid understanding of how to value the properties. On a property like this, I would still like to use the BRRRR model and pull my money back out but am unsure on how to value since it's so unique. I've also never dabbled in the commercial sector so I'm curious about the differences in financing as well.

    Any help is appreciated! 

    1Reply
    116 views

    Most Popular Reply

    Henry ClarkPro Member
    Developer · Member since 2020 · 4k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    6y

    @Kristian Conway

    Agree with above, to small to waste your time on storage.  Also the elevator would be the bottle neck.  You would need a whole new system, if you were basing your success on it and it would need to be a service elevator size.

    Would recommend you look at the following mix:

    Downstairs split into two 1,000 sq ft Contractor rentals.  (electrician, plumber, hvac, landscaping, etc).  We are looking at building these next in one of our storage locations.  They bring in more money per square foot than traditional storage, with less invest up front and ongoing.  If its a warehouse you should already have some bay/garage doors.  Just to rip out any excess material, then power wash.  Maybe a dividing wall and extra walk through door.  See if grandfathered in on sprinkler systems or don't need.  Also depends on outside parking and access.  To get a feel for the interest, you might "list" them on Loopnet or Craigslist and see what interest you get before you buy.  Or talk with a Commercial Real Estate person.

    Upstairs- make two or three large loft, retro apartments.  Strip barebones and paint all piping and ceiling black.  Put in three shower/commode/sink/kitchen, etc units.

    If this place has character and the right neighborhood.  I would also reach out to the local Micro brewery scene and see if someone is ready for the next size operation.

    For $100,000 depending on location, there is a business model there waiting to be found.

    See this reply in the discussion

    20 Replies

    Jump to latestLatest
    • Investor · Bentonville, AR · Member since 2014 · 759 posts · 379 votes
      6y

      @Kristian Conway That's a really small facility, especially for interior units. How would you provide access and manage it? I think you're going to have a hard time finding buyers at that small of a site, but I could be wrong there.

    • Investor · Avilla, IN · Member since 2013 · 796 posts · 769 votes
      6y

      Are you converting for exterior or interior accessible units? Id try to maximize the sqft usage and do exterior doors if possible. We just picked up two C class storage properties in NE Indiana and the appraiser valued them at a 10 cap. I'd think you'd in that range or slightly lower for a product like this if its done well. Id love to connect and see pics as you progress on this project. 

    • Contractor · New Orleans, LA · Member since 2018 · 36 posts · 42 votes
      6y

      @Zach Quick I was concerned about the size and amount of units. Whats an ideal size/number of units you would look for? However, I don't think finding buyers would be a huge issue as the site is centrally located in an urban area with a few new apartment complexes being built within walking/short drive distance. The units would all be interior units and I had planned to use a key fob system to provide access through one main door. I've included this cost in my rehab numbers as the access and security are high cost items but are also high priority of course. I would self-manage at first to work all the kinks out and then work in systems to remove myself from the process. 

    • Contractor · New Orleans, LA · Member since 2018 · 36 posts · 42 votes
      6y

      @Brandon Hicks This property has a brick exterior and a really solid shell so I don't think exterior doors would be feasible. That's a great idea and a great use of space though! Do you typically use that method on metal-sided structures? I'd love to connect and hear more about your properties!

    • Investor · Avilla, IN · Member since 2013 · 796 posts · 769 votes
      6y

      @Kristian Conway

      Makes sense and I like the idea you’ve posted above with the key fob.

    • Investor · Bentonville, AR · Member since 2014 · 759 posts · 379 votes
      6y

      @Kristian Conway Hard to answer on size, technically they come in all shapes and sizes, I wouldn’t want something that small personally.

      Be happy to look at your proforma to see if missing anything #’s wise.

      You mentioned two stories, does it have an elevator?

    • Contractor · New Orleans, LA · Member since 2018 · 36 posts · 42 votes
      6y

      @Zach Quick It does have an old elevator but it would need replaced. That's another thing that I think may disqualify this property as even with an elevator that could be a headache for clients. I did try and be thoughtful in unit design and incorporate the large units on the first floor as you wouldn't want a couch on an elevator lol. 

      Do you have a cutoff on amount of units that you deal with?

    • Investor · Bentonville, AR · Member since 2014 · 759 posts · 379 votes
      6y

      @Kristian Conway yeah I think once you price in the cost of an elevator being replaced you will walk.

      Not sure it matters as everyone’s wants are different but really a minimum 30,000 sq ft for me to have interest.

    • Henry ClarkPro Member
      Developer · Member since 2020 · 4k+ posts · 4k+ votes
      6y

      @Kristian Conway

      Agree with above, to small to waste your time on storage.  Also the elevator would be the bottle neck.  You would need a whole new system, if you were basing your success on it and it would need to be a service elevator size.

      Would recommend you look at the following mix:

      Downstairs split into two 1,000 sq ft Contractor rentals.  (electrician, plumber, hvac, landscaping, etc).  We are looking at building these next in one of our storage locations.  They bring in more money per square foot than traditional storage, with less invest up front and ongoing.  If its a warehouse you should already have some bay/garage doors.  Just to rip out any excess material, then power wash.  Maybe a dividing wall and extra walk through door.  See if grandfathered in on sprinkler systems or don't need.  Also depends on outside parking and access.  To get a feel for the interest, you might "list" them on Loopnet or Craigslist and see what interest you get before you buy.  Or talk with a Commercial Real Estate person.

      Upstairs- make two or three large loft, retro apartments.  Strip barebones and paint all piping and ceiling black.  Put in three shower/commode/sink/kitchen, etc units.

      If this place has character and the right neighborhood.  I would also reach out to the local Micro brewery scene and see if someone is ready for the next size operation.

      For $100,000 depending on location, there is a business model there waiting to be found.

    • Jon KellyPro Member
      Investor · Bethlehem, PA · Member since 2016 · 929 posts · 951 votes
      6y

      @Kristian Conway, I would double check with zoning to make sure you can convert to self-storage, even though it's listed as "Other Commercial." I'm going through a similar process now. I purchased a 3-unit: 2 apartments upstairs and large commercial space downstairs. It was zoned commercial, but only allows a "store." I'm in the process of applying for a variance for change of use to self-storage. 

      Also, look into other local facilities. See what their average size units and prices are. Reach out to them as a prospective tenant to see if there is a waiting list. That will give you a sense of interest for self-storage. 

      @Henry Clark provided awesome ideas that you should consider. The great thing about a space like this is the possibilities are endless. Just need to decide on what's best and get started! 

    • Real Estate Agent · Princeton, NJ · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
      6y

      @Kristian Conway - Definitely self shop storage in the nearest 5-10 miles before embarking on this project. I used interior access only storage in a dense center city at like $50/mo for a 10x5x8 tall. It took me hours to unload my small uhaul using the elevator and their free rolling carts and hiring the homeless guys who lived in the climate controlled units. In easier access areas almost everyone can drive up with their uhaul and directly unload into the unit which makes thin one story buildings very popular. Imagine if you’re paying movers $30-60 per hour. A marginally cheaper storage unit with a huge time waste by poor access won’t cut it. Successful Self storage is almost exclusively on or near major roads with available signage. Otherwise why expect you would have greater than 50-70% occupancy unless you marketed heavily to nearby apartments.

    • Contractor · New Orleans, LA · Member since 2018 · 36 posts · 42 votes
      6y

      @Henry Clark That's some great advice! I hadn't even considered the possibility of contractor rentals but that is definitely something to think about! I know this has several variables but whats a good rule of thumb for a contractor rental? Do you charge by sq/ft or do you have another pricing convention? 

      @Jon Kelly Thank you that's some great advice! 

      @Natalie Schanne I appreciate the insight! I've never used one myself but that's super helpful and I can see how that would be an issue. The benefit you have of being centrally located can almost be entirely offset by the lack of viable access. 

      I think I am going to pass on this individual property due to some of the factors we've discussed (elevator and size) but also due to the location and site logistics. The site it is located on is some what landlocked by other properties and would not be ideal for any other alternatives discussed. However, there's been some great ideas presented and I am definitely going to keep my eye out for a similar opportunity!

    • Henry ClarkPro Member
      Developer · Member since 2020 · 4k+ posts · 4k+ votes
      6y

      @Kristian Conway

      Around here $.85 to $1.00 per sq ft per month. NNN to be discussed by you.

      Look up Kansas City Contractor garages and look at their set ups.

      Contractors don't want top road frontage.  They prefer off the grid, but close to the neighborhoods.

      Good luck.

      Always make an offer if it has value. You said maybe $100,000.  Ask for:

      a.  $60,000

      b.  $40,000 and then $40,000 no interest in 5 years.

      c.  $80,000 if they replace and update the elevator to your specs.  etc.

    • South Bend, IN · Member since 2015 · 180 posts · 93 votes
      6y

      @Kristian Conway Great thread. I have a 4 unit around 5000sqft exactly as you described. 3 apartments upstairs and one unfinished downstairs. Currently the downstairs has a carpet guy in it but is way under market rent. I plan to list it to see if any other contractors are interested. Then based on feedback I would consider splitting it into two smaller units. Ill note that the downstairs has a garage door built into it on mine. Perhaps food for thought there if you do decide to buy it and rent to contractors.

      For our posterity Ill 2nd @Jon Kelly. My building is also zoned commercial and zoning disallows for self storage here.

    • Paul MoorePro Member
      Commercial Real Estate Fund Manager · Lynchburg, VA · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
      6y

      @Kristian Conway, if you want to get into self-storage, I would take my time and learn the business first. Scott Meyers is your man to teach that to you!  You could learn enough in 3 days to help you make a much better decision.  Feel free to connect directly if you'd like to get my special report on self-storage which will give you a quick start, but it will certainly not be adequate to get you to a decision point. 

    • Contractor · New Orleans, LA · Member since 2018 · 36 posts · 42 votes
      6y

      @Henry Clark I appreciate the input, that's some great info! I also love the statement "Always make an offer if it has value." That's something that was eating at me honestly. 

      @Aaron Linden Thanks for pitching in! What's the location of your property like? Also how do the tenants access the upstairs units? 

    • South Bend, IN · Member since 2015 · 180 posts · 93 votes
      6y

      @Kristian Conway It is in a B- residential area on a double sized lot. The garage door is off the main 2 lane street. There is an interior stairway for the residents to access their apartments.

    • Ronald RohdePro Member
      Attorney · Dallas, TX · Member since 2016 · 5k+ posts · 2k+ votes
      6y

      is this area growing? What do the neighbors look like? 

    • Contractor · New Orleans, LA · Member since 2018 · 36 posts · 42 votes
      6y

      @Ronald Rohde The area is growing. There's a new apartment complex a few blocks away and they are breaking ground on another nearby. The property has a used car lot on onside, a small apartment building on the other and a duplex in front of it. All the apartments are C class properties and have a lot of C clientele that hang around outside. I'm pretty picky about area so this kinda turned me off of the property. 

    • Ronald RohdePro Member
      Attorney · Dallas, TX · Member since 2016 · 5k+ posts · 2k+ votes
      6y
      Originally posted by @Kristian Conway:

      @Ronald Rohde The area is growing. There's a new apartment complex a few blocks away and they are breaking ground on another nearby. The property has a used car lot on onside, a small apartment building on the other and a duplex in front of it. All the apartments are C class properties and have a lot of C clientele that hang around outside. I'm pretty picky about area so this kinda turned me off of the property. 

      I don't know if C class tenants pay a lot for storage. It would concern me.

    Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.