Should I use 30 yr or 15 yr loan for my rental properties?

Should I use 30 yr or 15 yr loan for my rental properties?

East Peoria, IL · Member since 2014 · 39 posts · 9 votes

I have a question regarding which loan to use for my rental properties. Here is some background on me. 

I am 51 years old and am just beginning my real estate portfolio. I have a good paying, secure job making 6 figures and I don't spend much money. I have a mortgage payment on my house (15 yr loan) and have 12 more years to pay it off. My goal is to get between 3000 to 5000 monthly passive cash flow within 5-7 years. I've looked at turnkey investing and local investing and have decided to start with local investing because I will get higher cash flow doing local. I have a friend who is realtor and she is quite knowledgable about real estate investing and in fact finds homes for investors, brings contractors in to do rehabs and has a team that does property management. 

I have just gotten an appraisal on my primary home and am waiting the results although it should come in around 60000-70000 to use as HELOC. I also have a non retirement account worth about 65000 that I have set up so that it is attached to my checking account if I need it for anything real estate related. In addition, I have a 401k worth around 65000 but am not sure I will use that for real estate. I have other retirement accounts that I won't be using as I don't want to be taxed when I withdraw money from them.

My hometown bank gives a maximum 4 mortgages per person and I've already used one up for my primary so I have three mortgages left with them. I'll obviously need to find other ways to purchase more properties. 

The price range for my purchases will be between 40000 and 80000 (I live in central Illinois) and I've noticed some homes in this range are already rehabbed and some need rehabbing. I look at both groups. Between the realtor and friends who live in the city I'll be purchasing in, they can help me to determine good neighborhoods....I'll be able to determine this too as I grew up in a small town right outside of the city I'm purchasing in. 

Anyway my question is this.....due to my age at starting out, I'm wondering if I should use 30 year loans or 15 year loans. I can understand if I was 20 to 30 years younger I would be using 30 year loans all the way. But now that I'm older and hoping to retire within 7-10 years, I'm wondering if I should use 15 year loans and get the houses paid off and then have full cash flow from all the homes. This would also help with not having to purchase so many homes before I retire as I would get that full amount of monthly cash flow for each home. I figure I'll need at least 10-15 homes to get to my monthly cash flow goal but I see two different methods to attain this.....get the homes paid off (fewer purchases and I'll be helping to pay off the loan) or use 30 year loans (more purchases but I will not be helping to pay off the loan). 

Any thoughts and advice would be great!

Libby

0Reply
90 views

Most Popular Reply

Investor · Boston, MA · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 3k+ votes
8y

@Thomas S. Thanks for taking the time to respond to my question. 

I get the theory and see where you get the 2:1 ratio, but I have some issues with the math. 

1. If we call investing at 10% the opportunity return and paying the mortgage (5%) real return, due to the time value of money formula having five variables (Present Value, Future Value, rate, number of periods, and payment) the ratio of opportunity to true return cannot stay constant at 2:1. The closer the interest rate is to the opportunity rate and shorter the period of time, the lower the ratio, due to compounding interest. 

For example. If we take $100 payment and the Opportunity rate (10%) and mortgage rate (5%) and compound them over 15 periods, the future values (FV) are:

FV Opportunity= $3,177 and FV True=$2,158 or a ratio of 1.4: 1

If we change only the true rate to 7.5% the ratio drops to 1.2: 1

To get a ratio of 2: 1 in this period the Opportunity rate has to be 11.5% and the true rate 2.5%. 

If you change the period to 20 and keep the rates at 10% and 5% the ratio goes up to 1.7: 1. 

So like @Joe Splitrock pointed out, the difference between the mortgage rate and the opportunity rate is what drives the investment decision along with how long you hold the asset. 

Simple single period calculations like ROI can't capture the impacts that compounding has on an investment. That is where Discounted Cash Flow, IRR, MIRR, come in to play.

See this reply in the discussion

20 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Member since 2016 · 13k+ posts · 12k+ votes
    8y

    Maximum cash flow will be realised with 30 year loans. Take any positive cash flow and invest it in income funds to increase income even more. A income fund will comfortably generate 8-12% returns annually where as paying down a mortgage is only going to save you 4% (mortgage interest rate).

    Parking excess cash in a property is buying cash flow at a cost of $2 for every $1 returned and is at risk if the markets turn. 30 yr mortgage's and investing cash outside of real estate will generate maximum income if you are not interested in purchasing additional properties.. 

    Equity reduces your return on investment it does not increase it.

  • Allentown, PA · Member since 2016 · 515 posts · 404 votes
    8y

    @Libby Baugher

    Personally, I am a big believer in using real estate for its optimum capability, which is....A Tax Shelter Haven. Once your properties are paid off, your properties become assets rather than liability. Uncle Sam loves taxing you for your assets. So why give him a chance to tax you what you work so hard for?

    A 30 year mortgage puts you in the game where you can write off interest rates and other real estate associated expenses. A 30 year mtg keeps cost low in essence. For example, lets say the mortgage on a property is 1K with a 30 yr mtg, that same mtg doubles to 2K if its a 15 year right? What if one day, your tenant decides to not pay you for 6 months? The mortgage company is still going to ask for their money. While you are getting things sorted out with your tenant, which mtg term is easier to handle?  6K of back mtg payment with the 30 yr or 12K of back mtg payment with the 15 yr?

    Besides, you want to have as much cash free to yourself to be able to invest in other properties. You can free up cash easily with a 30 yr loan than a 15 yr loan. 

  • East Peoria, IL · Member since 2014 · 39 posts · 9 votes
    8y

    Wow, thanks guys! That all makes so much sense! Now I’m wondering if I should change my primary mortgage from 15 year to 30 year. 

  • Rental Property Investor · East Wenatchee, WA · Member since 2014 · 10k+ posts · 16k+ votes
    8y

    I analyze each on a case by case basis.  Biggest factor for me is overall goal and interest rate difference.  I don't want mortgage payments forever, so I like shorter terms. The amort difference is amazing. One went from principal paydown of $230/mo while a 30 to $1200/mo on a 15.  My 'cashflow' dropped $300/mo, but balance sheet rose $1000/mo. Case by case. This was in 2012 when the 15yr rate was 30% less than a 30.  Check the rate difference.

    If the rate difference is greater than .5% and I don't need every dollar of cashflow from doubling your til death, I mean mortgage,  I'll do a 15. Sounds like you don't need every dollar of payment savings.

    In your market I'd be tempted to buy for cash at a discount and refi later if needed.  I couldn't see using one of my 3 remaining loans on something so small. What if a $200,000 beautiful quad comes along right as you max out to 4 and your burdened with $40k loans.  Aren't those hard and expensive to get in the first place?

    Anyway, I've paid off a lot of 6% resi loans and commercial loans that were bothering me.  I've never looked back and wished I still had 15 years left, but that's just me. When a 15 pays off, a 30 still has about 65% to go.

    And the tax benefit argument of keeping loans forever is bogus.  The 'return' is negative 70%!

  • Member since 2016 · 13k+ posts · 12k+ votes
    8y

    @Steve Vaughan

    Lost returns on money in real estate outstrips all advantages. Parking dead cash in real estate is really only hoarding. Libby should not be choosing to invest for a 4% return by paying down a mortgage when income is of paramount importance.

  • Rental Property Investor · East Wenatchee, WA · Member since 2014 · 10k+ posts · 16k+ votes
    8y
    Originally posted by @Thomas S.:

    @Steve Vaughan

    Lost returns on money in real estate outstrips all advantages. Parking dead cash in real estate is really only hoarding. Libby should not be choosing to invest for a 4% return by paying down a mortgage when income is of paramount importance.

    You are all welcome to still have mortgage payments well into your 80s if you want to. No skin off my ....

    I have both so was sharing my experiences. If she doesn't care, probably no need for you to come back to me and say again what you've said a thousand times already, Thomas.

  • Rental Property Investor · Durham, NC · Member since 2016 · 7k+ posts · 7k+ votes
    8y
    Libby Baugher I swear I just commented on this. Start with 30 year then mix in 15-25 year as you get older. Steve Vaughan I think Thomas is closer to 10k times of saying the same thing. I’m with you I have no desire to have debt til I die
  • Flipper/Rehabber · Crown Point, IN · Member since 2009 · 482 posts · 216 votes
    8y

    Libby,

    Have you ever thought about using your 401k or your non retirement account to flip properties? This would generate cash for your retirement or cash to purchase rental properties. Then you don't need to take out a mortgage. Setting up a self directed IRA might work for you as well. A 1031 exchange might be worth looking into too. I won't explain how all of that works right now, but flipping properties and putting the money back into a retirement account, would help you build wealth for your retirement. Just some food for thought. Best of luck to you.

  • Investor · Boston, MA · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    8y

    @Libby Baugher It depends when you want to retire and how much money you'll need. The sooner you want to retire the more cash flow you'll need in the present, so a 30yr would work better. The later you plan on retiring the better a 15 yr looks. You can always turn a 30 yr mortgage into a 15 yr, but you can't turn a 15 year mortgage into a 30. The difference in rate, as @Steve Vaughan mentioned, is the 'price' you pay for the option of paying later. 

    @Thomas S. Honest question, I've heard you say "buying cash flow at a cost of $2 for every $1 returned" On the surface that looks like a ROI of 50% ($1 returned/$2 invested), but I'm curious to how you arrived at that ratio.

  • Aurora, CO · Member since 2016 · 158 posts · 118 votes
    8y

    @Libby Baugher, Personally I think the question shouldn't be 15 vs 30 years. The question should be what is your GOAL with real estate investing?

    Are you looking to supplement your 401k/Pension? Or are you looking at it being your only retirement vehicle? How much stress/work do you want upon retirement? What is your retirement $ goal?

    If you are looking at building up your portfolio to the largest, fastest with the most risk/leverage then a 30 year mortgage is the route to go. You can cash flow which allows you buy more etc etc. This has been mathematically proven to give you the 'best' return on money.

    The down side to a 30 year is you will always be in debt. You will always have to keep your real estate machine running in close to top performance, this will add stress in later years. When you get larger to reach your goal eventually you are going to have to either take over full time (so much for retirement), or hire someone (PM). If that happens you then add another point of failure in your business model. Plus you are giving the bank even more money for longer periods of time.

    So we circle back around to the original question. What is your GOAL with real estate? When you clearly define your goal (not 'be financially independent') you can start to tailor your strategy to meet that goal. And a 15 vs 30 should be one aspect of that strategy. 15 v 30 should not define your strategy or goal.

  • Joe SplitrockPro Member
    Moderator
    Rental Property Investor · Sioux Falls, SD · Member since 2015 · 9k+ posts · 18k+ votes
    8y

    @Brian Adzadi your payment does not double when going from 30 years to 15 years. For example, I was quoted 5.25% interest rate this week on a 30 year loan. If I change the term to 15 years, my payment would be 1.45 times more than a 30 year loan and I pay it off in half the time. 

    A tax deduction is a generally a good thing, but intentionally taking on debt to get a deduction doesn't make sense either. Assuming you were in the 30% tax bracket, for every dollar you pay of interest, you would get $0.30 back, so you are still paying $0.70 on the dollar. Not a great investment. I can do better than the IRS. Send me $1000 and I will send you back $800. 

    With a 15 year loan, you will still have mortgage interest deduction, only a shorter pay back period, so the deduction ends after 15 years. Many people are ready to exchange properties up to larger properties by that point, so having a paid off property gives you more equity to work with. Even if you keep the property, you could pull cash back out through refinance.

    @Thomas S. mortgage rates are no longer 4%. I was quoted 5.25% this week for 30 year investment property. As rates increase, the savings of considering a 15 versus 30 year loan increases. You mention an income fund will generate 8-12% returns. Are you referring to mutual funds, index funds or something else? Just curious what investment vehicle you believe safely yields these type of returns. I mention safely, because risk plays into this. Avoiding interest on a loan is a guaranteed return, so some people chose reduce risk over maximizing return. 

    @Steve Vaughan I was also able to grab a couple 15 year loans back in 2012 that had way better rates than the 30 year loans. Those two properties are ten years away from pay off. The house I purchased two years ago still has 28 years left. I always struggle between the choice of faster payoff with less cash flow versus higher cash flow and longer term. 

    @Libby Baugher at your age, I would not refinance my persona home into a 30 year loan. I would focus on paying that off, so your living expense is lower. Also, there is no home mortgage interest benefit with the new tax code, so better to finance rental properties and have your personal residence free and clear. If you can cash flow with 15 year loans, that may be the smart move. You will be 66 in 15 years, so not sure you want to have mortgages much later than that anyways. Look at the options. There is no right or wrong answer, despite what some opinionated people have to say.

  • Australia · Member since 2018 · 9 posts · 8 votes
    8y
    This is some great information
  • Member since 2016 · 13k+ posts · 12k+ votes
    8y

    @Bill F.

    "buying cash flow at a cost of $2 for every $1 returned"

    When a mortgage is at 5% and cash can be invested for a return of 10% a investor is passing on a potential two dollar return to save one dollar on a mortgage. This equates to a net loss of $1 on your investment.

    $1 in cash flow costs a investor $2 in lost opportunity value.

    To show how this impacts cash flow you assume 100K in dead equity is worth $833/month. This is the opportunity value at 10%.  If you paid yourself that 10% return on your cash that it should be earning you would deduct that $833 first from your rental income the same as you would be deducting your mortgage payment. From this you can see that debt free properties of any significant value are probably earning no real return since the value of your equity is eating all the income.

    This is a ultra conservative approach to real estate investing that in reality earns very low ROI.

  • Investor · Boston, MA · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    8y

    @Thomas S. Thanks for taking the time to respond to my question. 

    I get the theory and see where you get the 2:1 ratio, but I have some issues with the math. 

    1. If we call investing at 10% the opportunity return and paying the mortgage (5%) real return, due to the time value of money formula having five variables (Present Value, Future Value, rate, number of periods, and payment) the ratio of opportunity to true return cannot stay constant at 2:1. The closer the interest rate is to the opportunity rate and shorter the period of time, the lower the ratio, due to compounding interest. 

    For example. If we take $100 payment and the Opportunity rate (10%) and mortgage rate (5%) and compound them over 15 periods, the future values (FV) are:

    FV Opportunity= $3,177 and FV True=$2,158 or a ratio of 1.4: 1

    If we change only the true rate to 7.5% the ratio drops to 1.2: 1

    To get a ratio of 2: 1 in this period the Opportunity rate has to be 11.5% and the true rate 2.5%. 

    If you change the period to 20 and keep the rates at 10% and 5% the ratio goes up to 1.7: 1. 

    So like @Joe Splitrock pointed out, the difference between the mortgage rate and the opportunity rate is what drives the investment decision along with how long you hold the asset. 

    Simple single period calculations like ROI can't capture the impacts that compounding has on an investment. That is where Discounted Cash Flow, IRR, MIRR, come in to play.

  • Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2018 · 29 posts · 5 votes
    8y
    Originally posted by :

    @Libby Baugher at your age, I would not refinance my persona home into a 30 year loan. I would focus on paying that off, so your living expense is lower. Also, there is no home mortgage interest benefit with the new tax code, so better to finance rental properties and have your personal residence free and clear. If you can cash flow with 15 year loans, that may be the smart move. You will be 66 in 15 years, so not sure you want to have mortgages much later than that anyways. Look at the options. There is no right or wrong answer, despite what some opinionated people have to say.

    Wait, do you mean the interest deduction is gone because doubling the standard deduction will be more beneficial?  I'm pretty sure home mortgage interest is still deductible. It's just been set at lower limits.

    With that said, I agree that the OP should keep her original 15 year loan. The increase in cash flow will be marginal.

  • Joe SplitrockPro Member
    Moderator
    Rental Property Investor · Sioux Falls, SD · Member since 2015 · 9k+ posts · 18k+ votes
    8y
    Originally posted by @Roxie Kim:
    Originally posted by :

    @Libby Baugher at your age, I would not refinance my persona home into a 30 year loan. I would focus on paying that off, so your living expense is lower. Also, there is no home mortgage interest benefit with the new tax code, so better to finance rental properties and have your personal residence free and clear. If you can cash flow with 15 year loans, that may be the smart move. You will be 66 in 15 years, so not sure you want to have mortgages much later than that anyways. Look at the options. There is no right or wrong answer, despite what some opinionated people have to say.

    Wait, do you mean the interest deduction is gone because doubling the standard deduction will be more beneficial?  I'm pretty sure home mortgage interest is still deductible. It's just been set at lower limits.

    With that said, I agree that the OP should keep her original 15 year loan. The increase in cash flow will be marginal.

    You are right home mortgage interest is still deductible but with the higher standard deduction very few people will use it. I made the assumption that is her situation, but I shouldn't assume that. Regardless, I think keeping the 15 year on her primary residence makes more sense. 

  • East Peoria, IL · Member since 2014 · 39 posts · 9 votes
    8y

    Thanks for all the replies everyone! This is great information! I'll be keeping my 15 year loan on my primary residence. Now I just need to decide on the rental properties as I'll be purchasing my first two before this year is over. 

    Libby

  • George SkidisPro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Belleville, IL · Member since 2017 · 875 posts · 529 votes
    8y

    Length of mortgage is a personal decision. In 1993 I chose to only have 10 year notes and started my career. In 2003 there was an arson by a 15 year old girl and all my insurance was cancelled. The bank was for sale and needed to weed out a few commercial loans, Even after I acquired new insurance the damage was done. They called $500,000 in loans due at renewal. Thankfully I was in a very large equity position. With 15 or 30 year notes I could have lost everything. As it was I kept what I needed and sold enough property to pay off the rest.

    The first question you need to answer is CASH FLOW. How much can you do without it? Do you need to live off of the income or is it for a future use.

  • Rental Property Investor · Orange County, CA · Member since 2016 · 513 posts · 374 votes
    8y
    Libby Baugher I would buy a property each year debt free. Slower pace to creating a portfolio but your goal of cash flow will be achievable in seven years Less stress in life. You can easily do that. Real estate investing is a full time responsibility. Even if you have prop mgt overseeing your assets. You need to be ready to embrace the role of landlord once you acquire your first house You can easily do value add plays with your realtor friend. Buy property at a discount using cash and then refinance if needed. Since you don’t need cash flow from the house to survive, you can easily do 7/1 or 10/1 ARM product to save on interest cost and get your money out My two cents
  • Real Estate Broker · Cleveland Dayton Cincinnati Toledo Columbus & Akron, OH · Member since 2013 · 31k+ posts · 20k+ votes
    8y
    Originally posted by @Libby Baugher:

    I have a question regarding which loan to use for my rental properties. Here is some background on me. 

    I am 51 years old and am just beginning my real estate portfolio. I have a good paying, secure job making 6 figures and I don't spend much money. I have a mortgage payment on my house (15 yr loan) and have 12 more years to pay it off. My goal is to get between 3000 to 5000 monthly passive cash flow within 5-7 years. I've looked at turnkey investing and local investing and have decided to start with local investing because I will get higher cash flow doing local. I have a friend who is realtor and she is quite knowledgable about real estate investing and in fact finds homes for investors, brings contractors in to do rehabs and has a team that does property management. 

    I have just gotten an appraisal on my primary home and am waiting the results although it should come in around 60000-70000 to use as HELOC. I also have a non retirement account worth about 65000 that I have set up so that it is attached to my checking account if I need it for anything real estate related. In addition, I have a 401k worth around 65000 but am not sure I will use that for real estate. I have other retirement accounts that I won't be using as I don't want to be taxed when I withdraw money from them.

    My hometown bank gives a maximum 4 mortgages per person and I've already used one up for my primary so I have three mortgages left with them. I'll obviously need to find other ways to purchase more properties. 

    The price range for my purchases will be between 40000 and 80000 (I live in central Illinois) and I've noticed some homes in this range are already rehabbed and some need rehabbing. I look at both groups. Between the realtor and friends who live in the city I'll be purchasing in, they can help me to determine good neighborhoods....I'll be able to determine this too as I grew up in a small town right outside of the city I'm purchasing in. 

    Anyway my question is this.....due to my age at starting out, I'm wondering if I should use 30 year loans or 15 year loans. I can understand if I was 20 to 30 years younger I would be using 30 year loans all the way. But now that I'm older and hoping to retire within 7-10 years, I'm wondering if I should use 15 year loans and get the houses paid off and then have full cash flow from all the homes. This would also help with not having to purchase so many homes before I retire as I would get that full amount of monthly cash flow for each home. I figure I'll need at least 10-15 homes to get to my monthly cash flow goal but I see two different methods to attain this.....get the homes paid off (fewer purchases and I'll be helping to pay off the loan) or use 30 year loans (more purchases but I will not be helping to pay off the loan). 

    Any thoughts and advice would be great!

    Libby

    Go with a 30 year loan. If you get a 30 year loan you can always choose to pay it off on the 15 year schedule. If you run into a tough patch you have the freedom to scale back to the scheduled 30 year payments. With a 15 you are committed to the higher payments.  

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.