Multiplex Which type is better?

[Dustin Sifford]

I am looking in January to get my first Muliplex. Here are two types. One is more like an apartment style some have an HOA others do not. The other type is like a duplex or triplex some also have a small house on the property also. Could you tell me pros and cons and if you have a favorite type over the other. Lets assume both properties cash flow the same. Which style would you pick?

Apartment Style https://www.redfin.com/AZ/Phoenix/2827-E-Kathleen-...

Duplex with House style https://www.redfin.com/AZ/Phoenix/2849-W-Polk-St-8...