We've done something similar by offering local coffee, tea, snack baskets, bottled water, local pastries, and seasonal flavors (pumpkin spice, peppermint, gingerbread, etc.) which have been a big hit with much less risk involved. 

Eric,Pueblo has a lot to offer - Arkansas River Walk, Pueblo Reservoir, Arts Center, Family owned restaurants, Arkansas River activities, close to mountains, Colorado State University -Pueblo Campus, Pueblo Community College, home grown produce - known for peppers, and pumpkins, less traffic, driving distance to Colorado Springs and Denver.  

All year round North Conway and Jackson host monthly activities like Apple picking, Pumpkin carving, Host all the Major Holidays, Christmas, Thanksgiving, Easter, Mothers Day, Fathers Day, Halloween, Turkey Trots, Winter Ice plunges and more. 

@Sarah Kensinger Good idea on narrowing down my ideal guest/customer like the book The Pumpkin Plan talks about.

The one with particularly ugly brick(black, oranges, yellows) I matched the brick to Behr Pumpkin Butter and painted the wall around the fireplace as an accent and painted the rough cedar mantel something different, lighter creamy yellow.

Hey Pumpkin, I am Monkey.

I turn into a pumpkin around 9 and would still have to drive back to Rockland County.

It has little extra land for storage units or pumpkin patch to bump revenue a bit. 

And it is not about how many visitors you get pumpkin.

I know of one farmer, who i've been told, makes enough money in October/November from his corn maze and selling of pumpkins to pay all the bills for a year.