Primary or investing. 

Do you think we should structure it differently?

However, with strategic planning and assistance from experienced real estate accounting professionals, it may still be achievable for part-time investors.Primary Occupation: REPS is primarily tailored for individuals whose primary occupation revolves around real estate management and investment.

If the buyer certifies that they are going to use it as the primary resedence and it has a use and occupancy permit that alows use as a personal residence then I don't see why a lender would not. 

Each Church is different with respect to design but they are generally more expensive to renovate than some other structure types that may lend themselves better to a conversion.

We have sold it all (Except the Harley) including our primary residence that we had purchased and rehabbed ourselves over the past four years.

Lots of different issues to learn.  

that is the pro :-) we always forget the cons :a) current appreciation is very different right now, some CA property is getting hot but FL and TX experienced price reductionb) SF condo has depreciation, but san mateo condo has appreciation lolc) dont forget eviction, maintenance, tree falling, renter not paying, insurance increase a lot and property tax also increasethe risk/reward in rental today's market is not as enticing as 12 months ago.no more 10% appreciation with 7.4% mortgage rate.

This is something to keep in mind as you continue to expand your rental strategy and explore different platforms.

You will meet people from different walks of life that will give you different perspectives on real estate investing.