I even thought about selling mid construction.

Even when open, now you can still walk by.  

We haven't even touched on the safety and liability concerns.  

Unfortunately, after using the BP calculator, I'm not sure how we could make this just break even ( calculator is about -1200 a month).

My markets are very difficult I'm finding, even when looking at potential fixer-uppers, the numbers just don't work.

I know the SLC/Utah market has blown up since COVID and may even be considered overpriced at the moment but just wanted to hop on here and see if anyone has any suggestions on areas that would make sense?

Expect even bigger problems down the road.My suggestion is that you hire a professional property manager who knows how to handle this issue, along with the other 172 problems you are likely to face as a Landlord.

., I don't know if the town would even permit that and they don't return calls or emails. 

Even though I told our long term tenant about what we were doing and she thought she'd be okay with it, ultimately she didn't like all the different people coming and going. 

And even after all the wealth of information I've received from listening to the podcast shows, I feel like a chimp in a rocket ship!